[GON 2nd mafia game] The townies won

[archer3base]

I have not unvoted myself as my choice. If my death will help show the rest of you the error of your methods, save fellow innocent townsman from befalling the same fate.....let it be. I only ask one thing in return, after you realize that this method is flawed, and find and eliminate the real SCUM, bury me in the town square and erect a statue over me. Let the epitaph read:
Here lies DB4, we know not what we hung him for. He went to the gallows of our own election, when all he seeked was the towns protection.
On his head we placed a bounty, realizing too late he was townie. With a six foot neck and a purple tongue, he whispered his last...."Get The Scum"!

Any thoughts here guys?

If he was a townie wouldn't any scum pile on that last vote to lynch? Or maybe all scum have already voted for him? Any opinions would be greatly appreciated...

[CHECK-M8]

Well I will be the first to admit I have no idea what I am doing in this game, but I can't see any reason whatsoever that DB4 is mafia. I have him 17th out of 19 as likely to be mafia. And I am 19. with tuffy as 18. But once again I admit to being totally lost.
I thought 19 players would be a pretty small game. Now I am hearing that there may be more than one mafia and 3 party players, next thing I am expecting to hear is there might be aliens riding around in spaceships who can see our roles.

DB, if you are put down I will bring flowers to your grave and make sure you get your epitaph. And the one that drops the hammer will be my next pick to string up. If you have fooled me then I will just have to be fooled. I think you are a townie, although I will admit I could be wrong. I just see myself as the ONLY player coming to your aid, and the way I see it, if you were mafia your boys would be trying to save you. You can tell as much by peoples lack of friends as you can their friends.

[mtamburini]

I have not unvoted myself as my choice. If my death will help show the rest of you the error of your methods, save fellow innocent townsman from befalling the same fate.....let it be. I only ask one thing in return, after you realize that this method is flawed, and find and eliminate the real SCUM, bury me in the town square and erect a statue over me. Let the epitaph read:
Here lies DB4, we know not what we hung him for. He went to the gallows of our own election, when all he seeked was the towns protection.
On his head we placed a bounty, realizing too late he was townie. With a six foot neck and a purple tongue, he whispered his last...."Get The Scum"!

Any thoughts here guys?

If he was a townie wouldn't any scum pile on that last vote to lynch? Or maybe all scum have already voted for him? Any opinions would be greatly appreciated...

Thats a great thought Archer. It is possible that all scum has voted already for DB4. Maybe we should start asking questions to those who has voted for him.

[Killuminati19]

No reason given for ranking him (arbitrarily) 17th.

[DB4Christ]

You are wise Oh Great Fish! I appreciate the flowers.........but would be extremely grateful if you would just keep the dogs away!

[mtamburini]

I wouldnt mind if we talked about qbert68 or Elsuper bano. They voted for DB and are one of the few people in this forum that have talked.

[crasp]

Cue.
Users browsing this forum: crasp, DB4Christ, Gabsensei, mtamburini, Scarlet Lady and 0 guests

[mtamburini]

Cue.
Users browsing this forum: crasp, DB4Christ, Gabsensei, mtamburini, Scarlet Lady and 0 guests

Whats the point of this post crasp? We are all pretty active posters and there is activity going on right now so there would be a lot of people viewing the forum.

[mtamburini]

Well I will be the first to admit I have no idea what I am doing in this game, but I can't see any reason whatsoever that DB4 is mafia. I have him 17th out of 19 as likely to be mafia. And I am 19. with tuffy as 18. But once again I admit to being totally lost.
I thought 19 players would be a pretty small game. Now I am hearing that there may be more than one mafia and 3 party players, next thing I am expecting to hear is there might be aliens riding around in spaceships who can see our roles.

DB, if you are put down I will bring flowers to your grave and make sure you get your epitaph. And the one that drops the hammer will be my next pick to string up. If you have fooled me then I will just have to be fooled. I think you are a townie, although I will admit I could be wrong. I just see myself as the ONLY player coming to your aid, and the way I see it, if you were mafia your boys would be trying to save you. You can tell as much by peoples lack of friends as you can their friends.

Are you currently voting for you top mafia suspect?

[Scarlet Lady]

I'm not sure why DB4 is playing the martyr, perhaps this is one of the roles or he is going on holiday and wants to pull out of the game in style. Or else he is in collusion with the Reviver, so that would make him scum.

I've concluded that there are probably two mafias, as I can divide the players roughly into three groups but I'm probably wrong - maybe there are no scum at all.

[archer3base]

Well I will be the first to admit I have no idea what I am doing in this game, but I can't see any reason whatsoever that DB4 is mafia. I have him 17th out of 19 as likely to be mafia. And I am 19. with tuffy as 18. But once again I admit to being totally lost.
I thought 19 players would be a pretty small game. Now I am hearing that there may be more than one mafia and 3 party players, next thing I am expecting to hear is there might be aliens riding around in spaceships who can see our roles.

DB, if you are put down I will bring flowers to your grave and make sure you get your epitaph. And the one that drops the hammer will be my next pick to string up. If you have fooled me then I will just have to be fooled. I think you are a townie, although I will admit I could be wrong. I just see myself as the ONLY player coming to your aid, and the way I see it, if you were mafia your boys would be trying to save you. You can tell as much by peoples lack of friends as you can their friends.

I don't see any big 'tell' right now from anyone... That's the problem. If DB4 is a townie then I would guess 2 or 3 mafia have voted for him and no one wants to pile on that last vote for suspicion either way. JMO

[TheCrown]

I unvoted DB4 so we could have time to discuss other people and not lynch him so fast.

Cons to lynching DB4:
He is a great participator

Pros to lynching DB4:
He seems the scummiest on day 1, a very hard day to determine things
He's only a vanilla townie, so we wouldn't lose a power role, but could find out info from this

We would want to keep him at L-2 incase there was a double voter, or if DB4 was a hated townie (which would require 1 less vote for a lynch).

I am up for checking out the other silent ones I listed, but we are down to 9 days now, and whatever we do, it will be hard to tell what's going on in day 1, just the way it is.

I would like another claim, but it's not totally necessary.

[SiriusCowKing]

I cannot say what roles are in the game, anyway it's more fun this way. There is at least 1 mafia for sure, not gonna say if there is a 2nd mafia or 3rd party. Just go read what the roles are, it will help you figure out the possibilities. Scarlet, the reviver is a pro townie, not a pro mafia.

[mtamburini]

I cannot say what roles are in the game, anyway it's more fun this way. There is at least 1 mafia for sure, not gonna say if there is a 2nd mafia or 3rd party. Just go read what the roles are, it will help you figure out the possibilities. Scarlet, the reviver is a pro townie, not a pro mafia.

Are you saying there is a reviver then?

[mtamburini]

I unvoted DB4 so we could have time to discuss other people and not lynch him so fast.

Cons to lynching DB4:
He is a great participator

Pros to lynching DB4:
He seems the scummiest on day 1, a very hard day to determine things
He's only a vanilla townie, so we wouldn't lose a power role, but could find out info from this

We would want to keep him at L-2 incase there was a double voter, or if DB4 was a hated townie (which would require 1 less vote for a lynch).

I am up for checking out the other silent ones I listed, but we are down to 9 days now, and whatever we do, it will be hard to tell what's going on in day 1, just the way it is.

I would like another claim, but it's not totally necessary.

For this reason I do not vote DB but he is not out of my radar yet, how do you feel about the people I mentioned before?

I wouldnt mind if we talked about qbert68 or Elsuper bano. They voted for DB and are one of the few people in this forum that have talked.

[Scarlet Lady]

I cannot say what roles are in the game, anyway it's more fun this way. There is at least 1 mafia for sure, not gonna say if there is a 2nd mafia or 3rd party. Just go read what the roles are, it will help you figure out the possibilities. Scarlet, the reviver is a pro townie, not a pro mafia.

Thanks for the heads up moo. So he does want to be a martyr, unless he can revive himself - or he's got another trick up his sleeve.

[crasp]

Cue.
Users browsing this forum: crasp, DB4Christ, Gabsensei, mtamburini, Scarlet Lady and 0 guests

Whats the point of this post crasp? We are all pretty active posters and there is activity going on right now so there would be a lot of people viewing the forum.

Unfortunately Santa just knocked on my door so i missed the cue for the second part of that post.(Caught me off guard and i answered. cost me a fiver. ) Everytime i look at the bottom of my screen i see you and scarlet lady sitting at the bottom like a pair of binoculars. Then if i make any comment in that regard you suddenly appear quickly followed by the Crown. Patterns, Mith patterns. Like the pattern that neither you or the other aforementioned are voting for DB. Or that the Crown, and DB are on a mission to get the whole town to declare. Or scarlet lady trying to convince us that there are only two mafia. If there are less than three and at least one third party I will eat my santa socks.

[TuffyLess]

I wouldnt mind if we talked about qbert68 or Elsuper bano. They voted for DB and are one of the few people in this forum that have talked.

and Ragot too ... hasnt the MOD prodded these guys at least once already?

[mtamburini]

I unvoted DB4 so we could have time to discuss other people and not lynch him so fast.

Cons to lynching DB4:
He is a great participator

Pros to lynching DB4:
He seems the scummiest on day 1, a very hard day to determine things
He's only a vanilla townie, so we wouldn't lose a power role, but could find out info from this

We would want to keep him at L-2 incase there was a double voter, or if DB4 was a hated townie (which would require 1 less vote for a lynch).

I am up for checking out the other silent ones I listed, but we are down to 9 days now, and whatever we do, it will be hard to tell what's going on in day 1, just the way it is.

I would like another claim, but it's not totally necessary.

For this reason I do not vote DB but he is not out of my radar yet, how do you feel about the people I mentioned before?

I wouldnt mind if we talked about qbert68 or Elsuper bano. They voted for DB and are one of the few people in this forum that have talked.

Bolded the wrong section, meant to bold the cons section not the pros

[Scarlet Lady]

Cue.
Users browsing this forum: crasp, DB4Christ, Gabsensei, mtamburini, Scarlet Lady and 0 guests

Whats the point of this post crasp? We are all pretty active posters and there is activity going on right now so there would be a lot of people viewing the forum.

Unfortunately Santa just knocked on my door so i missed the cue for the second part of that post.(Caught me off guard and i answered. cost me a fiver. ) Everytime i look at the bottom of my screen i see you and scarlet lady sitting at the bottom like a pair of binoculars. Then if i make any comment in that regard you suddenly appear quickly followed by the Crown. Patterns, Mith patterns. Like the pattern that neither you or the other aforementioned are voting for DB. Or that the Crown, and DB are on a mission to get the whole town to declare. Or scarlet lady trying to convince us that there are only two mafia. If there are less than three and at least one third party I will eat my santa socks.

I meant two mafia families, one of which you must belong to as you keep picking on me. At least I know my queens darling, Vicky would be very disappointed in you.

[crasp]

Cue.
Users browsing this forum: crasp, DB4Christ, Gabsensei, mtamburini, Scarlet Lady and 0 guests

Whats the point of this post crasp? We are all pretty active posters and there is activity going on right now so there would be a lot of people viewing the forum.

Unfortunately Santa just knocked on my door so i missed the cue for the second part of that post.(Caught me off guard and i answered. cost me a fiver. ) Everytime i look at the bottom of my screen i see you and scarlet lady sitting at the bottom like a pair of binoculars. Then if i make any comment in that regard you suddenly appear quickly followed by the Crown. Patterns, Mith patterns. Like the pattern that neither you or the other aforementioned are voting for DB. Or that the Crown, and DB are on a mission to get the whole town to declare. Or scarlet lady trying to convince us that there are only two mafia. If there are less than three and at least one third party I will eat my santa socks.

I meant two mafia families, one of which you must belong to as you keep picking on me. At least I know my queens darling, Vicky would be very disappointed in you.

Two questions.
1. why would i pick on you if i was mafia. The Crowns doing a good enough job for the two families. (that two families thing is the biggest red herring i have ever saw )
2. Why would Vicky be dissapointed in me?

[Cump Sherman]

I can't believe my friend DB is mafia but not getting the last vote is bothering me. Either all the mafia has already voted for him or he is mafia and this is all a ploy to keep him in the game a long time. Thoughts? Someone help me!!!

[CHECK-M8]

Well I will be the first to admit I have no idea what I am doing in this game, but I can't see any reason whatsoever that DB4 is mafia. I have him 17th out of 19 as likely to be mafia. And I am 19. with tuffy as 18. But once again I admit to being totally lost.
I thought 19 players would be a pretty small game. Now I am hearing that there may be more than one mafia and 3 party players, next thing I am expecting to hear is there might be aliens riding around in spaceships who can see our roles.

DB, if you are put down I will bring flowers to your grave and make sure you get your epitaph. And the one that drops the hammer will be my next pick to string up. If you have fooled me then I will just have to be fooled. I think you are a townie, although I will admit I could be wrong. I just see myself as the ONLY player coming to your aid, and the way I see it, if you were mafia your boys would be trying to save you. You can tell as much by peoples lack of friends as you can their friends.

Are you currently voting for you top mafia suspect?

NO!! Crown is in top 7 but not #1. I haven't changed my vote because I don't want to be changing my vote every day. But if he got close getting his neck stretched I would change it, even if he does say bad things about my dolphins...

[SiriusCowKing]

I cannot say what roles are in the game, anyway it's more fun this way. There is at least 1 mafia for sure, not gonna say if there is a 2nd mafia or 3rd party. Just go read what the roles are, it will help you figure out the possibilities. Scarlet, the reviver is a pro townie, not a pro mafia.

Are you saying there is a reviver then?

Do I really need to write "if there is one in the game" every time I talk about a certain role?

[SiriusCowKing]

Day 1 vote count:

archer3base - Cump Sherman,
crasp - Scarlet Lady
DB4Christ - archer3base, justplay4fun, Ragot25, qbert68, Gabsensei, Killuminati19, Crasp, DB4Christ, Elsuper bano
Elsuper bano - King Edward 3rd
TheCrown - CHECK-M8


DB4Chirst is at L-1

With 19 players in the game it takes 10 votes to lynch.

Deadline is in 9 days