M:tG Planeswalker mafia - Town wins!

by **Victor Sullivan** on Fri Nov 11, 2011 5:00 pm

Makes me and edoc sounds like a celebrity couple. I call being the man in our relationship!

-Sully

by **freezie** on Sat Nov 12, 2011 2:06 pm

I'll reinstate my vote for sheep

Just because of the shameless bandwaggon, and the fact that this is slow moving..

by **slowreactor** on Sat Nov 12, 2011 4:24 pm

[quote="safariguy5"]Vote Count

pancakemix(1)- Rodion
Iron Butterfly(2)- Victor Sullivan, Leitz
Rodion(1) edocsil
doomyoshi(2)- doomyoshi, wildwilliam
Leitz(4)- drake_259, Iron Butterfly, jgordon1111, sheepofdumb (L-4)
sheepofdumb(1)- freezie
Victor Sullivan(1)- Iliad

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

Considering the speed at which this game is going - would you guys like me to implement a deadline? let me know please

by **edocsil** on Sat Nov 12, 2011 11:23 pm

slowreactor wrote:
safariguy5 wrote:Vote Count

pancakemix(1)- Rodion
Iron Butterfly(2)- Victor Sullivan, Leitz
Rodion(1) edocsil
doomyoshi(2)- doomyoshi, wildwilliam
Leitz(4)- drake_259, Iron Butterfly, jgordon1111, sheepofdumb (L-4)
sheepofdumb(1)- freezie
Victor Sullivan(1)- Iliad

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

Considering the speed at which this game is going - would you guys like me to implement a deadline? let me know please

DEADLINES D1 WAR ALWAYS GOOD!

Anyhow, Unvote vote Doom

by **sheepofdumb** on Sun Nov 13, 2011 4:27 am

freezie wrote:I'll reinstate my vote for sheep

Just because of the shameless bandwaggon, and the fact that this is slow moving..

I love to shamelessly bandwagon day one joke vote. As love as it doesn't bring the lynchee to -2 I don't see any harm. There's no reason to lynch and anyone who tries to hammer or brings a joke vote to -1 is suspect.

by **DoomYoshi** on Sun Nov 13, 2011 11:42 am

[quote="edocsil"
DEADLINES D1 WAR ALWAYS GOOD!

Anyhow, Unvote vote Doom[/quote]
how are day 1 deadlines always good? In a lot of cases they will lead to a lynch for no reason, or even worse, no lynch at all.

Shouldn't we allow some extra time for things to develop?

by **wildwilliam** on Sun Nov 13, 2011 6:24 pm

DoomYoshi wrote:
edocsil wrote:DEADLINES D1 WAR ALWAYS GOOD!

Anyhow, Unvote vote Doom

how are day 1 deadlines always good? In a lot of cases they will lead to a lynch for no reason, or even worse, no lynch at all.

Shouldn't we allow some extra time for things to develop?

agree, but deadlines get them going. also fixed your quote.

by **freezie** on Sun Nov 13, 2011 10:11 pm

sheepofdumb wrote:
freezie wrote:I'll reinstate my vote for sheep

Just because of the shameless bandwaggon, and the fact that this is slow moving..

I love to shamelessly bandwagon day one joke vote. As love as it doesn't bring the lynchee to -2 I don't see any harm. There's no reason to lynch and anyone who tries to hammer or brings a joke vote to -1 is suspect.

I never said I wanted a lynch..I am just trying to be the spark this dead motor needs.

by **Iron Butterfly** on Mon Nov 14, 2011 5:14 pm

jgordon1111 wrote:vote leitz

People who vote with no explanation always make me suspicious. It wasnt even a joke.

by **DoomYoshi** on Mon Nov 14, 2011 5:27 pm

Iron Butterfly wrote:
jgordon1111 wrote:vote leitz

People who vote with no explanation always make me suspicious. It wasnt even a joke.

Interesting point. I have never played with jgordon before. How many games have you played before jgordon?

by **jgordon1111** on Mon Nov 14, 2011 11:03 pm

first mafia game getting the feel of how its done,watching and reading what some of you have done in the past.getting a feel for who to watch close,from what i have seen in the archived games those that start pointing are those that need to be watched closest. and my vote for leitz was not bandwagon,it was to see who was quickest to jump in and then back out and start pointing,and who would stick to their guns on their vote.my vote for leitz was based on one simple thing he was among the first to cast a vote.

by **DoomYoshi** on Mon Nov 14, 2011 11:33 pm

Ok. Usually, as you vote, you should explain.your reasons for voting... For the first part of the first day, jokes are acceptable. Now we are, I hope, out of the joke vote phase. Unfortunately, we don't have much to go on.

You claim that those who point are the ones that need to be watched. Can you give an example where such a case has occurred?

by **jgordon1111** on Mon Nov 14, 2011 11:59 pm

not yet,but someone will emerge eventually,just waiting for now,to see who really tries to guide the the vote in a particular direction

by **rdsrds2120** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 1:48 am

WHOA. Forgot I was in this. Hi guys.

I''ll read over the pages real quick-like and try to get an idea of what's happening #-o

-rd

by **DoomYoshi** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 3:06 am

jgordon1111 wrote:not yet,but someone will emerge eventually,just waiting for now,to see who really tries to guide the the vote in a particular direction

Specifically what I mean is, in what archived mafia games have you seen this that has lead to you making this plan?

by **jgordon1111** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 5:33 pm

lol,my,my, what leading questions you have yoshi ! Are you secretly trying to confess something? And no I will not finger point myself thank you. I read from gangster to pokemon,and there is a pattern there. 8-)

That good enough to get the ball rolling yoshi

by **freezie** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 5:42 pm

Except pokemon game, people were foolish enough to be manipulated by the oh so easy to spot evil people :evil:

à

I keep my grudge on that game...

by **Rodion** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 6:23 pm

jgordon1111 wrote:lol,my,my, what leading questions you have yoshi ! Are you secretly trying to confess something? And no I will not finger point myself thank you. I read from gangster to pokemon,and there is a pattern there. That good enough to get the ball rolling yoshi

I don't get why you say you have data confirming some sort of trend and then refuse to back it up by showing us.

FOS Jgordon1111

by **Rodion** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 6:24 pm

freezie wrote:Except pokemon game, people were foolish enough to be manipulated by the oh so easy to spot evil people à

I keep my grudge on that game...

That game sucked! We never had an active majority to form a lynch, plus Fircoal would usually forget to use his night actions! :cry:

by **Iron Butterfly** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 6:43 pm

jgordon1111 wrote:first mafia game getting the feel of how its done,watching and reading what some of you have done in the past.getting a feel for who to watch close,from what i have seen in the archived games those that start pointing are those that need to be watched closest. and my vote for leitz was not bandwagon,it was to see who was quickest to jump in and then back out and start pointing,and who would stick to their guns on their vote.my vote for leitz was based on one simple thing he was among the first to cast a vote.

So it was not a joke vote.

You seem to imply there was a definate plan in voting the way you did.

Are you saying you beleive Leitz is Mafia?

by **wildwilliam** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 7:11 pm

jgordon1111 wrote:lol,my,my, what leading questions you have yoshi ! Are you secretly trying to confess something? And no I will not finger point myself thank you. I read from gangster to pokemon,and there is a pattern there. That good enough to get the ball rolling yoshi

I would like to know the pattern

by **jgordon1111** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 8:36 pm

one answer to one question I have no idea what leitz is,I already said i voted him because he was one of the first to vote,there were others ahead of him, and i have no opinion on what he is an can unvote him at anytime if needed. The games that i have read seem to go slow for a long time before anyone does anything,this just speed it up a little maybe.

by **jgordon1111** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 8:41 pm

Rodion you answered the first question with your second response about the pokemon game i believe 8-)

by **slowreactor** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 9:19 pm

Vote Count

pancakemix(1)- Rodion
Iron Butterfly(2)- Victor Sullivan, Leitz
doomyoshi(2)- doomyoshi, wildwilliam
Leitz(4)- drake_259, Iron Butterfly, jgordon1111, sheepofdumb (L-4)
sheepofdumb(1)- freezie
Victor Sullivan(1)- Iliad
DoomYoshi(1) - edocsil

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

Looks like it's starting to pick up again, if everything crashes again though I will probably implement a deadline o.O

by **wildwilliam** on Tue Nov 15, 2011 9:33 pm

Leitz wrote:Vote Iron Butterfly because there is no such thing as an iron butterfly

this is your only post......

unvote vote leitz

M:tG Planeswalker mafia - Town wins!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Re: M:tG Planeswalkers mafia [15/15] Day 1 Begin!

Who is online