Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[AK_iceman]

Key word being "isn't entirely" the same. While some roles may or may not have been changed taking an actual merry men and making him not would be entirely changing the story.


Killing me during the daytime would be a stupid mistake for the town and nobles to make as it is my destiny to die at night at the hands of the merry men at some point.

So why would the Merry Men kill you? That doesn't seem to make any sense... It would be one thing to say you MAY die... But to have a destiny???

Maybe he's an unlynchable townie role, and the only way for him to die is for mafia to night kill him?

[AK_iceman]

Of anyone else in the game I am twice as likely to die at their hands than anyone else. While it might not happen, the odds are that it will and I've resigned myself to that.

How do you know this? It seems to me like you're just making shit up now, unless Aimless hinted at this in your role PM in which case you need to elaborate.

[autoload]

3. With a belivable case against Selin, an cases against Aegnor and LSU going on, this sure is a strange reason to vote me. I would understand if you based your vote against me on the fact that you belive Aegnor, but this feels like you are trying to keep your distance with a soon-to-be-hung scum, while in the same time you are trying to help him a bit.
FOS NARC

3. you are the only person who still thinks there is a case against Selin. ( feel free to correct me anybody )

I also believe a Selin Lynch could be informational to the town.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I was informed it in my role.

[Anarkistsdream]

I know, Mandalorian, but I honestly think that Selin has more likely of a chance to have a Pro-town role...

Honestly, I don't know what to think....

Selin, Mandalorian, LSU, and Aegnor all have suspicions regarding them that seriously make me question what the hell is going on.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Like I said, it's pretty much my destiny to die at night by the hands of the merry men as I'm twice as likely as anyone else based on how my role was set up. Lynching me will only help the scum win.

[dwightschrute]

reading over the posts
i decide to
Unvote

[wicked]

Geez all these people will "lynch me this way by X day" roles. sheesh. So if Mandy dying by day 3 will help the town, why don't we lynch him first?

[for dummies]

ok people this is getting sort of ridiculos. We are thinking too much. It is only the first day almost all first day lynches are of townies anyway, so here is what i suggest. We lynch someone that Mandy has been going after (selin or agenor) if they are scum we trust mandy and then lynch the other one. If they are pro town we lynhc mandy. There is a very goodlikelyhood that 1 of these three is scum. So we should just test it out.

[Anarkistsdream]

ok people this is getting sort of ridiculos. We are thinking too much. It is only the first day almost all first day lynches are of townies anyway, so here is what i suggest. We lynch someone that Mandy has been going after (selin or agenor) if they are scum we trust mandy and then lynch the other one. If they are pro town we lynhc mandy. There is a very goodlikelyhood that 1 of these three is scum. So we should just test it out.

That's a fairly intelligent idea...

[hecter]

Ya… You do have a point… But which one? Selin or Aegnor?

[for dummies]

whoever has more votes at the moment? i think that is selin. i don't think it really matters

[autoload]

My vote would go towards Selin. As a matter of fact...

Vote: Selin

[Anarkistsdream]

My feeling is that Aegnor poses more of a threat... But okay...

Vote: Selin

[hecter]

Unvote
vote selin

[for dummies]

can we get a votecount aimless?

[jnd94]

ok people this is getting sort of ridiculos. We are thinking too much. It is only the first day almost all first day lynches are of townies anyway, so here is what i suggest. We lynch someone that Mandy has been going after (selin or agenor) if they are scum we trust mandy and then lynch the other one. If they are pro town we lynhc mandy. There is a very goodlikelyhood that 1 of these three is scum. So we should just test it out.

goood idea, that will almost surely take us to mafia. And then the people that stick up for the accused can be our next leads.

[Aimless]

Vote Count
autoload - 1 (Guilty_Biscuit)
LSU Tiger Josh - 2 (Ehriggn, XenHu)
Selin - 9 (mandalorian, LSU Tiger Josh, for dummies, spiesr, dwightschrute, dominationnation, autoload, hecter, Anarkistsdream)
Aegnor - 1 (got tonkaed)

Not Voting - 12

With 25 alive, it take 13 to lynch!

[dominationnation]

ok I havent been around a computer for a while so I dont realy know whats going on and dont feel like reading 20 pages of posts. Can someone give me a quick summary please

[AK_iceman]

ok I havent been around a computer for a while so I dont realy know whats going on and dont feel like reading 20 pages of posts. Can someone give me a quick summary please

No, you need to read it all.

[Anarkistsdream]

ok I havent been around a computer for a while so I dont realy know whats going on and dont feel like reading 20 pages of posts. Can someone give me a quick summary please

We are voting Selin... If Mandalorian is wrong, we lynch him next. if he is correct, we lynch Aegnor next.

[dominationnation]

ok I havent been around a computer for a while so I dont realy know whats going on and dont feel like reading 20 pages of posts. Can someone give me a quick summary please

We are voting Selin... If Mandalorian is wrong, we lynch him next. if he is correct, we lynch Aegnor next.

anyother suspecions floating around or anyone really determined not to vote for selin?

No, you need to read it all.

your really mean
you must be maifa

[AK_iceman]

Sorry, but I have little tolerance for people who sign up to play mafia, then can't be bothered to read everything.

[dominationnation]

It was really just today. I do have things to do (unfortualy) so I can make a living by playing cc(again unfortuantly) so i had little trouble getting to a computer.

sorry ill try not to let it happen again

[mandalorian2298]

Geez all these people will "lynch me this way by X day" roles. sheesh. So if Mandy dying by day 3 will help the town, why don't we lynch him first?

ok people this is getting sort of ridiculos. We are thinking too much. It is only the first day almost all first day lynches are of townies anyway, so here is what i suggest. We lynch someone that Mandy has been going after (selin or agenor) if they are scum we trust mandy and then lynch the other one. If they are pro town we lynhc mandy. There is a very goodlikelyhood that 1 of these three is scum. So we should just test it out.

Might I suggest that Sk kills me if I am wrong? Otherwise (if Selin to be a good Allan-a-Dale) you guys will spend half of Day 2 wandering if I am a jester.