Wandlore Battles Kalish out. Hogwart wins!

[dustn64]

Dustn : Since this could make you practicaly imprevius to death, I suggest that you investigate Kalish. Also, it would be kind of nice if you would share with us the results of your first two investigations.

When did I ever say I was a cop? In fact I don't have a wand. I tried to steal yours last night but I guess someone stole it before I did (or something of that sort).

[Koesen]

Why would a third party be interested in bodyguarding Dumbledore?

It fits the story. Fawks isn't a wizard and therefore belongs to neither side.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but Hagrid isn't a wizard either and he's town. All deatheaters are wizards and they're not town. Town and wizard are not synonymous.

I maintain that a third party bodyguard makes no sense. I am increasingly convinced that Kalishnikov is scum.

[freezie]

Sierra_leon replaces Got tonkaed.


Due to the number of spam post done by kwanton ( 3 or more posts in a row ) I asked him by pm why he was so much double posting.

His answer was, in my eyes, completly and abolutly absurd.

Therfor, I am replacing him. Unless many disagree. If you all wish, please tell me what you want me to do.

As for Kwanton, no more posts until that is cleared. 6 posts in a row was a bit too much for my taste, especially those that were repeating themself for nothing.

And I am serious..NO posts from you.

[Sierra_Leon]

Hi everyone! I'm a big fan of the Harry Potter books, so I asked freezie if I could sub for this game. I'm going to re-read this entire thread, but not right now because I've had a little too much to drink tonight (it's 3.30am here in the Netherlands). I'll post more when I wake up sober tomorrow (hopefully without a hangover), but for now I'll just confirm that when tonka said

However since i might as well help the town im Hagrid, who does not have any powers of note.

he was telling the truth.

[ga7]

Hmm... I'm not sure how to take these Kwan antics, which now remind me of Reinquisition... Meh, no need to replace him IMO.

[Fircoal]

There is no need to replace Kwan for Multi posting. Multi posting is nothing. I once posted 10 posts in a row in a mafia game. REgardless I still think KWan is town and is an idiot. Also I have other idea. Syzygy and Tal or Exile are scum, and the other is an SK or a 3rd party scum role.

[kalishnikov]

Hmm... I'm not sure how to take these Kwan antics, which now remind me of Reinquisition... Meh, no need to replace him IMO.

I agree, I don't see any need to replace him.

If it was 'pure' spam (smilies and such) then maybe, but not when it is somewhat story-related.

[freezie]

Fine, won't do then.

[kalishnikov]

Fine, won't do then.

Feel free though if you feel it's called for, your the mod.

[freezie]

I prefer when the mod interact with the players to see if something is worth doing or not, in case of a personal view on the situation.

If it was clear to me that he had to be replaced, I would have done by now.

[kalishnikov]

Why would a third party be interested in bodyguarding Dumbledore?

It fits the story. Fawks isn't a wizard and therefore belongs to neither side. But, he is loyal to Dumbledore and he has the power to cure fatal wounds with he's tears. Finally, being a phoenix, he 'recharges' his power by combusting (dying for a day) and then being reborn (as is shown in "Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets") Thus, this is either a great role by Freezie or a great lie by Kalish.

In my oppinion, the reasons for lynching Kalish are outweighted by the possible gain from not lynching him.

Dustn : Since this could make you practicaly imprevius to death, I suggest that you investigate Kalish. Also, it would be kind of nice if you would share with us the results of your first two investigations.

Exile: Fred without George? You have to admit that that sounds like a strange setup?

I did some Googling and you are completely correct. This role makes perfect sense as a surviver, contrary to what I though before I read.

And for once I agree with mandalorian; if whoever has the cop wand/is the cop would like to investigate me, feel free. I'm just a useless third party. And no, I'm not the godfather (he'd turn up town anyway, in my experience); pretty sure thats a Deatheater Lord and he's already dead.



Unvote, vote: Talapus I say we go this route and see what night brings, I can be investigated (and cleared) and we can continue on with this to find the actual scum.

[kalishnikov]

I prefer when the mod interact with the players to see if something is worth doing or not, in case of a personal view on the situation.

If it was clear to me that he had to be replaced, I would have done by now.

That's a good way to look at it, and I'm sure that if you thought the quality of the game was being ruined you'd take action immediately. Good decision.

[Koesen]

For the record, I still believe Kalishnikov to be scum.

However, since there doesn't seem to be a lot of support for his lynch, I'll switch to Talapus.

Unvote
Vote Talapus

[freezie]

A vote count is in order:

Kalish (2) Serbia, kwanton
Talapus (4) LSU, ga7, kalish, koesen.
Tonka (1) Mandy
Kwanton (1) Syzygy
ga7 (1) Talapus

14 alive, 8 to lynch.

[Koesen]

Kalish still has two votes.

[kwanton]

Hrm.

I assume i can post now.

Sorry for the spam but I figured the best way to save myself would be to make everyone else think I was a Jester. C'mon. Dobby was a great fake claim for a jester role, at least give me that much.

HoHum....i guess I'll play in a more conventional method now. Boring but nonetheless here we go.


I am town. I claim Hermione Granger officially. Syzygy is a lying bag of scum. Like fir said before, I would not have claimed Hermione if I was anything but. You could say that this is a huge WIFOM but I am telling the truth. I did not have any powers before I stole a wand. Now, I believe that none of the characters have a power inherent with their role. They must steal for a power. The reason I believe this is that Hermione is such a main role. If anyone would have a power it would be one of the three main characters (me Ron and Harry). Why do you think that there has only been one death a night and one of them was Voldemort? Someone claimed to have the Avada Kedavra wand which i assume would grant killing powers. That acounts for it and there are no other kills to speak of. If even scum don't have a normal night killing power, then why would kalish, a "survivor" have some? It also makes sense that a magicy-type person would need a wand to do magic. And the fact that kalish says he can "make" a wand strikes me as odd too. If you've read the books (which I am sure freezie has) then a pheonix like Fawkes could not just make a wand nor use one.

Along the same line of thought, if scum in fact are powerless without wands, maybe they have increased numbers to make up for this. Just speculation but it could be quite possible.

Here is who I think are scum:

1. Syzygy- Beyond a doubt scum IMO. Choose to believe me or not but it will come out in the open soon. Syzygy has pretty much put the nail in his coffin and trading a vanilla with a wand for one of the last few scum is OK with me.

2. Talapus- What I have to go on is what everyone else has said about the twin thing. But that does seem kind of damning to me. Nothing new for me to put in about this cuz everything else has already been said.

3. Kalish- In addition to what I said above, I'd like to add that I am in no way 100% sure that he is scum. He could very well be telling the truth and have a very odd role. But he is a target for a vote at this point.

On the topic of mandy/koesen: There's really no way of knowing if they are scum or not. It is very hard to tell mid-game if they changed sides. That is the one thing that could screw us over and once we resolve all the current suspects I suggest you go after them.


Other than that, lynch me if you'd like. I am not a jester. I am a plain run-of-the-mill boring old vanilla townie with a pretty badass wand. Let me live tonight and I target syzygy with it, taking away his vote and night action for tomorow. Lynch me today and you gain nothing but a dead townie and a confirmed scum. Either way you guys aren't looking too shabby.


Yes I know, generic, boring, overdone regular defense. Apparently it's bad for me to try anything "crazy" or think otside of the box.

[Syzygy]

Kwanton - you're full of shit and your antics in this game are started to piss me off.

There are only 2 possibilities I see here.

Case 1: He's a jester. Don't lynch him, please nightkill him instead.

Case 2: He's scum trying to pull some stupid trick.

If anyone would have a power it would be one of the three main characters (me Ron and Harry)

Alright, first point. Seeing as we have all already claimed, will Harry (Nag) please come foward to denounce this for the bullshit it is - I, as the legitimate Hermione know that I started with no special abilites. I would also ask Ron (Mandy) to claim, but I feel he can't be trusted.

As to Kwanton's words regarding Fawkes I really couldn't give a crap about that right now.

As to this...

Let me live tonight and I target syzygy with it, taking away his vote and night action for tomorow.

I say fine, go ahead that is if you really have the ability to do so which I doubt.

As far as I'm concerned, I think he's a jester wasting our fucking time.

[nagerous]

Syzygy hes saying that he didn't start with powers.

[nagerous]

unvote vote kwanton Freezie's comments and the fact he sounds pissed off implies kwanton is not a jester. I also doubt freezie to be the kind of mod to put a jester in so I feel this is a safe bet. If kwanton is hermoine, syzygy's fate is already sealed.

[Syzygy]

Syzygy hes saying that he didn't start with powers.

I realize - he's saying he has a wand. I think it's a bluff though.

[nagerous]

Kwanton's actions sound more like frustrated scum that hes being owned and trying to end the game in a bang possibly.

[Syzygy]

Kwanton's actions sound more like frustrated scum that hes being owned and trying to end the game in a bang possibly.

You really think so?

Because I REALLY think he's a jester.

[nagerous]

Nah, freezie wouldn't put a jester in the game and then when they started acting up like I did in that other game, threaten to replace him. That makes NO sense. I suggest we lynch kwanton, maybe you're pushing him as a jester because it buys you time and don't want him to be revealed as hermoine .

[Syzygy]

Nah, freezie wouldn't put a jester in the game and then when they started acting up like I did in that other game, threaten to replace him. That makes NO sense. I suggest we lynch kwanton, maybe you're pushing him as a jester because it buys you time and don't want him to be revealed as hermoine .

Pfff. Yeah, right.

I just realized that I still have no vote on him anyway, so I'll keep it that way.

[mandalorian2298]

Dustn : Since this could make you practicaly imprevius to death, I suggest that you investigate Kalish. Also, it would be kind of nice if you would share with us the results of your first two investigations.

When did I ever say I was a cop? In fact I don't have a wand. I tried to steal yours last night but I guess someone stole it before I did (or something of that sort).

You are Vanilla Dumbledore? With a bodyguard?

Why would a third party be interested in bodyguarding Dumbledore?

It fits the story. Fawks isn't a wizard and therefore belongs to neither side.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but Hagrid isn't a wizard either and he's town.

Gladly. Hadgrid is a wizard.

Unvote