X-Men Mafia- Town Wins! All roles and night actions revealed

by **safariguy5** on Mon Oct 04, 2010 8:44 pm

confirm. Man, I don't understand the case against anyone. It's really all a lot of fingerpointing and discussion about "feel" votes. Screw your feelings, how about some evidence?

by **AceArtemis** on Mon Oct 04, 2010 11:43 pm

I don't know about aage. He stayed off Naxus the entire time, even voting no lynch day 1 to avoid the Naxus bandwagon. And day 2, he fought against the naxus lynch. As I said earlier, scum don't usually put themselves in the spotlight to defend townies. But if aage is town, he should have been at least a little suspicious of Naxus due to the shady piecewise roleclaim and the fact that townies don't know who the mafia are.

But sensfan's sudden post and vote reeks of OMGUS. FoS.

More analysis to come tomorrow, I've been busy.

by **aage** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 1:35 am

sensfan wrote:Im the worst replacement for jrl? Well, that's a 'feel' vote, in fact more of a i'm scum and know whos not mafia so lets kill him. It's screamin I'm scum kill me. Just because im inactive doesnt mean im not town. Can we just please vote for someone useful? The deadlines close, so we gotta do something. Aage seems like a good choice to lynch tonight, or at least get a roleclaim outta him and get matters straight. But trying to BW on someone who is inactive and is a rookie at this?

vote aage

You weren't exactly replacing anything up to that point, except you were also not posting anything, just like jrl. As I said in an early post, I'm trying to get you back online. The best way to do that is by spicing up the discussion. It worked. I will happily unvote.

by **sensfan** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 6:13 am

AceArtemis wrote:But sensfan's sudden post and vote reeks of OMGUS. FoS.

OMGUS? Really. I think my post was fair and clear and you think its OMGUS?
Aage unvoting me, well i guess ill keep an eye on you. for now, my vote will stand.

by **ga7** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 6:58 am

safariguy5 wrote:confirm. Man, I don't understand the case against anyone. It's really all a lot of fingerpointing and discussion about "feel" votes. Screw your feelings, how about some evidence?

Lol, if you reread where's the evidence that you say exist and that we missed? No matter who we lynch I'm pretty sure it'll be on details so instinct is important. No one slipped up, the only thing that popped out yesterday was Aage's defense of Naxus.

AceArtemis wrote:I don't know about aage. He stayed off Naxus the entire time, even voting no lynch day 1 to avoid the Naxus bandwagon. And day 2, he fought against the naxus lynch. As I said earlier, scum don't usually put themselves in the spotlight to defend townies. But if aage is town, he should have been at least a little suspicious of Naxus due to the shady piecewise roleclaim and the fact that townies don't know who the mafia are.

But sensfan's sudden post and vote reeks of OMGUS. FoS.

More analysis to come tomorrow, I've been busy.

The aage part sums up my thoughts on this matter, except scum putting themselves on the spotlight to defend someone they know is town then clamoring their towniness is a tactic I saw used before. Today is a bit different though as Aage actively tried to divert the attention on other wagons instead of just stubbornly defending Serbia. Anyhow, I guess it's not impossible Aage is just an overtrusting townie so I think Serbia is still the better option.

by **strike wolf** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:28 am

safariguy5 wrote:confirm. Man, I don't understand the case against anyone. It's really all a lot of fingerpointing and discussion about "feel" votes. Screw your feelings, how about some evidence?

I'd agree but we really don't have any significant evidence to go on. Day 2 proved that there is a busdrive. Night 2 proved there was a vig...both probably town roles so why try to flush them out? No cop has stepped forward to say that anyone's guilty, Colton's kind of cop like ability have shown that we have a hider and that ga7 is bulletproof but no evidence to show alignment other than that what those abilities usually mean as far as alignment. So we have some evidence to suggest town roles but no hard evidence to suggest anyone who's directly mafia.

aage and Serbia. I personally see aage as more likely mafia than anyone but I will admit that I am not convinced yet. Serbia not as much so but there are definitely small possible slip ups that point to that possibility.

by **Victor Sullivan** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:36 pm

Could someone give me a short summary as to what has happened? I honestly would rather not go thru 20 pages of posts.

by **ga7** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:41 pm

Doubtfully, reread day 2 at least...

by **edocsil** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:44 pm

I would suggest you read. Any summary would be biased.

by **colton24** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:45 pm

Grrrrsss damn rereading suckzorz

by **ga7** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:46 pm

Btw Serbia, you have less than a day before you're lynched, anything to say?

by **ga7** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:47 pm

Guys, don't ask to be replacements if this little pains you... It's way more useful to get impressions when reading everything at once than just following the thread, more people should do it in general

by **edocsil** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:48 pm

ga7 wrote:Btw Serbia, you have less than a day before you're lynched, anything to say?

Strike has the same number of votes as serbia, and TBH I think it is more likely he is scum then serb. Slip ups and odd behavior > few posts.

by **colton24** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:55 pm

Strike-1
Serb-2

by **ga7** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:57 pm

Ah it's actually Serbs & Aage at 2 votes each. I suppose anything can happen before the deadline then :roll:

by **colton24** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:58 pm

I myself find Serb more scummyz than aage so I will vote serbia and see where that takes us

by **Serbia** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:05 pm

ga7 wrote:Btw Serbia, you have less than a day before you're lynched, anything to say?

I've already said my peace. I really don't want to be forced into a claim based on not saying anything on Day 2, and suggesting that I might just enjoy a threesome (with apologies to my wife, who's reading this as I write it!) There are very few people who have actually been posting a lot here. And people who join disappear too. (how posts are there from sensfan? where has fircoal gone? Hell, victor joined and doesn't even want to read! In fact, based on that alone I'm FOS: victor)

Of course, now I see that you're all putting the pressure on me. I will claim tomorrow if necessary. But I'm telling you all now, I am town.

by **ga7** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:10 pm

Hmm... I'd like to get to the bottom of this today so that if you're town you avoid a mislynch with a too high VC, and now that you mention it I kinda want to wagon Fir for doing one useful post day 2 then disappearing... Ah well your choice.

by **Victor Sullivan** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:11 pm

Read up on D2 happenings and I think the best option currently is to vote...

Serbia

by **edocsil** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:14 pm

Well, now we have a little triangle of 2 votes. Maybe a triple claim and we lynch the worst liar? Sucks, but scum claims are sometimes easy to spot.

I am all for a Fir Wagon!

by **ga7** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:16 pm

edocsil wrote:Well, now we have a little triangle of 2 votes. Maybe a triple claim and we lynch the worst liar? Sucks, but scum claims are sometimes easy to spot.

I am all for a Fir Wagon!

I think it's a bit early to let scum know who to kill... We shouldn't be at lylo yet.

by **edocsil** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:17 pm

ga7 wrote:
edocsil wrote:Well, now we have a little triangle of 2 votes. Maybe a triple claim and we lynch the worst liar? Sucks, but scum claims are sometimes easy to spot.

I am all for a Fir Wagon!

I think it's a bit early to let scum know who to kill... We shouldn't be at lylo yet.

Good point, might expose something important. Still leaves a Fir wagon!

by **Serbia** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:35 pm

UNVOTE
VOTE: Victor

That was about the most useless bandwagon vote I've ever seen.

I'm Gambit, town power booster. At night, I get to choose a player to "charge". The effect will be random, could protect a player, block them, etc.
First night, I targeted Edocsil. Apparently that caused him to be busdriven with aage. Weird.
So on the second night, I decided to target aage directly. My effect on that one was an investigative answer. aage is third party schizophrenic. He gets an action at night, but has no idea what the effect will be. (my guess then is that he may have targeted lalaland, seeing as he ended up dead)

Now, I'd been tempted to vote aage, but getting rid of him really isn't going to help town at all, because we need to get rid of mafia, not third party - which really is the only reason I haven't voted him. (and right now it would help me to vote him too, seeing as he's in 2nd to be lynched) But I don't think it's the best move right now, based on what I've learned.

So guys, don't lynch me. I don't know what effect I'll have going forward, but would sure be nice to get a chance to find out, eh?!

by **strike wolf** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:41 pm

edocsil wrote:
ga7 wrote:Btw Serbia, you have less than a day before you're lynched, anything to say?

Strike has the same number of votes as serbia, and TBH I think it is more likely he is scum then serb. Slip ups and odd behavior > few posts.

1=2 I'll remember that for math class.

by **edocsil** on Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:51 pm

strike wolf wrote:
edocsil wrote:
ga7 wrote:Btw Serbia, you have less than a day before you're lynched, anything to say?

Strike has the same number of votes as serbia, and TBH I think it is more likely he is scum then serb. Slip ups and odd behavior > few posts.

1=2 I'll remember that for math class.

Hey, horseshoes and hand grenades, how bought input on Serb?

Personally I believe him, especially because it explains some of the N1 stuff. If he is counter claimed for the stuff it is an obvious lynch, but I doubt he would claim it if it would be countered, much safer to stay silent.

Would like to hear others thoughts as well.

X-Men Mafia- Town Wins! All roles and night actions revealed

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Tuesday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Re: X-Men Mafia - Day 3! Deadline Thursday night!

Who is online