by Nzen on Fri May 29, 2009 4:42 am
Hmm, both Skoffin and captainwalrus have lied. Unfortunately, that impedes town just as much as scum.
Skoffin’s story can make sense. A mafia roleblocker might fit the setup. She could be a cop. She could plausibly give the same story if she is vanilla and a roleblocker kept at her (to ‘confirm’ his suspicion). Mafia probably would avoid an unintuitive falseclaim, and the real cop may counter-claim. Which could be the point, but seems a great risk.
Captainwalrus’ story can be plausible. A cop who checked mphj and Simon Viavant would likely withhold claiming. A cop might also hazard a vanilla falseclaim when faced with a day one lynch.
I don’t feel any strong distinction besides captainwalrus’ desire for a lynch. He jumped behind me when I suggested we random vote rather than indicate someone else. While I share culpability, he persists in his desire. I guess I’ll vote captainwalrus.