Webcomics Mafia! Evil Prevails!

[Iliad]

I wouldn't put my money on militant as the mafia godfather. He is the sort to throw a game when losing, but not when in sitting pretty on the prestige role. As he hasn't said anything since the first day, that leaves /. I don't recall anything glaring (besides Drench's accusation yesterday), so I will reread for ammunition.

The fact that he has been lurking makes him very suspicious. Please don't metagame-I don't care if he has thrown games, the evidence is pointing towards him.

[Iliad]

In fact his replacement has only posted three times altogether.
Once to say he has replaced and that he will re-read.
His second post was to jump on the drench wagon. Pretty straightforward though the nag comment is interesting.

after reading through everything again.......

vote drench

nagerous should be looked at tonight.

after reading through everything again.......

vote drench

nagerous should be looked at tonight.

The f*ck you talking about?

I trust spiesr

vote drench

I trust spiesr as well, you just seemed to back drench a few times. that is all.

And here suspect accuses nag of supporting drench. Will have to check whether that is in fact true, and that could yield up an interesting result, but right now suspect/militant is a very likely suspect (pun not intended).

Vote suspect

[Suspect101]

In fact his replacement has only posted three times altogether.
Once to say he has replaced and that he will re-read.
His second post was to jump on the drench wagon. Pretty straightforward though the nag comment is interesting.

after reading through everything again.......

vote drench

nagerous should be looked at tonight.

after reading through everything again.......

vote drench

nagerous should be looked at tonight.

The f*ck you talking about?

I trust spiesr

vote drench

I trust spiesr as well, you just seemed to back drench a few times. that is all.

And here suspect accuses nag of supporting drench. Will have to check whether that is in fact true, and that could yield up an interesting result, but right now suspect/militant is a very likely suspect (pun not intended).

Vote suspect

actually I am waiting to hear responses to questions I sent to MM about the game. It was a pretty straight forward case against drench, who was a mafia, so everyone should have been on that bandwagon. why are you saying it was scummy for me to be on a mafia bandwagon?

That clears you in my book Drench

unvote

you have some pretty shady reasoning there iliad.

[spiesr]

I think he says that it is scummy that your only action was to jump on a popular wagon...

[nagerous]

Except, suspect, I unvoted Drench when I was one of the first to hop on his initial wagon

[nagerous]

f*ck it, vote drench

there is nothing else going on at the moment and he has peaked my scumdar all game.

See, on page 24, only PMChugh was pressurising him and then I jumped on him, resulting in a developing bandwagon. I then unvoted, because Drench gave a claim, which would be daft to lynch him after the claim he gave!

Vote suspect - not an OMGUS but I think he is involved with Drench some way, possibly his godfather.

[Suspect101]

I think he says that it is scummy that your only action was to jump on a popular wagon...

it wasn't a bandwagon for sake of bandwagoning. He had a very bad excuse for all of his rebutles and he had an over complicated character. It was a very logical choice.... unlike....

f*ck it, vote drench

there is nothing else going on at the moment and he has peaked my scumdar all game.

See, on page 24, only PMChugh was pressurising him and then I jumped on him, resulting in a developing bandwagon. I then unvoted, because Drench gave a claim, which would be daft to lynch him after the claim he gave!

Vote suspect - not an OMGUS but I think he is involved with Drench some way, possibly his godfather.

the claim he gave was a little wishy-washy, and you jumped off because of that. just because he claimed does not mean he is innocent, as we proved, but if you say that was your reason.....

I did not vote for you or ask for you to be lynched. I asked that you be investigated because I thought we were going to get a lynch and it was going into night. something that could have easily proven your alliance.

and no, it is a OMGUS vote.

[sheepofdumb]

Very sorry about my lack of posts. I was vacationing in DC for a week. I totally forgot about CC or I would have gotten on once or twice.

[nagerous]

I think he says that it is scummy that your only action was to jump on a popular wagon...

it wasn't a bandwagon for sake of bandwagoning. He had a very bad excuse for all of his rebutles and he had an over complicated character. It was a very logical choice.... unlike....

f*ck it, vote drench

there is nothing else going on at the moment and he has peaked my scumdar all game.

See, on page 24, only PMChugh was pressurising him and then I jumped on him, resulting in a developing bandwagon. I then unvoted, because Drench gave a claim, which would be daft to lynch him after the claim he gave!

Vote suspect - not an OMGUS but I think he is involved with Drench some way, possibly his godfather.

the claim he gave was a little wishy-washy, and you jumped off because of that. just because he claimed does not mean he is innocent, as we proved, but if you say that was your reason.....

I did not vote for you or ask for you to be lynched. I asked that you be investigated because I thought we were going to get a lynch and it was going into night. something that could have easily proven your alliance.

and no, it is a OMGUS vote.

Investigated when our cop is dead?

Also, learn into what OMGUS means

[Suspect101]

I think he says that it is scummy that your only action was to jump on a popular wagon...

it wasn't a bandwagon for sake of bandwagoning. He had a very bad excuse for all of his rebutles and he had an over complicated character. It was a very logical choice.... unlike....

f*ck it, vote drench

there is nothing else going on at the moment and he has peaked my scumdar all game.

See, on page 24, only PMChugh was pressurising him and then I jumped on him, resulting in a developing bandwagon. I then unvoted, because Drench gave a claim, which would be daft to lynch him after the claim he gave!

Vote suspect - not an OMGUS but I think he is involved with Drench some way, possibly his godfather.

the claim he gave was a little wishy-washy, and you jumped off because of that. just because he claimed does not mean he is innocent, as we proved, but if you say that was your reason.....

I did not vote for you or ask for you to be lynched. I asked that you be investigated because I thought we were going to get a lynch and it was going into night. something that could have easily proven your alliance.

and no, it is a OMGUS vote.

Investigated when our cop is dead?

Also, learn into what OMGUS means

there is no other way to investigate besides through a cop role? hummm, and I thought you had played this game before and were really good.

and I know what OMGUS means, in this case, it means that you and your vote suck.

[Iliad]

I think he says that it is scummy that your only action was to jump on a popular wagon...

it wasn't a bandwagon for sake of bandwagoning. He had a very bad excuse for all of his rebutles and he had an over complicated character. It was a very logical choice.... unlike....

f*ck it, vote drench

there is nothing else going on at the moment and he has peaked my scumdar all game.

See, on page 24, only PMChugh was pressurising him and then I jumped on him, resulting in a developing bandwagon. I then unvoted, because Drench gave a claim, which would be daft to lynch him after the claim he gave!

Vote suspect - not an OMGUS but I think he is involved with Drench some way, possibly his godfather.

the claim he gave was a little wishy-washy, and you jumped off because of that. just because he claimed does not mean he is innocent, as we proved, but if you say that was your reason.....

I did not vote for you or ask for you to be lynched. I asked that you be investigated because I thought we were going to get a lynch and it was going into night. something that could have easily proven your alliance.

and no, it is a OMGUS vote.

Investigated when our cop is dead?

Also, learn into what OMGUS means

there is no other way to investigate besides through a cop role? hummm, and I thought you had played this game before and were really good.

and I know what OMGUS means, in this case, it means that you and your vote suck.

You are really, really not helping your case.

Your predecessor did not post, and your only action was to jump on a wagon and then to make a very shaky accusation. Not only that you used a hyperbole in it too.

As far as I am concerned you a very good lynch for today

[spiesr]

We have to keep our eye on those motioning for the lynch of an unpopular player...

[Snorri1234]

We have to keep our eye on those motioning for the lynch of an unpopular player...

We shouldn't ignore the unpopular player either. I'm willing to accept Suspects claim that he jumped on the bandwagon because Drench was an obvious scum but he hasn't given a very good explanation as to why we should trust him on nagerous.


I don't know about lynching him though, he doesn't strike me as mafia.

[Suspect101]

We have to keep our eye on those motioning for the lynch of an unpopular player...

We shouldn't ignore the unpopular player either. I'm willing to accept Suspects claim that he jumped on the bandwagon because Drench was an obvious scum but he hasn't given a very good explanation as to why we should trust him on nagerous.


I don't know about lynching him though, he doesn't strike me as mafia.

I do not think that nag should be lynched. I just said he should be investigated at night for reasons stated previously. That small comment seems like it has hit a nerve with two players. I understand nag being upset with me asking for him to be investigated, but it just seems like right now iliad is grabbing at anything he can find and trying to get me lynched without thinking anything through. simply read his comment.

[Snorri1234]

We have to keep our eye on those motioning for the lynch of an unpopular player...

We shouldn't ignore the unpopular player either. I'm willing to accept Suspects claim that he jumped on the bandwagon because Drench was an obvious scum but he hasn't given a very good explanation as to why we should trust him on nagerous.


I don't know about lynching him though, he doesn't strike me as mafia.

I do not think that nag should be lynched. I just said he should be investigated at night for reasons stated previously.

I never said you thought that. I think your reasoning for saying an investigation be spend on nagerous isn't very solid.

[Snorri1234]

after reading through everything again.......

vote drench

nagerous should be looked at tonight.

The f*ck you talking about?

I trust spiesr

vote drench

I trust spiesr as well, you just seemed to back drench a few times. that is all.

I mean, you said this but I haven't seen anywhere that nagerous backed drench. Why did you say this?

[Suspect101]

after reading through everything again.......

vote drench

nagerous should be looked at tonight.

The f*ck you talking about?

I trust spiesr

vote drench

I trust spiesr as well, you just seemed to back drench a few times. that is all.

I mean, you said this but I haven't seen anywhere that nagerous backed drench. Why did you say this?

reasons being that nag claimed drench was "cleared in his book", I quoted the wording in my other posts.

[Snorri1234]

reasons being that nag claimed drench was "cleared in his book", I quoted the wording in my other posts.

That's not the same as "backing someone a few times". Sure, I think it's poorly chosen as it wasn't a very convincing role-claim, but that is hardly a good reason to call for an investigation. (Particularly since, if there is any investigating role left, you and / are also suspicious and I would say with a far better reason.)

[spiesr]

We have to keep our eye on those motioning for the lynch of an unpopular player...

We shouldn't ignore the unpopular player either.

Well yes, I didn't mean that we shouldn't maybe lynch said player, just that we should make a notice of those advocates...

[Iliad]

reasons being that nag claimed drench was "cleared in his book", I quoted the wording in my other posts.

That's not the same as "backing someone a few times". Sure, I think it's poorly chosen as it wasn't a very convincing role-claim, but that is hardly a good reason to call for an investigation. (Particularly since, if there is any investigating role left, you and / are also suspicious and I would say with a far better reason.)

Not only did nag not back him drench at all, rather once nag seemed satisfied with drench's claim. Remember drench had most of us fooled at that point, so don't say you just jumped on a an obvious scum, he did not back him a few times but rather "once"

And not only that, but-YOU HAVE NO OTHER POSTS. Your posts are-you being replaced and promising to re-read, you jumping on drench's wagon and throwing an accusation and nag and then one more saying that nag backed drench.

People do we really need more proof?

Let's see-
Militant doesn't post at all and goes inactive. Suspect "replaces" him and lurks masterfully. Not only that but he votes for an "obvious scum" jumping on a wagon. How convenient that he distances himself away from the mafia with that vote. Remember that at that point drench is not "obvious scum". Drench was suspicious but it only became obvious the next day after the watcher caught him. And now suspect is continually lying and twisting the truth. Apparently nag unvoting after drench came up with a fakeclaim that fooled us all, is backing him a few times. Nag backed him up a few times in that one post. Obviously

And apparently he explained it in his other posts. He only began posting again after I accused him. Fancy that-didn't post at all until threw in a vote on a wagon, and an accusation, and didn't post at all until he suddenly started posting after accusations flew against him.
What does that mean if a player doesn't post but suddenly starts once there are accusation against him-that's right that he was checking the thread but not posting. Lurking.

Bandwagoning, lying, lurking suspect has them all.

Now about nag.

Well. Since there's absolutely no way for me to defend myself, and I'm screwed anyway, allow me to truly claim.

I'm Krug and Dr. Van Kruglor (same person). That part was true. I am a ...well...I'll let MM tell you. But, unfortunately for a faction, I was the only way for that faction to have a mole in another faction and bring down said faction. You've just wasted it. I hope you're happy. Nyeh. I enjoyed playing, and good luck to the faction that I'm part of. Even though I was trying to kill said faction, but hell. Good luck anyways.

(Also, BAH.)

Drench here implies that there is more than one faction, ie more than one mafia. That very well may be the case-I'll check the scenes for different roles. Maybe suspect is another usurper, naively trying to throw down nag. Suspect's accusation of nag does seem to be quite trying and pushy and trying to appear nonchalant.

I'll look for evidence of multiple mafia factions and which ones are they.

Meanwhile lynch the lying lurker.

[Iliad]

No-One Is Safe

Not even the son of death himself, little Grim Junior. With night having well and truely fallen, those who walk in shadow are at their most deadly. The master of evil had sent his best assassin to wipe out one particular member of the drawn. This assassin also appeared to be a ninja, dressed all in black, with only eye-holes cut out, and unlike TIN, was very good at killing.
Grim Jr on the other hand was only 10, very inexperienced at reaping and currently in his mortal state. When cornered by the ninja, he brought out his sythe, and a blade duel commenced. As they fought, Grim was surprised to hear that the noises the ninja was making were not manly. Was this a woman...?
The end saw experience winning the day. Grim Jr was found the next morning, stabs and cuts adorning his body. He was one of the town's most powerful characters. A GRIM blow had been struck against them...


william18 - Grim Jr (3-shot Vigilante) has been killed!

Day 2 Begins!

It's Getting Personal

As the second night descends, we will accompany the primary antagonist of our story. Not much can be said of his character, other than his trademark hat that strikes fear into his enemies. Pleased with the results of his assassin the night previous, he decided to indulge in a bit of DIW. Being lazy, his town target was chosen purely at random. After just 36 seconds, it was over. On the way back, he was certain there were a pair of eyes following his movements...
Not much was left of the body, and the only way the town discovered who it actually was the following morning was by noticing who was absent from the group. Considering she was a powerful individual, this did nothing to lift the town's spirits. [/i]


AceArtemis - Benny (White Mage) has been killed!

Day 3 Begins!

I'll try and make the nights shorter, although people dropping out every night doesn't help.

Lucas was a sensible, intelligent and not particuarly lucky member of the drawn, and tonight, he would play the central role of tonight's twisting events. He had taken it upon himself to deduce who were behind the recent killings, and now he was on his way to spy on another member of the drawn. Peering into the window of this individual's house, he could just make out his shape in the gloom, while the moon casted his shadow on the far wall. Noticing this made Lucas reel back in horror, was this a demon? He had horns! Clearly he wasn't a protagonist, and Lucas knew he had to reveal his investigation to the drawn. Watching him go, a solitary figure looked over the rim of his cardboard box in a nearby alley, and above him on the roof, yet another character was watching the events below.
The ninja returned for this night's kill, and the person running through the streets proved to be an obvious target. From the roof of an overlooking building, it took just one shuriken throw to the neck to bring him down. Lucas bled to death in the middle of the street - his discovery was for naught.


pmchugh - Lucas (Cop) has been killed!

Day 4 Begins!

Suspect 101 replaces militant

Okay so these are the three night scenes. In all the scenes it seems a ninja carried out the murders. Also the black hat guy from xkcd seems to be the godfather. However I did find things that were very interesting.

The large italics seem to prove it's the xkcd guy with the hat. However the huge font highlights a very important fact-the godfather didd not send in his kill during night 2 and it was randomly chosen for him. And guess who was inactive then. And guess who was swiftly replaced by next night. We very well may have the godfather on our hands here.

[Suspect101]

reasons being that nag claimed drench was "cleared in his book", I quoted the wording in my other posts.

That's not the same as "backing someone a few times". Sure, I think it's poorly chosen as it wasn't a very convincing role-claim, but that is hardly a good reason to call for an investigation. (Particularly since, if there is any investigating role left, you and / are also suspicious and I would say with a far better reason.)

you are right, I used a poor choice of words. And I did not assume that all the investigating rolls were gone, this is not a C9 so more than 1 investigator roll could be out there. All I did was make a suggestion that he should be looked at, not lynched, not killed, nothing. I stated my opinion, and that is all.

[Snorri1234]

Right.


Vote Suspect101.

Bring up a claim.

[Snorri1234]

reasons being that nag claimed drench was "cleared in his book", I quoted the wording in my other posts.

That's not the same as "backing someone a few times". Sure, I think it's poorly chosen as it wasn't a very convincing role-claim, but that is hardly a good reason to call for an investigation. (Particularly since, if there is any investigating role left, you and / are also suspicious and I would say with a far better reason.)

you are right, I used a poor choice of words. And I did not assume that all the investigating rolls were gone, this is not a C9 so more than 1 investigator roll could be out there. All I did was make a suggestion that he should be looked at, not lynched, not killed, nothing. I stated my opinion, and that is all.

Actually, I meant that nagerous used a poor choice of words.

I don't assume all investigating roles are gone either, but I'd say it's fair that there aren't more than two at the most. So advocating that the remaining investigator go for someone that hasn't raised any suspicion is pretty weird.

[spiesr]

At this point we might as well do what appears to be the road we are maybe heading on and have suspect fork over a claim. Towards this end I vote suspect. He should soon have enough that he will attempt some sort of claim...