Chris Nolan Mafia - Game Over [ARCHIVE]

[Fircoal]

I find it interesting that this happened. It is true that none of us really looked into speisr but in his actions he has played like a town figure. I find it a bit funny that Edoc and Streaker both seem very eager/happy at this new idea. It does mean we have to put more thought into our actions though because now we aren't able to just mislynch one, and then kill the other. We have to get the right one. I ask you all flavor aside, which one of the three has acted the most pro-town/pro-themselves?

[Commander9]

I find it interesting that this happened. It is true that none of us really looked into speisr but in his actions he has played like a town figure. I find it a bit funny that Edoc and Streaker both seem very eager/happy at this new idea. It does mean we have to put more thought into our actions though because now we aren't able to just mislynch one, and then kill the other. We have to get the right one. I ask you all flavor aside, which one of the three has acted the most pro-town/pro-themselves?

It's not all just acting about pro-town... And you should know it well enough. You can remember me in Nostalgia mafia - no one had any doubts that I'd be pro-town, but I was not. Spiesr has pretty much the same style of play in every game and it is very hard to notice him acting scummy. Right now, I feel that going by roles, while not perfect, can shed some light upon this - someone here is not being truthful. I'm fairly sure, at least after Vio's death, that you are not what is holding us in this game, so it shouldn't be you. I also know that it's not me (and my play along with the role should suggest that as well). That leaves us with spiesr, streaker and Edoc.

Edoc - a bit ambigious play, but generally seemed pro-town. Character: Very ambiguous.
Streaker - hasn't contributed all that much (least of all 3). Character: Ambiguous, but not as much as the other 2.
Spiesr - his playing has generally seemed pro-town. Character: The most ambiguous and possibly the most dangerous.

I know fully well that both Edoc and Spiesr are very capable actors and manipulators, so their play doesn't tell the full story. Streaker isn't generally know that much for it, but he's still good. Right now I think I'd prefer to try out Spiesr or Edoc (In that order).

[Fircoal]

I find it interesting that this happened. It is true that none of us really looked into speisr but in his actions he has played like a town figure. I find it a bit funny that Edoc and Streaker both seem very eager/happy at this new idea. It does mean we have to put more thought into our actions though because now we aren't able to just mislynch one, and then kill the other. We have to get the right one. I ask you all flavor aside, which one of the three has acted the most pro-town/pro-themselves?

It's not all just acting about pro-town... And you should know it well enough. You can remember me in Nostalgia mafia - no one had any doubts that I'd be pro-town, but I was not. Spiesr has pretty much the same style of play in every game and it is very hard to notice him acting scummy. Right now, I feel that going by roles, while not perfect, can shed some light upon this - someone here is not being truthful. I'm fairly sure, at least after Vio's death, that you are not what is holding us in this game, so it shouldn't be you. I also know that it's not me (and my play along with the role should suggest that as well). That leaves us with spiesr, streaker and Edoc.

Edoc - a bit ambigious play, but generally seemed pro-town. Character: Very ambiguous.
Streaker - hasn't contributed all that much (least of all 3). Character: Ambiguous, but not as much as the other 2.
Spiesr - his playing has generally seemed pro-town. Character: The most ambiguous and possibly the most dangerous.

I know fully well that both Edoc and Spiesr are very capable actors and manipulators, so their play doesn't tell the full story. Streaker isn't generally know that much for it, but he's still good. Right now I think I'd prefer to try out Spiesr or Edoc (In that order).

I am well aware it isn't the only part of the equation, but it seems with all of this role/theme talk we're forgetting about the scum tells themselves. An argument only based on the roles especially in this scenario won't end up as profitable as one of the whole entirety. I'm not saying to only focus on this but rather to give some focus to it so we can choose from the whole.

[edocsil]

I find it interesting that this happened. It is true that none of us really looked into speisr but in his actions he has played like a town figure. I find it a bit funny that Edoc and Streaker both seem very eager/happy at this new idea. It does mean we have to put more thought into our actions though because now we aren't able to just mislynch one, and then kill the other. We have to get the right one. I ask you all flavor aside, which one of the three has acted the most pro-town/pro-themselves?

It's not all just acting about pro-town... And you should know it well enough. You can remember me in Nostalgia mafia - no one had any doubts that I'd be pro-town, but I was not. Spiesr has pretty much the same style of play in every game and it is very hard to notice him acting scummy. Right now, I feel that going by roles, while not perfect, can shed some light upon this - someone here is not being truthful. I'm fairly sure, at least after Vio's death, that you are not what is holding us in this game, so it shouldn't be you. I also know that it's not me (and my play along with the role should suggest that as well). That leaves us with spiesr, streaker and Edoc.

Edoc - a bit ambigious play, but generally seemed pro-town. Character: Very ambiguous.
Streaker - hasn't contributed all that much (least of all 3). Character: Ambiguous, but not as much as the other 2.
Spiesr - his playing has generally seemed pro-town. Character: The most ambiguous and possibly the most dangerous.

I know fully well that both Edoc and Spiesr are very capable actors and manipulators, so their play doesn't tell the full story. Streaker isn't generally know that much for it, but he's still good. Right now I think I'd prefer to try out Spiesr or Edoc (In that order).

I am well aware it isn't the only part of the equation, but it seems with all of this role/theme talk we're forgetting about the scum tells themselves. An argument only based on the roles especially in this scenario won't end up as profitable as one of the whole entirety. I'm not saying to only focus on this but rather to give some focus to it so we can choose from the whole.

My only question is why do you care? You will not be the target of any night actions likely, as we know your role pretty much beyond all doubt. It is your turn to choose. You can vote for me with both of your votes and try to get Com or Streaker to change their mind or you can end the day with a vote.

[pancakemix]

Reminder

You guys have about 30 hours to decide or a no lynch will be reached.

[Streaker]

C'mon Fir, it's your move.

[edocsil]

C'mon Fir, it's your move.

For chirst sake man. Do something.

[Fircoal]

C'mon Fir, it's your move.

For chirst sake man. Do something.

Sorry didn't know it was coming up. Sadly for you Edoc, I am most worried about you thusly I'll Vote: Edoc. Sending off the secret vote.

[pancakemix]

Vote Count

Spiesr - 3 (edocsil, Comm9, Streaker)
Edocsil - 3 (Spiesr, Fircoal, ???)

EXT. INTERSECTION - DAY

Most of the town in waiting outside at the intersection. they seem impatient. Time passes. One by one they begin to leave as the sun begins to set. At sundown, Fircoal arrives.

CHU: Hey guys...

There is no one else at the intersection.

CHU: ...guys?

No lynch. It is now Night 5. Please send all night actions by 9 pm ET on May 30.

[edocsil]

*Snores loudly*

[pancakemix]

Stolen Goods

EXT. ALLEY - NIGHT

Spiesr walks calmly through the alleyway, his nightly work done. He carries with him a stuffed duffel bag labeled "Property of James Graves". A shadow appears at the other end of the alley. The two stare each other down.

SPIESR: Why don't you take a picture? It'll last longer.

???: I will. But only once I've given you what you deserve.

The figure raises a gun and shoot Spiesr dead. He pulls out a camera and snaps a photo of the body. He then begins to examine the bag. It is full of pictures of another man. The shadow, seemingly frustrated, takes out a lighter and burns Spiesr's photo. He drops the burning picture onto the body, setting the alleyway alight.

Spiesr AKA are Cobb (Following, 1998) Pro-Town Thief has been killed!



It is now Day 6. June 5 deadline.

[Fircoal]

Well would you look at that, there's a killing role yet. Although I'm surprised at the choice there... What did everyone do?

[edocsil]

Well would you look at that, there's a killing role yet. Although I'm surprised at the choice there... What did everyone do?

I have no action. I can't believe he was telling the truth.

Streaker was the obvious killer there.

Commanders Claim is Dom Cobb. It is ironclad but it has no backup from the scenes.
I am the White Knight, flavor proven
Fircoal is Alfred, proven
Streaker is Shelby, prover by the last scene

Hell, if Cob is town Leonard sure as hell should be. I don't know what to do. Com is the only avenue I see beyond myself.

[Commander9]

Well, I directed Streaker to spiesr, so the kill was partly my fault - I still thought it needed to be done. Well, it's a call between Edoc and streaker and I'm going for edoc here. Vote edoc.

[edocsil]

Well, I directed Streaker to spiesr, so the kill was partly my fault - I still thought it needed to be done. Well, it's a call between Edoc and streaker and I'm going for edoc here. Vote edoc.

I can't really blame you, it's the logical choice. The only thing I have to offer is that to the best of my knowledge I am Town, the only way I am Scum is if I didn't actually know it. Considering the character it isn't impossible. Before anyone (fir) brings the end of the day all I have to say in my defense is look at how I play as scum. I very rarely lie, I merely bend the truth, it makes for a better fake. So I sit here and say this. I am the White Knight, I am town, I have no night action. I do not lie.

[Commander9]

I can't really blame you, it's the logical choice. The only thing I have to offer is that to the best of my knowledge I am Town, the only way I am Scum is if I didn't actually know it. Considering the character it isn't impossible. Before anyone (fir) brings the end of the day all I have to say in my defense is look at how I play as scum. I very rarely lie, I merely bend the truth, it makes for a better fake. So I sit here and say this. I am the White Knight, I am town, I have no night action. I do not lie.

I fully understand what you are saying, but I'm not really sure that there are any other choices. Streaker looks likely to be town, but... Worst case scenario, he can be lynched tomorrow. I highly doubt Fir would be the reason the game is not over as I don't think that in order for town to win, they have to kill 3rd party double voters. It's possible, but highly unlikely. I know that my character is pro-town and I highly doubt that Dominic Cobb would be a hidden evil guy... And that leaves us only with you.

[Streaker]

Right.

Vote edoc
Not a hard choice after all. Even tried stalling for a day with a case. Game 'should' end after his lynch.

[edocsil]

Alright, one last gamble, as I have to live to win. Vote Commander.

My only guess is that he has a fake, and a damn good one. He is the only player who hasn't been in any scenes at all. Fircoal, can you help me with this? Unless I miss my guess you only need to continue to survive right? If you help me eliminate Com9 you will be one step closer to the end of the game, and with your two votes no matter who is alive tomorrow you can hang whoever you feel is a threat.

[Commander9]

Alright, one last gamble, as I have to live to win. Vote Commander.

My only guess is that he has a fake, and a damn good one. He is the only player who hasn't been in any scenes at all. Fircoal, can you help me with this? Unless I miss my guess you only need to continue to survive right? If you help me eliminate Com9 you will be one step closer to the end of the game, and with your two votes no matter who is alive tomorrow you can hang whoever you feel is a threat.

Well, this is the last time I ever decide to feel any contempt for you or help you in any mafia game. Should have seen this coming, especially after Spiesr's death. If I die, game moves into night with 3 people left... A possible night kill and if Edoc really is scum, he ends with 2 people and wins.

[Commander9]

Furthermore, spiesr investigated me and he confirmed I was Dominic Cobb. When he investigated you, the mod left it ambiguous. Desperate scum is desperate, Edocsil.

[Fircoal]

Before I do any helping of anyone out. I was thinking of something and I'd like clarification. Streaker did you target Speisr last night? I want to be 100% sure the kill was you.

[edocsil]

Alright, one last gamble, as I have to live to win. Vote Commander.

My only guess is that he has a fake, and a damn good one. He is the only player who hasn't been in any scenes at all. Fircoal, can you help me with this? Unless I miss my guess you only need to continue to survive right? If you help me eliminate Com9 you will be one step closer to the end of the game, and with your two votes no matter who is alive tomorrow you can hang whoever you feel is a threat.

Well, this is the last time I ever decide to feel any contempt for you or help you in any mafia game. Should have seen this coming, especially after Spiesr's death. If I die, game moves into night with 3 people left... A possible night kill and if Edoc really is scum, he ends with 2 people and wins.

I don't think Contempt was the word you intended to use there.

But anyways, what other options do I have from my perspective? Do not blame me for my course any more then I for yours.

I know Fir's role and Streaker is confirmed through scenes, it leaves only you baring bastard modding. You if I recall correctly were not confirmed as Cobb, a Top was found on you, it could just as likely have been the wife's. Mal? that was her name wasn't it.

[Commander9]

@ Fir:

If you would like earlier in the thread (if you're that lazy, tell me and I'll quote them) were my existence was confirmed by actions which were somehow redirected.

I don't think Contempt was the word you intended to use there.

But anyways, what other options do I have from my perspective? Do not blame me for my course any more then I for yours.

I know Fir's role and Streaker is confirmed through scenes, it leaves only you baring bastard modding. You if I recall correctly were not confirmed as Cobb, a Top was found on you, it could just as likely have been the wife's. Mal? that was her name wasn't it.

You said yourself that you were fine with being lynched should spiesr turn out not to be scum. Of course, scummy appetite grows while eating. As far as me being Cobb - nice try, but you should have looked at the thread before lying:

Well, I visited commander last night and can confirm that he is Cobb from Inception.

[edocsil]

@ Fir:

If you would like earlier in the thread (if you're that lazy, tell me and I'll quote them) were my existence was confirmed by actions which were somehow redirected.

I don't think Contempt was the word you intended to use there.

But anyways, what other options do I have from my perspective? Do not blame me for my course any more then I for yours.

I know Fir's role and Streaker is confirmed through scenes, it leaves only you baring bastard modding. You if I recall correctly were not confirmed as Cobb, a Top was found on you, it could just as likely have been the wife's. Mal? that was her name wasn't it.

You said yourself that you were fine with being lynched should spiesr turn out not to be scum. Of course, scummy appetite grows while eating. As far as me being Cobb - nice try, but you should have looked at the thread before lying:

Well, I visited commander last night and can confirm that he is Cobb from Inception.

Humh, what page is that on, I couldn't find it. I would like to see the whole quote.

[Commander9]

Humh, what page is that on, I couldn't find it. I would like to see the whole quote.

Start of day 4, page 33.