Trivial Twist Mafia! End of Madness!

[/]

Huh, perhaps the remaining scum are all submariners, it would explain why we've never had a night kill all game.

Skimmah

NO U
browng-08- lynched
animorpherv1- lynched
sam_levi_11- lynched
ace1217 - mod-killed
danodukebb / Iliad / kalishnikov -lynched
When has anyone been killed by the mafia so far?

[icedagger]

Ah you're right.. forgot ace was modkilled

[pmchugh]

Huh, perhaps the remaining scum are all submariners, it would explain why we've never had a night kill all game.

Its possible but it could also be to do with this locked house.

I know it seems silly but I think it may be worth lynching ice just to get this game to progress or else we could be going until day 100.

p.s. Is this the longest game (in terms of days) that there has ever been on CC?

[Nickbaldwin]

I don't like the sound of day 13, MM could be planning something unlucky for us

[/]

Huh, perhaps the remaining scum are all submariners, it would explain why we've never had a night kill all game.

Its possible but it could also be to do with this locked house.

I know it seems silly but I think it may be worth lynching ice just to get this game to progress or else we could be going until day 100.

p.s. Is this the longest game (in terms of days) that there has ever been on CC?

There's always that tiny chance ice decided to make one of the most absurd, impossible to lie about fake claims ever. But I'd still like to think he's a confirmed townie, all he hinders is the mafia's night kills, town still controls the result of every day for now, meaning we are currently at a great advantage to end this game, free lynches with no night kills. Vote pmchugh, What sort of progress might you be attempting to get underway?

[icedagger]

Lack of night kills up to last night is pretty obvious.. doc + lightning rod immunity, then ace protects himself, then mafia don't send a kill cos of MM's weird threat. Last night is more strange though.. but finding an overarching theory for every night is kinda pointless when they're already explained up to last night.

Vote pmc your argument doesn't even begin to make any sense (how will lynching me get the game going?)

[Minister Masket]

cena has been prodded for the second time.
He will not be let off so lightly next time...

[cena-rules]

I honestly have nothing to say

[Minister Masket]

I honestly have nothing to say

How disappointing.
If I was in your position, I...well....you'd know what I'd do.

[cena-rules]

I honestly have nothing to say

How disappointing.
If I was in your position, I...well....you'd know what I'd do.

good point

*streaks and then blows up spain*

[pmchugh]

Huh, perhaps the remaining scum are all submariners, it would explain why we've never had a night kill all game.

Its possible but it could also be to do with this locked house.

I know it seems silly but I think it may be worth lynching ice just to get this game to progress or else we could be going until day 100.

p.s. Is this the longest game (in terms of days) that there has ever been on CC?

There's always that tiny chance ice decided to make one of the most absurd, impossible to lie about fake claims ever. But I'd still like to think he's a confirmed townie, all he hinders is the mafia's night kills, town still controls the result of every day for now, meaning we are currently at a great advantage to end this game, free lynches with no night kills. Vote pmchugh, What sort of progress might you be attempting to get underway?

Fair enough point, i meant cop investigations and things like that. I guess I just want a normal mafia, I don't really know how to go about it but tell me how is he confirmed townie. This is mafia with a twist and him as mafia would be an interesting one, although admittedly unlikely and I take back my suspicion of a lynch.

not to sound too OMGUS but you seem to be leading the town, you were the main instigator yesterday in kalish's lynch and today ice follows you with a very similar comment in the very next post.

I really need to re-read the thread then I will post something of more value and sense.

[Minister Masket]

Contrary to Nick's paranoia, I have nothing nasty planned for Day 13. After all, nothing bad happens in daylight...

For some reason, I really want this day to end, so the next deadline will be on Saturday, 9pm.

Have a nice day now!

[pmchugh]

Contrary to Nick's paranoia, I have nothing nasty planned for Day 13. After all, nothing bad happens in daylight...

For some reason, I really want this day to end, so the next deadline will be on Saturday, 9pm.

Have a nice day now!

Im not looking forward to night.

[Nickbaldwin]

Cock, I shouldn't have said anything.

I think we should keep Ice alive as long as is possible, as / says he is hindering night kills which gives us more time to deduce who is scum. Good old fashioned reading between the lines still works, we still have evidence in the form of posts, but we are without the night actions of our power roles. I think we still have enough to work from to finish this game without killing the almost certain lightning rod.

[pmchugh]

2) cena-rules - Confirmed Actor
5) icedagger - Confirmed Lightning Rod
6) dunc_2007 - Unclaimed
8.) / - Unclaimed
9) Nickbaldwin- Unclaimed
10) pmchugh - Unclaimed

Now in an 11-player game chances are we have 2-3 scum. With one dead that leaves 2 max.

If it is two then we only have 2 lynches or one lynch and a NK left so we better choose wisely this time.

Do you think a mass claim is sensible? I thought most people had but apparently not, I cant make heads or tails of the night scenes anyone care to share what they deduce?

[/]

What to do?
Unvote, if PMC is town, and ice and myself were town, scum could easily hammer by now.
I don't think a mass claim to be wise if there is still an active mafia roleblocker, but at the same time, we're likely doomed anyways if we don't get a proper scum lynch today and claiming may help in that regard.

[icedagger]

Cock, I shouldn't have said anything.

I think we should keep Ice alive as long as is possible, as / says he is hindering night kills which gives us more time to deduce who is scum. Good old fashioned reading between the lines still works, we still have evidence in the form of posts, but we are without the night actions of our power roles. I think we still have enough to work from to finish this game without killing the almost certain lightning rod.

Does this stink of newbie scum to anyone else? Staying on the fence, rephrasing what's already been said and not actualy coming out against anyone

Unvote Vote Nick

[icedagger]

Mass claim seems fairly pointless since there is a pretty much limitless amount of fake claims the mafia could make, which we have no way of proving/disproving. We would just be outing the power roles.

Slash why exactly do you think there is a mafia RB?

[/]

Eh, not sure, I suppose logically there probably isn't one, But this "locked house" appeared even before you received your role, so I just assumed it had something to do with role-blocking.

[icedagger]

Actualy the first mention of it was immediately after I recieved my role

[/]

Oh, I see...
Whoops, I guess I got sam_levi lynched with absolutely no reason then, lucky that he was scum though.

[Nickbaldwin]

Cock, I shouldn't have said anything.

I think we should keep Ice alive as long as is possible, as / says he is hindering night kills which gives us more time to deduce who is scum. Good old fashioned reading between the lines still works, we still have evidence in the form of posts, but we are without the night actions of our power roles. I think we still have enough to work from to finish this game without killing the almost certain lightning rod.

Does this stink of newbie scum to anyone else? Staying on the fence, rephrasing what's already been said and not actualy coming out against anyone

Unvote Vote Nick

I'm not coming out against anyone because I'm not sure who to come out against, it's a very confusing game. I stated my beliefs, some of which had already been said (which I posted in agreement with), is there anything wrong with that? Or would you like me to keep quiet so you can accuse me of submarining instead.

[pmchugh]

Cock, I shouldn't have said anything.

I think we should keep Ice alive as long as is possible, as / says he is hindering night kills which gives us more time to deduce who is scum. Good old fashioned reading between the lines still works, we still have evidence in the form of posts, but we are without the night actions of our power roles. I think we still have enough to work from to finish this game without killing the almost certain lightning rod.

Does this stink of newbie scum to anyone else? Staying on the fence, rephrasing what's already been said and not actualy coming out against anyone

Unvote Vote Nick

I'm not coming out against anyone because I'm not sure who to come out against, it's a very confusing game. I stated my beliefs, some of which had already been said (which I posted in agreement with), is there anything wrong with that? Or would you like me to keep quiet so you can accuse me of submarining instead.

It is espicially as a replacement and ive been here for day, but their is a slight air of scummyness about your posts.

I don't really think that a mass claim would be brilliant as said its too easy to fake claim.

p.s. When was the last time we heard from dunc?

[icedagger]

Cock, I shouldn't have said anything.

I think we should keep Ice alive as long as is possible, as / says he is hindering night kills which gives us more time to deduce who is scum. Good old fashioned reading between the lines still works, we still have evidence in the form of posts, but we are without the night actions of our power roles. I think we still have enough to work from to finish this game without killing the almost certain lightning rod.

Does this stink of newbie scum to anyone else? Staying on the fence, rephrasing what's already been said and not actualy coming out against anyone

Unvote Vote Nick

I'm not coming out against anyone because I'm not sure who to come out against, it's a very confusing game. I stated my beliefs, some of which had already been said (which I posted in agreement with), is there anything wrong with that? Or would you like me to keep quiet so you can accuse me of submarining instead.

No it's just I've played a few newbie games recently and it really is amazing the consistency with which newbie scum use the fence-sitting tactic

[/]

I didn't see any scum tells while skoffin was playing, Still, I suppose Nick, might be scummy, perhaps?
Also, judging by MM's posts, Cena isn't just a normal action-less actor, though I don't think we'll get much from pressing that any further.
I know we need a lynch, but I don't feel comfortable rushing this under current circumstances.
On the other hand, the odds definitely aren't getting any better from here with no lynch Vote Nickbaldwin...