[Exp] CYOC! #4 Endgame! Town wins, you filthy animals

[dakky21]

Also, Please read the rules I have posted. I'm not singling anyone out, but the rules are there for a reason.

You just said ptlowe copied your PM. So he is not lying. Maybe about the alignment.
Well, anyway, after some thinking I will

unvote
vote ptlowe

Because if he is saying the truth about his role, we're pretty much stuck with him and we can't find his alignment unless a cop investigates him today.
I'd rather use my kill on someone who I think might be mafia, well, that is double-edged sword as well. Currently set on Tim, benga, endgame or Streaker.

[pancakemix]

I wasn't gonna come out and say it, but I think Dakky's correct about ptlowe's post. With that in mind, I can't really vote for PT because he's not lying about the role and I can't see him as scum because that's just too strong for mafia to have.

[ptlowe]

Also, Please read the rules I have posted. I'm not singling anyone out, but the rules are there for a reason.

You just said ptlowe copied your PM. So he is not lying. Maybe about the alignment.
Well, anyway, after some thinking I will

unvote
vote ptlowe

Because if he is saying the truth about his role, we're pretty much stuck with him and we can't find his alignment unless a cop investigates him today.
I'd rather use my kill on someone who I think might be mafia, well, that is double-edged sword as well. Currently set on Tim, benga, endgame or Streaker.

unvote vote time i know im not mafia so better to put someone else in the mix im not sure about. Also funny dakky would rather keep a third party then a towny

[ptlowe]

vote Tim

[Marashu]

Also, Please read the rules I have posted. I'm not singling anyone out, but the rules are there for a reason.

Not entirely sure what this is about, but after re-reading the rules, I saw this:

10. Clues or game information may be hidden in the text, but nothing that would give away a player's identity.

Strike keeps posting saying to stop looking into the scene post because it's just flavour, but the mod has pretty much confirmed that it's worth analyzing. I'm not saying we should focus exclusively on it or rely on it like mitch likes to do, but I don't think it's a good idea to be dismissive about it.

I agree with mets that ptlowe is either useless as town because of his claim, or uncheckable scum (and that's assuming he's telling the truth about not being a PGO N1). And since my case on benga isn't picking up steam, deadline is tomorrow, and it's weekend, I would rather see a ptlowe lynch over having both him and Tim lynched.

fp'd by dakky, pcm - if he did copy his role, I'm more inclined to believe that N1 he is not a PGO. I would have voted ptlowe so that we don't hit both him and Tim with a plurality lynch on a weekend when activity is typically low, but dakky's vote made me not need to right yet. I do agree with pt that Wing looking for an excuse to vote for him, and Streaker keeping his vote on pt after saying that benga's his biggest scumread, is weird:

It looks like the only 2 who are pushing against me are 1) my biggest scumread and 2) a claimed 3rd party.

fp'd by ptlowe

[Metsfanmax]

unvote ptlowe

Possibly that was him posting his role PM and not getting modkilled for it -- not sure. But as much as I disagree with posting that much information from your role to prove your point, it would be irresponsible of me to lynch what is now almost certainly town just to get revenge for it. I believe in policy lynches, but not that kind of policy lynch -- that's the mod's job.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Unvote vote Benga

At least that was easy choice.

[TheForgivenOne]

Vote Count:

Marashu – Strike Wolf (1)
TimWoodbury – virus90, Iron Butterfly, ptlowe (3)
Benga – Marashu, pancakemix, wingcmdr Ginkapo (3)
Ptlowe – streaker, dakky21 (2)
dakky21 - madmitch (1)
Iron Butterfly - HotShot53 (1)
Streaker - Benga, Endgame422 (2)

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch. Deadline is set for November 15th at 17:00 CCT. Also a reminder, as per the rules I posted: If no majority is reached at the end of the deadline if made, the player with the most votes will be lynched and the game will enter into the night phase. As of now, a lynch off would occur between TimWoodbury and Benga. This is my last vote count before the deadline tomorrow.

[Metsfanmax]

Ok. I don't at all have a case on Tim, and I think a benga lynch will provide some useful intel, so vote benga.

[TimWoodbury]

vote benga better him then me right??

[ptlowe]

unvote vote strikereminds me, place my vote where it belongs.

[TimWoodbury]

lets try this again vote benga

[benga]

god, hoped it would not come to this, but since I am dead anyway...

I am towns doc, gl town

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

god, hoped it would not come to this, but since I am dead anyway...

I am towns doc, gl town

Character?. This is a feeble claim

[Streaker]

I don't know what happened to my post, there's about a third of it that dissapeared completely, including my unvote, vote benga.

That's L-2, what is your character? And why not just full claim anyway if you claim doc?

[benga]

My char has nothing to do with my role, tough crowd to please

I am harley quinn

Just wanted to help town, don't worry streaker after this you should be lynched,
You fooled the bunch so far, you won't after this

And once again you lie, i am with you on L5

[ptlowe]

My char has nothing to do with my role, tough crowd to please

I am harley quinn

Just wanted to help town, don't worry streaker after this you should be lynched,
You fooled the bunch so far, you won't after this

And once again you lie, i am with you on L5

Any counter claims? Would rather lynch a none PR role?

[Metsfanmax]

Harley Quinn is a villain character in DC Comics. Not clear to me that it would get chosen for a town role, certainly not clear enough to unvote.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Doctor harleen francis quinzel..... but yeah i am with mets here

[strike wolf]

Alignment is random not based on whether a character is good or bad.. Fos Mets and wing.

vote tim
I never bought into the Benga case from the beginning and id rather not lynch a claimed doc day 1.

[strike wolf]

For the record, Harvey was a psychiatrist not a regular doctor in the comics/shows but the claim is close enough that the character makes sense to me.

[Metsfanmax]

Alignment is random not based on whether a character is good or bad.. Fos Mets and wing.

Which is precisely why we cannot use the doc claim alone to avoid a lynch -- a mafia doc is super dangerous to permit to live.

[TimWoodbury]

My char has nothing to do with my role, tough crowd to please

I am harley quinn

Just wanted to help town, don't worry streaker after this you should be lynched,
You fooled the bunch so far, you won't after this

And once again you lie, i am with you on L5

i know thatgs a lie, metsfan was sum cop and his partner i think pixar was skum doc in another game so character and stuff dose matter

[madmitch]

If you only knew which character I chose which role I got (vig, but why), you wouldn't doubt it, but I can't say anything more than that

YOU guys believe Dakky but not Benga , FOS on Tim , Mets, and WCG . especially Wings protecting Dakky again .

[strike wolf]

My char has nothing to do with my role, tough crowd to please

I am harley quinn

Just wanted to help town, don't worry streaker after this you should be lynched,
You fooled the bunch so far, you won't after this

And once again you lie, i am with you on L5

i know thatgs a lie, metsfan was sum cop and his partner i think pixar was skum doc in another game so character and stuff dose matter

Weak logic. I forget the term for it but just because this happens in one game doesn't mean it is in all.

Alignment is random not based on whether a character is good or bad.. Fos Mets and wing.

Which is precisely why we cannot use the doc claim alone to avoid a lynch -- a mafia doc is super dangerous to permit to live.

But that's not what you were saying. You were attacking the character itself even though it has nothing to do with alignment. Also mafia doc is maybe a bit better than a midlevel role not a super dangerous one. Its too late probably to stop the lynch now but I would like this noted for tomorrow if Benga flips town.