Wandlore Battles Kalish out. Hogwart wins!

[freezie]

VotaSempra:

Kalishnikov (1) Koesen.
Talapus (2) Syzygy, LSU
Ga7 (1) Talapus
The1exile (1) Nagerous

[dustn64]

UNVOTE

[LSU Tiger Josh]

kalish's

[Koesen]

I completely forgot about the rule that says if you don't have a wand you can steal one. And as nagerous said, I've still got the wand I started with so I've had no reason to meddle with stealing any so I never looked into it. I'm not a big HP fan like most of you so I've got nothing when it comes to wand names and characters and stuff, I've just been trying to work the actual gameplay angle and disregard that which I don't understand (i.e., wands and spells and such).

How does it make any sense that I'm scum based on the fact I forgot a rule which I read a weak or more ago and haven't dealt with at all? That's just kinda stupid, if you ask me. But since mandalorian says it, it will be bandwagoned upon...

Btw, FOS: dustin, Koesen. At least mandalorian/ga7's vote have some kind of reasoning behind them, not just parroting what was said before them.

Been away for most of the weekend and come back to find the case against Kalishnikov all but dissolved.

I am, however, not completely convinced by Kalishnikov's mentioning of rules. Are you talking about the rule set in the first post that you read long ago and forgot about or do I misunderstand your defense?

[Koesen]

Also, does the case against Talapus focus entirely on the sibling issue, or is there someone who counterclaims the same character?

I would think that if one of the twins is there, the other one will be there too, and both should be town. If there's nobody to claim the same character, I am inclined to think the sibling issue, though intriguing, is kind of moot.

[The1exile]

Well, it could be a false claim. Mods do occasionally provide them. There is also the fact that his posts scream scumminess.

[Koesen]

Well, if Kalishnikov gives me a satisfying answer, I may switch to Talapus.

[Fircoal]

Indeed. I spotted a few already: GT, Fircoal.

that's because I was avoiding the thread. I didn't feel like playing atm.

[Fircoal]

I'm Pavarti Patil

last night I stole Frenchie-chan's doc wand.

[kwanton]

awww crap.

I'm hermione. I can't believe I missed syzygy's claim.

vote syzygy

I stole voldy's wand from mandy last night.

[mandalorian2298]

Role Claim list update:

1. Talapus - George Weasly.
2. Mandy - Ron Weasly.
3. Ga7 - Neville Longbottom
4. Nag - Harry Potter
5. Koesen - Padma Patil
6. Syzygy - Hermione Granger
7. Exile - Fred Weasly (Wandmaker Apprantice)
8. LSU - Olivander (Wandmaker)
9. Dustn - Albus B. P. W. Dumbledore
10. Serbia - Nearly-Headles Nick (Survivor)
11. Fircoal - Parvati Patil
12. Kwanton - Hermione Granger

The two players marked orange, might have been penalized with an alligment switch during the previous Night. Thus, although their name-claims probably can be trusted, they alone don't prove their innocence.

The two players marked blue have claimed the same role.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vote Syzygy because of Kwanton's counter-claim.

Exile: I ment that we need for the third Weasly Twin to claim. If one of you two is fake, then there is still one unknown Weasly Twin roaming around.

[nagerous]

[mandalorian2298]

Sorry for the edit. I just took the quotation of.

[nagerous]

Weren't expecting to be fastposted?

[mandalorian2298]

Weren't expecting to be fastposted?

Hell no. Who is on-line in this time of day!?

[nagerous]

Craazy people like myself, though I've gotta return a library book before 10am else I be fined a hefty fine. I had enough time to go on the internet and ponder the kwanton syzygy case with a before I leave.

[Syzygy]

awww crap.

I'm hermione. I can't believe I missed syzygy's claim.

vote syzygy

I stole voldy's wand from mandy last night.

Bullshit. If you're seriously going to believe this, please kill kwanton next.

And SFOS: Mandy. I haven't trusted you since the possiblity of your alignment change, furthermore Kwanton's 'reasoning' where he somehow stole Voldemort's wand from you last night seems a bit dodge. How do you get a dead guy's wand? Please explain that.

[nagerous]

2. Wands are given out RANDOMLY at the beginning of the game. It doesn’t mean because you stole Rogue’s wand from bob that Bob is Rogue. He could well be Dumbledore.

[nagerous]

Kwanton, mandy was confirmed pro-town yesterday. Why would you steal his wand? I'm not sure also that Syzygy is dumb enough to claim such a prominent character if he was one of the few remaining deatheaters. Your actions smell like lyncher.

[Koesen]

Between Kwanton and Syzygy, Syzygy sounds more believable to me. He said something in the middle of the Mandy-and-Me-Madness that persuaded me he was town.

I guess under those circumstances, the logical thing is to

Unvote
Vote Kwanton

I'm still curious about Kalishnikov, though. Was it the rule set in the first post you read and forgot about?

[Syzygy]

2. Wands are given out RANDOMLY at the beginning of the game. It doesn’t mean because you stole Rogue’s wand from bob that Bob is Rogue. He could well be Dumbledore.

Hmm... alright. I understood that he was talking about the wand voldemort started out with, and thus thought WTF?

But I still see a problem with this. As you should know as well as several other players, the wands do not have such names. The wand you had on night 2 was the Spy Wand, not [insert character's name]'s Wand.

Thus, how could he know it was Voldy's wand... unless he is making stuff up?

That's two lies now on Kwanton's part.Unvote, Vote: Kwanton

[kwanton]

unvote
vote kwanton

Lynch me

[kwanton]

2. Wands are given out RANDOMLY at the beginning of the game. It doesn’t mean because you stole Rogue’s wand from bob that Bob is Rogue. He could well be Dumbledore.

Hmm... alright. I understood that he was talking about the wand voldemort started out with, and thus thought WTF?

But I still see a problem with this. As you should know as well as several other players, the wands do not have such names. The wand you had on night 2 was the Spy Wand, not [insert character's name]'s Wand.

Thus, how could he know it was Voldy's wand... unless he is making stuff up?

That's two lies now on Kwanton's part.Unvote, Vote: Kwanton

It said "Voldemort's Wand" as the name of the wand.

Go ahead syz.

Lynch me.

You know you want to.

See what happens.

[kwanton]

Now I know what you are syz. You're not getting away.

Even if you lynch me.

Let me live and I use voldy's wand on you.

Get me lynched......well you'll find out.

[kwanton]

8 TO LYNCH!!!

That's me syz and koes who have voted me.

I wonder which two of us are scum

C'mon just 5 more of you guys.