No Theme Mafia - town + nag win!

by **Samlen** on Fri Jun 02, 2017 4:46 pm

Sounds pretty believable. At least, it doesn't sound fake enough for me to change my vote. Even explains why pika's claim of roleblocking you was true on both sides. Time to reevaluate the rest of my list though.

by **nagerous** on Sat Jun 03, 2017 5:33 am

Fircoal wrote:*shrugs* I might as well roleclaim I guess.

I'm The Freak with the Binocular Kink.

It's a bit of a confusing role but it works like this. I get to commute out of the town and investigate someone on the same night. I am supposedly immune to all night actions when I do this. However I can only do this twice per game.

If you can tell from what I said I did this on DJ night 1, and no one on night 2.

Given what I know of my role it's not confusing at all how none of the blocks went through, they weren't supposed to. What I don't get is how Nag's first bussy got me. Because reading my role PM that shouldn't have happened.

I think I have a sort of understanding. From reading my PM and Skittles PM to me, my role is meant to be a day action really that affects people in the night.. but I screwed up night 1 and used it as a night action but I think Skittles let me off, but I guess because you had commuted allowed the role block not to work ? Pika role blocked ga7 which prevented his role block on me succeeding as well. Slightly confusing turn of events but sort of explains it a little.

Not sure about night 2, I shoved my bussy into pika this time, but he claims a successful role block on Lovo.

by **Pikanchion** on Sat Jun 03, 2017 6:06 am

I roleblocked Fircoal the first night (or at least tried to), not ga7. Maybe roleblockers can't roleblock other roleblockers? That should explain all of that side of things from my point of view.

As a side note: Fircoal's claim matches the description of their role I was given.

by **Skoffin** on Sat Jun 03, 2017 7:51 am

Sorry ragian, I am blind and I cannot see.

Chuchu sounds believable to me.
Sam, in answer to your question, even if I trust you that doesn't make Lovo town; as I said you can have an enabler for an opposite alignment, it means nothing.

I'm not trusting pika because he's not giving us a name, as such I am inclined to think he's scum and the one we should be lynching. vote pika

by **Skoffin** on Sat Jun 03, 2017 7:55 am

hit enter too soon.
Pika is top suspect for now, other suspects are lovo and ragian.

since you guys asked what a douche is... XD While it's a word commonly used as an insult towards men, a douche is actually a device for cleaning vaginas.

by **lord voldemort** on Sat Jun 03, 2017 7:56 am

That is pika at -1. Full claim????

by **Fircoal** on Sat Jun 03, 2017 10:57 am

I would like to see a full claim from Pika as well.

by **Samlen** on Sat Jun 03, 2017 5:14 pm

Skoffin wrote:Sorry ragian, I am blind and I cannot see.

Chuchu sounds believable to me.
Sam, in answer to your question, even if I trust you that doesn't make Lovo town; as I said you can have an enabler for an opposite alignment, it means nothing.

I'm not trusting pika because he's not giving us a name, as such I am inclined to think he's scum and the one we should be lynching. vote pika

Out of town for weekend so slow replies, but one of my choices for when I die is to allow lord to take2 actions during the night. If he's evil while I'm town then that's just diabolical to give me a chance to super power an evil role.

by **Pikanchion** on Sat Jun 03, 2017 6:25 pm

My role's name is Cute Cat that Scratches.

Skoffin still hasn't made any real claim and vaguely alludes to a post restriction or similar, while claiming to know what happened to the night kill, and Ragian has made an unverifiable claim. I think the two of them or the pairing of Samlen and lord voldemort are the likely scum teams.

by **lord voldemort** on Sat Jun 03, 2017 10:12 pm

At this stage I'm willing to take the chance on lynching pika
Skoffin is a wild unknown because of the post claim. And raigan is probably the other scum
I'll wait until later tonight and lynch if nothing else present itself

by **madmitch** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 1:43 am

Skoffin wrote:My name is Mitch

you are so lucky, and just for that I am going to fill your douche with lemon juice. pucker up :lol:

by **Ragian** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 3:21 am

unvote

That really took a while. Which is weird. I need to piece the actions together in my head before deciding on this. There's something about skoffin that gets me iffy, but for the life of me, I wouldn't be able to say whom she would be scum with

by **lord voldemort** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 5:36 am

vote pika

As discussed already. I don't think that there is any more info to be gained

by **Skittles!** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 7:49 am

Vote Count

Pika (3) - samlen, Skoffin, LOVO
Skoffin (1) - pika

4 to lynch, leaving Pika at -1

by **Ragian** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 8:12 am

See, this is sort of an iffy situation. I think it's either Pika or the ones voting him.

If, for instance, Pika flips town, I would go for those three. I'd probably go for Skoffin before the two others. But if Pika flips scum, I would have to believe that scum would be the ones not voting for Pika. Unless, of course, scum is throwing scum under the bus. I just don't see any reason why scum would do that at this point of the game.

I would really like thoughts from both chu and Nag before hammering...

by **Skoffin** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 8:33 am

I see Pika as going either way. His name seems reasonable, but it just seems odd that he delayed so long over giving it and the only time I've seen him delay like this he happened to be scum. I'd like Pika to give an explanation over why he chose to delay like he did.
The only reason I can come up with is that he took time to fake claim a name, or that is his real name but it also suits a killing type role.
If Pika is town then it looks most likely that ragian is town too as he could have hammered by now.

by **Ragian** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 8:44 am

Yeah, the hammering delay is basically because the two I trust the most are not saying too much, and because the ones voting Pika are the ones I think are scummy. But while I got you, Skoffin. Who would you go for if Pika flips town or scum?

by **Skoffin** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 8:50 am

I... don't really know. I guess lovo is my other suspect. I'm starting to be wary of Nag because the only thing that made him look town was his role ability, but now I'm wondering if it was a mistake to just assume that. His power would give an advantage to scum because he'll get info on two players, but he also wouldn't want too many townies talking to each other.. which would explain why chu was chosen two nights in a row.

by **Pikanchion** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 10:08 am

Skoffin wrote: I see Pika as going either way. His name seems reasonable, but it just seems odd that he delayed so long over giving it and the only time I've seen him delay like this he happened to be scum. I'd like Pika to give an explanation over why he chose to delay like he did.
The only reason I can come up with is that he took time to fake claim a name, or that is his real name but it also suits a killing type role.
If Pika is town then it looks most likely that ragian is town too as he could have hammered by now.

But as I mentioned before (albeit while somewhat inebriated), I did soft claim the role to some degree last night. Ask Fircoal if you want. I'm suspicious of those who pressed so hard for a name when the names show so little and both the mechanical side of my role and the actions I took were fully verified.

Why does nobody else seem concerned that Skoffin refuses to reveal anything of value about her role? -Or the fact we have only one living roleblocker claimed and no kills last night, with no other leads as to why there was no kill, and the plan is now to lynch the roleblocker?

Apparently, there is a way to get this information if we "give enough questions", but nobody seems interested in trying. I tried something but the response was less than helpful, perhaps somebody else would like to try?

by **Pikanchion** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 10:09 am

Skoffin who is mitch?

by **Ragian** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 4:32 pm

I would like to exhaust all methods before lynching anyone today. But how does one access information in a correct way?

@LoVo, why do you think there's no more information to get today?

by **lord voldemort** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 6:50 pm

at this stage the only person i truly trust to be town is samlen.

skof does bring up a point about nag. that it appears to be a too strong town role to have.

I want to hear more from fircoal and nag. they are playing very quiet.

by **Skoffin** on Sun Jun 04, 2017 7:38 pm

unvote for now to avoid a sudden hammer.

Overall names aren't that important, but I do think it can be something useful to know. If someone tried to do a fakeclaim they might try giving a name that doesn't really match the style going on. But modtly, Pika, I'm only really suspicious of it because of that other game we played where you were super scum XD

My namne was she who forgets, the mitch thing was to give you guys a hint at the sort of role I have. Skittles be trolling me yo.
at this point it's highly valuable we get more from nag and chu

by **nagerous** on Mon Jun 05, 2017 2:56 am

Skoffin wrote:I... don't really know. I guess lovo is my other suspect. I'm starting to be wary of Nag because the only thing that made him look town was his role ability, but now I'm wondering if it was a mistake to just assume that. His power would give an advantage to scum because he'll get info on two players, but he also wouldn't want too many townies talking to each other.. which would explain why chu was chosen two nights in a row.

I don't get the information on anyone. They share the information with each other then I have tried to get them to reveal in game thread and that is how we caught ga7 who also helpfully revealed a potential mafia godfather who we are up against.

I am obviously not the mafia godfather - personally I haven't got on the pika lynch because I am not convinced at this stage of scummy credentials

by **nagerous** on Mon Jun 05, 2017 3:00 am

Ragian wrote:unvote

Sorry. Frustrated. I just went with whoever had the most votes on her, and the only one we know has been lying.

Anyway, I'm nothing but a loser VT, so I have nothing to add, nothing to do, nothing to lose. Also, my weird arse name is "He Who Never Had A Prom Date".

@Pika, give us your name. vote Pika

I don't buy it - in strikes game you were 'the guy who rigged the prom king vote' mafia double voter

Now you are another prom related role?? It seems very coincidental and my theory is your subconscious is thinking when making this fake unverifiable claim. Also mafia godfather claiming vanilla townie makes a lot of sense. Dakky was just a 'vanilla' are you called a 'vanilla' or are you a 'townie'?

No Theme Mafia - town + nag win!

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Re: No Theme Mafia - Day 3, let's protect the bussy

Who is online