My thoughts:
Suspect101 wrote:you are an evil scientist. in a game with the main villian as an evil scientist., which is why I would vote for you..... but... seeing as to where you have played the game, I think that you would not join a game with an evil scientist as the villian being an evil scientist yourself.
Just because his avatar features an "evil scientist", doesn't mean MM is an evil scientist in this game. MM cannot control what role he gets, and he is just as likely to have received a scum role as anyone else. Voting based on avatars might work for Day 1 random voting, but it is stupid later in the game when we actually have evidence to go on. If we want to find scum, we must examine the evidence on the table, not look for the person whose avatar looks like the game's villain. At the moment, I see no good reason MM is scum.
ace1217 and XenCobra need to post more or be replaced. It is quite likely that one of them is scum, but I'd rather have a discussion than blindly bandwagon an inactive in the hopes that they are scum. We can make a more informed lynch if we can get all 5 players posting.
As for Suspect, he either has no idea what he is doing, or is scum. I am leaning toward him being inexperienced, judging by his other games.