Coheed & Cambria mafia - Town Winnn.

[/]

GA7, IF YOU DON'T EXPLAIN YOUR CLAIM ABOUT SELIN WITHIN THE NEXT 24 HOURS, I WILL HAVE TO ASSUME THAT YOU ARE JUST SCUM STIRRING TROUBLE.

I think it was supposed to be a joke, since Selin always accuses people of being a very specific role in the same fashion.

[Skoffin]

Boo! Seems I was wrong about Sierra, if only he would stop acting so dodgy

But I was right about pancake atleast Let's see how I do on my third hunch. I still suspect Narkyboy, for my previous reasons stated, plus I do not agree with the reason of 'a survivor is a good lynch'. I think survivors are a crap lynch, and those that say otherwise are usually scum just trying to hurry things up so they don't get turned on next.

Vote Nark

[Skittles!]

VOTE COUNT

Clive (2) - Mandalorian2298, jnd94
Selin (2) - ga7, Anarkistsdream
Anarkistsdream (1) - Skoffin

With 13 alive, 7 to lynch

Need to prod some people, possibly replace.

Also, PCM will be replacing ace1217.

If you lot haven't figured out, I'm not prodding people this game because it is mainly a waste of time. I just will replace them, and if they come back, they can be on the replacement list after the person that replaced them is dead.

[Skoffin]

Bloody hell, every time someone says PCM I think Pacman for some reason. Bugger it, I'm just going to call him that from now on.

[pancakemix]

HIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII.

[danodukebb]

sooo theres not much been going on worth writing...
thats why i've been inactive but im back

[danodukebb]

and drunk, even though I was told not to write in here drunk anyomre

[Anarkistsdream]

Boo! Seems I was wrong about Sierra, if only he would stop acting so dodgy

But I was right about pancake atleast Let's see how I do on my third hunch. I still suspect Narkyboy, for my previous reasons stated, plus I do not agree with the reason of 'a survivor is a good lynch'. I think survivors are a crap lynch, and those that say otherwise are usually scum just trying to hurry things up so they don't get turned on next.

Vote Nark

Sorry that you are, as always, wrong...

[mandalorian2298]

I just recieved a PM from Ga7 (not about this game). Hence: unvote vote Ga7. How about prodding him, Skittles?

[ga7]

I just recieved a PM from Ga7 (not about this game). Hence: unvote vote Ga7. How about prodding him, Skittles?

I'm not caught up with this game yet, will post something of relevance later today My accusation was semi serious and I'm surprised no one even saw the logic behind it.

[ga7]

K so my reasoning. Mandy claims to have targeted Selin, Illy claims to have protected AD. There was 3 kills last night. Unless there's a busdriver (who should claim right away to avoid confusion if he had anything to do with this) I believe scum is at least one of those 3.
If Illy lied about being a doc, actual doc might have protected Selin. We can't really run that risk though IMO, as Illy's claim kinda made sense.
If Mandy lied about being a vig (which wouldn't be that surprising considering there were 3 kills, but not sure) he might be mafia claiming to have targeted his GF for safety, or just claiming to have targeted someone random. I doubt it's the case seeing Selin's absence of reaction to this. The fact Mandy is so defensive of Selin brings some credit to this theory also.
Basically in case no one lied there's still the possibility Mandy was just blocked (more doubtful than busdriver since there was 3 kills) or Selin is actually bulletproof of some kind. But I just don't find it likely seeing their reaction.

[militant]

I decided to re read a bit:

Shouldn't there be a bandwagon by now? Cumon there's no dito in this game we can get away with it

NOTE

ace1217 has replaced ditocoaf.

Icedagger said this on page 5, now Dito had set to be replaced by then, he was still in the game, although not talking much, he was still skimming although no one picked up on that. Fos Ice for skimming.

a whole lot of nothing on day one, but mehh that's to be expected

Dano said this on page 6, maybe him just being silly or he could not be bothered to say anything, I think he did this so to post, thus making it appear like he is active and posting, but not actually contributing anything of substance, kinda like submarining but posting nothing so to make it look like he is not submarining, if that makes sense Also saying nothing much happened in the first 6 pages is ridiculous, mandy was forced to claim on page 7, he didn't go to lynch-3 in a page, this further goes to validate my point Dano was kinda skimming.

not much going on so vote sierra

we don't have anything to go off of

Page 9. Again, I think this is ridiculous, a lot went on, Iliad messed up by not wanting to suggest a non random lynch, mandy had claimed just two pages before, yet Dano said not much is going on, this could be because Dano is not the greatest mafia player or he is better than we expect.

Once again, after Iliad slips up and Sierra, ga7 and Ad all vote Iliad, Dano comes along, says very little and joins the bandwagon:

yes, backtracking is never good
unvote
vote illiad

Now on page 11Dano said:

unvote for now

let me go back and think, it's been a while since I read them...but give me a few minutes

Then 30 minutes later he went on to say:

vote illiad

I was looking back and checking some stuff out
but I'm pretty sure that Dr. Hohenberger DID indeed die

Now I cannot fault Dano at all here, he is knowledgeable about the theme, which is useful, he unvotes to check out Iliads claim, then votes again when it seems like he has found sufficient evidence to make him think Iliad is indeed guilty, again, I cannot fault Dano for this, but what made me suspicious is his next post:

don't kill me if i am wrong however, but i remember something about his creations being in danger after he's dead...

Pancake put his trust in Dano and voted Iliad, Dano then almost backtracks, it seems to me, after some thinking, that Dano may have just posed to check out Iliads role for half and hour, but actually just used his posed investigation to vote for Iliad, he wants Iliad lynched, so he unvotes then goes to check out the role, and then votes again. I think Dano is manipulating everybody trust, we all know Dano knows the theme, so he is using that to throw us on the wrong path. This is just a theory though.

Now page 12, the page after the above quotes where Dano checked out the role, and confirmed he thought Iliad, on the previous page, eh voted Iliad after his search, but on page 12 he votes him again:

...unvote

i don't really believe him..but to be on the safe side

Again, I think this goes towards my ealier theory about Dano not posting much just to get along and make it look like he is contributing, but here he is backtracking, and cannot make up his mind. Wha also make me wonder, was how Dano found out sufffient information about the theme and came to the conclusion that Iliad was in fact scum, but now, he dones not trust him. Call me stupid, but if you dont trust someone you would want to vote them, yet Dano unvotes Iliad while stating that he does not trust him, again, backtracking and stalling, making it look like he is contributing.

Dano votes No lynch:

i vote a non-lynch as well,
I'm just worried my knowledge of C&C will cause the mafia to vote me off...
but on the other hand, skittles said that it won't be verbatim to the comics and songs..

(I removed the lyrics to save space)
As previously stated a no lynch would only help scum.

vote pcm

for the record selin, i never vote hoped, i voted for someone, then went back to check the story and then unvoted...i believe i only voted for one person, or 2...

More reason-less bandwagoning once Skittles set the deadline on page 19.

After PCM's lynch, Dano asks fo Doc protection which I think is funny, simply because of his knowledge of the theme, I can think of 2 claimed town players that would be more deserving of protection, a cop and a doc, two claimed pro town players, I think this is a ploy to confuse a noob doc into protecting a scum.

Sorry that was really long, but Vote Dano

[danodukebb]

noob question..why is skimming bad?

[militant]

noob question..why is skimming bad?

My tummy went all bad then, you know that feeling you get when you go down a hill real quick in a car, anyway, skimming is bad because it kinda defetas the point of mafia, to find the scum you only have actions and what they say, now if they dont say anything, it kinda seems like they dont want to talk in case they slip up. Skimming is bad for other reasons too but they escape me at the minute, I shall post them as I remember them.

Is that all you have to say, you dont have an opinion on anything I wrote?

[Anarkistsdream]

Damn, militant... That was all very well-written.

[militant]

Damn, militant... That was all very well-written.

Thanks, but which post do you mean, the big ass one or the explanation?

[Anarkistsdream]

Damn, militant... That was all very well-written.

Thanks, but which post do you mean, the big ass one or the explanation?

Big ass one...

[ga7]

Agreed, good job on the Dano case Mili I agree there's something too fishy about Dano's behavior so far but would like to explore other leads first; it might be a good option to fall back on though.

[danodukebb]

Dont really have much to say about your "investigation"

I "backtracked" yes, because I tried to figure some stuff out in the story and check peoples stories to see if they checked out

I am still noobish in mafia but trying to get smarter/better

I hate to say this but you're big post seems almost scummy to me, that you would go out that far and deep on a whim..

Notice how I haven't posted too much lately? because I'm trying to figure some stuff out, do what you have to but don't blame me

[sheepofdumb]

Well there's two things we can do. Not care if dano has information about the theme because we can always go to Wikipedia to find that stuff out or download the comics and read them for ourselves. Or we could care that he can check claims better than we can and keep him alive because of this advantage he has. In which case he has a lot more freedom to act more scummy then we do.

[pancakemix]

Well there's two things we can do. Not care if dano has information about the theme because we can always go to Wikipedia to find that stuff out or download the comics and read them for ourselves. Or we could care that he can check claims better than we can and keep him alive because of this advantage he has. In which case he has a lot more freedom to act more scummy then we do.

And if he's scum?

[danodukebb]

then you're screwed,
whats the other leads right now?

I can see if I can figure some shit out

[sheepofdumb]

Well there's two things we can do. Not care if dano has information about the theme because we can always go to Wikipedia to find that stuff out or download the comics and read them for ourselves. Or we could care that he can check claims better than we can and keep him alive because of this advantage he has. In which case he has a lot more freedom to act more scummy then we do.

And if he's scum?

If he's scum he can hide under the cover of "well I know the theme better than everyone." If he's not town then it looks like we have a pretty good candidate for day 2's lynch.

[danodukebb]

i wouldn't go so fast there sheepy

[mandalorian2298]

K so my reasoning. Mandy claims to have targeted Selin, Illy claims to have protected AD. There was 3 kills last night. Unless there's a busdriver (who should claim right away to avoid confusion if he had anything to do with this) I believe scum is at least one of those 3.
If Illy lied about being a doc, actual doc might have protected Selin. We can't really run that risk though IMO, as Illy's claim kinda made sense.
If Mandy lied about being a vig (which wouldn't be that surprising considering there were 3 kills, but not sure) he might be mafia claiming to have targeted his GF for safety, or just claiming to have targeted someone random. I doubt it's the case seeing Selin's absence of reaction to this. The fact Mandy is so defensive of Selin brings some credit to this theory also.
Basically in case no one lied there's still the possibility Mandy was just blocked (more doubtful than busdriver since there was 3 kills) or Selin is actually bulletproof of some kind. But I just don't find it likely seeing their reaction.

Please explain the bold part Ga7. How am I defensive of Selin? I gave you 24 hours to explain the reasons behind your claim tha Selin is the Godfather and then I voted you because the way you dropped an accusation and then went into hiding seemed as scummy as hell to me.
After I read your first post, I was hoping that you are some kind of uber-Cop capable of finding Godfathers. But, given that your accusation had been totaly unfounded, you are promoted to No. 2 on my Scum-list.
Unvote vote Clive (because he is still No 1 ) SFOS GA7