Rolegift Mafia 2 Endgame: Give 'til it Hurts

[Yomiel]

I've already said the investigation itself may be wrong, but the easiest way to even come close to figuring that out is to lynch LSU, who is acting suspicious anyway.

[/]

Vote Count:

Yomiel (4) - Campin_Killer , Rodion , LSU Tiger Josh , ???
LSU Tiger Josh (4) - thechuck51 , Yomiel , jak111 , jonty125

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch
deadline Wednsday

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Same old stuff from yomiel. My gift is either vigilante or tracker. As I said before once the cop report gets a different result and at that point people think I am the best choice of the two than so be it. I personally will go off of tracking reports when they show someone going to a dead guy. As was pointed out before magic 8 balls are completely random. I also find it suspicious that yomiel claimed it was the same kind as pancake after pancake stated it. Yomiel is to the most suspicious today with her same old stuff. Lynching her would eliminate a lot of the drama and constant repeating of the same old shit with someone else able to receive the cop gift.

[Yomiel]

Now there's another weird post from LSU. He tries to make me look bad, even though I barely said anything.

The Cop has gotten the result, and you need to die for us to test it. You came up as Mafia, and you've acted like your Mafia.

You also suddenly find it odd that I claimed to have the same item as another player, when this info was posted a long while ago?

And you also claim your gift must be one of two things, but there is no guarantee of that.

[spiesr]

And you also claim your gift must be one of two things, but there is no guarantee of that.

If he is telling the truth about who he sent it too it is pretty much is guaranteed.

[jak111]

And you also claim your gift must be one of two things, but there is no guarantee of that.

If he is telling the truth about who he sent it too it is pretty much is guaranteed.

Unless PMC is tricking us all, but I doubt it. So much WIFOM with this game... ARGH!!!!

[Yomiel]

I don't doubt it. Lying about whether or not you got a gift hardly seems crazy. It casts doubt and makes it so you don't have to lie about whatever gift you did get, which could lead to complications later. And once it's revealed there are roles like thieves in the games...

[Rodion]

Milkshake?

[Yomiel]

This is getting a little weird. Crazy was on at least twice today, but he still hasn't really posted anything, even though we're all kind of waiting on him.

[pmchugh]

Hohohohoho, Merry Christmas everyone.

Unfortunately I was not paying too much attention before, as I forgot to report that I sent a gift to speisr for being a good little boy last night, yet he only received a lump of coal... what trickery is this?

Also I am sick of people being sick of the little elf yomiel. As far as I can see, yomiel is being voted for nothing other than being disliked and all the votes seem pointless. Campin, WIDNFUSINGITTWUHAINTN. (While I do not find you suspicious in this game, I think the way you have acted is not that nice- the acronym is bound to catch on.)

Present coal to reindeer LSU- As much as I liked the sound of speisrs plan this is just simpler. In fact I would continue to push this idea (of investigating in two halfs) so we know which is which.

[Yomiel]

O_O?

[Hensow]

with out Crazy stating what gits shield received I presume \ has pm him with the relevant information I understand the game as follows
Yomiel needs to stop reposing the same post every hour and even if he isn't scum him be lynched would make day 3 more fun
LSU has been found guilty by the cop Yomiel hold however we do not know the sanity

but if we find LSU alignment we will be able to divide the cop in to the following:
>if LSU is scum then the cop is ether sane or paranoid but we will assume it to be sane
>if LSU is town it is ether paranoid or insane if it is insane it we find sucm as "not guilty" if it is paranoid it will never find a sole "not guilty" and so we can use it to find scum but not rule people out as definitely town so long as we can identify it.

since I see no reason why spiesr's plan should fail and if it dose gifters will be able to clam.
Therefor I will vote LSU

[Yomiel]

Stop trying to start trouble over stupid stuff.-.-

And what about chugh? Did he just do something?

[Rodion]

Unfortunately I was not paying too much attention before, as I forgot to report that I sent a gift to speisr for being a good little boy last night, yet he only received a lump of coal... what trickery is this?

1 - Pmghugh claimed he got 0 gifts
2 - Spiesr claimed he got 0 gifts
3 - Jak claimed Safari's item generated 2 steals, thus explaining 2 gifts not making it to their original destinations
4 - Jak claimed he gifted pmchugh - 1 gift not reaching its destination
5 - LSU claimed he gifted pmchugh - 2 gifts not reaching its destination
6 - Pmchugh claimed he gifted Spiesr - 3 gifts not reaching its destination

My conclusion is that we have at least one liar among PMC, Spiesr, Jak and LSU.

Milkshake?!

[everywhere116]

Unfortunately I was not paying too much attention before, as I forgot to report that I sent a gift to speisr for being a good little boy last night, yet he only received a lump of coal... what trickery is this?

1 - Pmghugh claimed he got 0 gifts
2 - Spiesr claimed he got 0 gifts
3 - Jak claimed Safari's item generated 2 steals, thus explaining 2 gifts not making it to their original destinations
4 - Jak claimed he gifted pmchugh - 1 gift not reaching its destination
5 - LSU claimed he gifted pmchugh - 2 gifts not reaching its destination
6 - Pmchugh claimed he gifted Spiesr - 3 gifts not reaching its destination

My conclusion is that we have at least one liar among PMC, Spiesr, Jak and LSU.

Milkshake?!

I don't remember Jak claiming that he sent his gift to pmc. What page is it on?

[jonty125]

I still can't believe we haven't lynched LSU. Maybe I should construct a case, and people will listen to that over a guilty cop result.

[Rodion]

Everywhere: viewtopic.php?p=3812067#p3812067

[Yomiel]

I still want to know what chugh did to LSU...

I'm on my other computer, so I can't check my notes regarding Jak.

But chugh suddenly saying what he did really strikes me as odd.

Hmm... How do we bring Milkshake to the yard?

Ask the host to prod?

[jak111]

Unfortunately I was not paying too much attention before, as I forgot to report that I sent a gift to speisr for being a good little boy last night, yet he only received a lump of coal... what trickery is this?

1 - Pmghugh claimed he got 0 gifts
2 - Spiesr claimed he got 0 gifts
3 - Jak claimed Safari's item generated 2 steals, thus explaining 2 gifts not making it to their original destinations
4 - Jak claimed he gifted pmchugh - 1 gift not reaching its destination
5 - LSU claimed he gifted pmchugh - 2 gifts not reaching its destination
6 - Pmchugh claimed he gifted Spiesr - 3 gifts not reaching its destination

My conclusion is that we have at least one liar among PMC, Spiesr, Jak and LSU.

Milkshake?!

I don't remember Jak claiming that he sent his gift to pmc. What page is it on?

I sent it to PMC, I claimed it shortly after he said he didn't receive a gift. Now with 3 gifts MISSING (2 stolen by me) a third gift is a lier. However, atm, I believe Spiesr since I tracked him nowhere last night. HOWEVER, if LSU is lynched and he turns up mafia, that will explain where the third came from. A guilty result on him + a 3rd uncounted for missing gift makes no sense.

But what strikes me odd is that pmc claims to have sent it to Spiesr... I tracked spiesr.. so unless he either didn't use it or a busdrive happened somewhere, pmc could be lying unless that's the other gift I stole. (I mean what's the chances of me stealing both gifts from PMC). So I feel as though we've caught a scum here. Either LSU is lying and just dug his own grave deeper, or PMC is lying causing us to take another day to get him.

[jonty125]

I sent it to PMC, I claimed it shortly after he said he didn't receive a gift. Now with 3 gifts MISSING (2 stolen by me)

I forgot to send mine yesterday. (I've already sent today's)

[pmchugh]

I still can't believe we haven't lynched LSU. Maybe I should construct a case, and people will listen to that over a guilty cop result.

I agree that naughty child LSU should be lunched, it is certainly the easiest way to test reliability of the investigations (and also of yomiel after further investigations). I am not sure what to make of the doubly named gift though.

Mrs Rodion Claus, my wife, has also been acting rather strangely. His lack of useful contribution combined with vote on yomiel make it look like he is trying to go for the easiest lynch. inb4 essay reply.

Merrrry Christmas everyone!

fastposted. It would be most foolish of dear old santa to fake claim that I sent a gift to good girl speisr, given the track and his claim of not having received a gift. It is possible there is another type of roll affecting the distribution of gifts, or that I have a dud gift.

p.s. If you forget to send your gift, ask the mod nicely and as early as you can and you may be rewarded.. or punished.

[Yomiel]

jak, are you sure you're the one who got the alcohol?>_>

[jak111]

jak, are you sure you're the one who got the alcohol?>_>

Aye, part of my ancestory is from Scotland. I be able to drink down the rum with no problem.

Anyway, Jonty, not sending your gift is not the 3 we are talking about. 2 people sent to PMC, and 1 sent to Spiesr. I only stole 2 gifts, so one gift is a lier.

At the moment I think I stole my own gift and PMC's gift and that LSU is our possible lier. If not I may have stole mine and LSU's and PMC is the lier. However, I believe Spiesr is cleared.

[Yomiel]

I think Chugh should be focused on tonight.

But yeah, let's get on with lynching LSU already. We can't keep letting one person hold the game up.

[everywhere116]

@Rodion: Thank you. How do you link to specific posts by the way? I could never figure out how to do that.

jak, are you sure you're the one who got the alcohol?>_>

Aye, part of my ancestory is from Scotland. I be able to drink down the rum with no problem.

Anyway, Jonty, not sending your gift is not the 3 we are talking about. 2 people sent to PMC, and 1 sent to Spiesr. I only stole 2 gifts, so one gift is a lier.

At the moment I think I stole my own gift and PMC's gift and that LSU is our possible lier. If not I may have stole mine and LSU's and PMC is the lier. However, I believe Spiesr is cleared.

I suppose now we have two reasons to doubt LSU, and we only have 2 days left. Well, Yomiel, you get your wish, at least from me, today.

Vote LSU