[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[dazza2008]

He never thought I was a death eater he was being a dickhead

I think he can't help that

Caught up but just more confused than anything. Too much flavour. I think I even played a harry potter mafia once and i still don't get it.

Storr's play has just been weird to me though. Why claim survivor day 1 just for a laugh? That shit gets you lynched. I need to read back through but I will probably vote Stor just for being a cunt.

Than you're no use to town and should be lynched tomorrow

It's then

No use to town because I don't know the flavour or I joked? If either of them is a reason to be lynched I will happily vote myself. I was always under the impression mafia was a game and I play games for fun. If I am wrong then sorry buddy.

You joked about wanting to vote for storr?

Nah. That part was not a joke.

I get what people are saying about the was stor plays. I have played a few games in our clan forum with him. I get people saying he acts like he knows stuff often as town but here I can't see him being town. At best he is third party at worst he is scum. If he is scum he has to play the way he normally plays to no attract too much attention so I think he is a good lynch today.

[mtamburini]

He never thought I was a death eater he was being a dickhead

I think he can't help that

Caught up but just more confused than anything. Too much flavour. I think I even played a harry potter mafia once and i still don't get it.

Storr's play has just been weird to me though. Why claim survivor day 1 just for a laugh? That shit gets you lynched. I need to read back through but I will probably vote Stor just for being a cunt.

Than you're no use to town and should be lynched tomorrow

It's then

No use to town because I don't know the flavour or I joked? If either of them is a reason to be lynched I will happily vote myself. I was always under the impression mafia was a game and I play games for fun. If I am wrong then sorry buddy.

You joked about wanting to vote for storr?

Nah. That part was not a joke.

I get what people are saying about the was stor plays. I have played a few games in our clan forum with him. I get people saying he acts like he knows stuff often as town but here I can't see him being town. At best he is third party at worst he is scum. If he is scum he has to play the way he normally plays to no attract too much attention so I think he is a good lynch today.

Thats the only part I Read which made me want to vote for you so how do you feel knowing that is my reasoning for you to die?

[StorrZerg]

He never thought I was a death eater he was being a dickhead

I think he can't help that

Caught up but just more confused than anything. Too much flavour. I think I even played a harry potter mafia once and i still don't get it.

Storr's play has just been weird to me though. Why claim survivor day 1 just for a laugh? That shit gets you lynched. I need to read back through but I will probably vote Stor just for being a cunt.

Than you're no use to town and should be lynched tomorrow

It's then

No use to town because I don't know the flavour or I joked? If either of them is a reason to be lynched I will happily vote myself. I was always under the impression mafia was a game and I play games for fun. If I am wrong then sorry buddy.

You joked about wanting to vote for storr?

Nah. That part was not a joke.

I get what people are saying about the was stor plays. I have played a few games in our clan forum with him. I get people saying he acts like he knows stuff often as town but here I can't see him being town. At best he is third party at worst he is scum. If he is scum he has to play the way he normally plays to no attract too much attention so I think he is a good lynch today.

Mrs. Norris can you believe these students? Revolting! there must be some must be death eaters in disguise, what could they gain by kicking me out of the school? WHo do they expect to keep the castle in a good state of repair? Shouldn't the students be trying to find the death eaters hmm... So much complaining all the time from them, its a wonder more are not expelled.

[sempaispellcheck]

Bearing in mind that I've never played with any of you before, let me explain my thought process on Storr/Filch:

Initial thoughts: Filch is a Squib, with no magic, so no power role. He's probably more likely to be town because he's loyal to Hogwarts.

-first 2 posts-

It wasn't until after my 2nd post about him that I remembered that Filch gleefully worked for Umbridge (who would be scum if she were in this game) in Book 5. (It's been a while since I read the books - I've forgotten a few things, but sometimes things can come back to me).

-3rd post-

My next thought was, if scum could technically use him, why don't we try to beat them to the punch? But, more importantly, let's see where he's trying to lead us, in order to get an idea of how helpful/harmful he will be. He's insisting mtam is scum, so let's go for mtam. If he flips town, we know we probably shouldn't trust Filch. If he flips scum, we may be able to.

Around that time, Storr also reminded me that Filch has no magic, and therefore could not become a Death Eater.

Also, I unvoted Storr, in case you weren't looking, and am no longer interested in getting him lynched today.

sempai

[StorrZerg]

Filch doesn't know any more than a first year student, Just uses his eyes to try and catch Students disguised as Death Eaters...

@sempai, why cant you use your eyes to find a Death eater? WHy must you follow around like a troll?

[degaston]

Considering that I think Dega and Sempai are a likely scum pair I am fine with voting either of them.

Wouldn't be surprised if they are. I already called out how jump-happy they were. First all wagon Storr and when Storr points to Mtamb they quickly switch like he is their leader.

Excuse me? I never voted for Storr. I was just questioning him because I didn't understand what he was doing, and Tonka thought that I was going after him.

At first I thought Storr was just rambling nonsense, then Tonka suggested he might have a power that could have identified Mtam as a death eater, so that's what made me vote for mtam. Then Storr denies having a power, so I don't know what to think anymore, and Strikewolf jumps on me for backtracking. Now it seems that people are saying that Storr and Mtam are going after each other because of a personality conflict?

I never thought that it made much sense for Storr to draw that much attention to himself if he was scum. It looks like he just enjoys playing in character, and I'm fine with that.

Meanwhile, Tonka says that I jumped on "every single person who ever says anything in [my] direction." when it was only him and strikewolf that I voted for, but not HotShot. Should we lynch that liar?

And strikewolf jumps on me because he says that it makes no sense for filch to be a day cop because he prowls around at night? As though the mod had to be perfectly consistent when he was assigning roles?

On day 1, I have no clue who is scummy and who isn't. I vote for this person or that person just to see what happens. If somebody thinks that's scummy... whatever.

[got tonkaed]

I guess out of all the reads I am most confused with Streaker's/mtamb's read on charm.

At this point having reread again it probably is a bit harsh to be as on degaston as I have been, he didn't push back on hotshot, and maybe he just missed the bottom of the opening scene. From there a couple people pressured and he omgus'ed a few times, which can happen.

Having said that, prior to charm's longer catch up post, the only posts were voting death eaters and noting to streaker that while they couldn't have ice cream, they could have chocolate and candy which echos something from the first post about wanting to eat chocolate frogs.

I cant think for the life of me of a character in the top 24 or so harry potter characters that does a whole lot based off that tiny flavor. But it was good enough for Streaker, I guess I am just looking to be enlightened on that one.

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

Strikewolf - virus90
degaston - Strikewolf, HotShot
StorrZerg - dakky, aage, madmitch, BGtheBrain
mtamburini - sempai, degaston, Endgame
Ragian - mtamburini, dd
sempai - Storr, Streaker

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

[Streaker]

I guess out of all the reads I am most confused with Streaker's/mtamb's read on charm.

At this point having reread again it probably is a bit harsh to be as on degaston as I have been, he didn't push back on hotshot, and maybe he just missed the bottom of the opening scene. From there a couple people pressured and he omgus'ed a few times, which can happen.

Having said that, prior to charm's longer catch up post, the only posts were voting death eaters and noting to streaker that while they couldn't have ice cream, they could have chocolate and candy which echos something from the first post about wanting to eat chocolate frogs.

I cant think for the life of me of a character in the top 24 or so harry potter characters that does a whole lot based off that tiny flavor. But it was good enough for Streaker, I guess I am just looking to be enlightened on that one.

Don't know what to say about charm here. Did I really call town on her already? I don't believe I have.
Mtamb rated her town-ish, based on meta. I agree to this read, and await further posts from her to develop my read further.

Degaston deserved the attention he got. Simple as that. His last defense was actually quite good. I do not agree anymore that Degaston is a worthy persuit for now.

Need to reread Sempai's post again before commenting.
MTAMB baby, what are your feelings towards Sempai?

Ragian is jumping quite heavily for the little pressure he is under...

[got tonkaed]

At this (very early) point I have a few soft town reads, and 2 soft scum read

-Mtamb towny feeling
-Charm towny feeling
-virus90 towny feeling
-Hotshot adding to this list for calling out Degaston

-Degaston slight scum read (for his scummarizing about the death eaters, I mean it was 2 flippin' posts above that.)
-Got Tonkaed slight scum read for his calling out Storr as a lynch candidate, but stating in the same sentence that he is clearly not anti town.

This was where I got it from. Charm had not said very much at all at this point. Had told you about some chocolate and wanted to get death eaters. There is a fair about of meta going on at the moment.

[Streaker]

Ah yes. I knew that post was gonna come back later in the day.
It was a very early 'read' post. Charm's read based solely on meta. Difficult to explain but the one game she was mafia in it was obvious from post nr 1.

By no means will I stand by those reads if anything changes. For instance I have Degaston more neutral instead of scum now. It only takes 1 post...

I consider meta a good thing on D1, but is difficult when playing in a group you don't know (most) players. Meta helps out and is often proven a good aid.

Tonka, what is your opinion on Sempai and Ragian?

[got tonkaed]

Raigan - I don't get as much of the case against him to be honest. Most of his early posting was the type of stuff you'd expect from a newer player who hadn't played in a large game. Mtam decides he is bad and then I feel like he kind of loses a meta argument over the next few pages. He hasn't really done a lot in terms of actual content, so I don't think there is a ton of reason to dislike him.

Sempai - gets in trouble early on for making the same argument a few people have on storr. I feel like a lot of the sempai stuff is connected to how you feel about letting an active 3rd party player stay in the game. If you want storr dead (dd,mtam) then sempai is scummy defending him. Sempai also switched fairly frequently, which has been the case of most of the active players, since we have all bounced around a bit. Strike pointed him out as someone who might be paired with degaston, but if degaston is just being nooby, that might be a weak connection. Either way, sempai has jumped plenty of times, and could be accused of pushing an easy lynch. I would not be against pressuring sempai more and maybe eventually going with him as a d1 lynch.

[sempaispellcheck]

I'm not actively trying to defend Storr, for what that's worth - I'm just saying he could, potentially, maybe, be useful later on. That said, I can see (and have made) a few arguments for getting rid of him early. I've got an FOS on him, but that's as far as I think I'll go today.
I've never played with any of you, so I don't know your metas, and I don't really know how to read people yet, since this is only my third game (and I've been nightkilled early in every game I played.
I kind of like the idea of following someone else's lead early on in the hope that the result will give us some information on that person as well (hence my mtam vote - looking to shed a little more light on Storr).
Basically, I'm kind of jumping around because I don't know much of anything (it is D1), and I'm trying to get some type of foothold somewhere.
I also think I need to reread the thread a bit more closely and see what (if anything) I can figure out.

sempai

[StorrZerg]

Students following students makes sense, student blindly following an unknown smells of death.

[charm]

Charm is most likely town, shes not super town like Id expect her to be in games but wont be my focus today. What do you think of the person i am voting for

Yes, I'm being a bit more reserved this game - last time I was in a big game like this and having fun with flavor I was thrown out early on. So, I figure with the guys that I have not played, I need to be introduced to my style slowly. For example, this from Tonka:

Charm had not said very much at all at this point. Had told you about some chocolate and wanted to get death eaters. There is a fair about of meta going on at the moment.

Tonka hasn't played with me before, so he doesn't know that I always like to serve the boys some food or drinks and have a shop in town!

@Tonka - don't waste your time looking for significance in the chocolate frogs or my comment on Death Eaters - the only reason I stated those 2 is because we are on "D1: Riding the H. Express" - which the candy cart lady is on the train and it's only natural that the mafia would be called Death Eaters.

@MTam - I don't think much of you voting for Raigan, other than I will say you need to carefully use your words - I was getting all side tracked with your bad language. I think HotShot might be on to you being a Vig as you were talking about getting Storr during the night.

[BGtheBrain]

*****

[StorrZerg]

I've claimed 3rd party survivor, yet that's not obvious I guess. I'm under no post Restriction other than having fun and being sad I'm not with anyone.

I keep hearing people say Storr may have a trick up his sleeve or he may be useful later on.

He's either a 3rd party survivor who has done nothing but draw attention to himself, claimed without pressure and made D1 suck worse than normal OR hes lying about the full extent of his role.

So, yeah. Ill lynch based on poor play or Ill lynch on Lynch all Liars...

Filch plays in your face, would you rather a sad squib claim latter when it could be lylo?

A fake claim of paranoid wizard (pgo),

Filch no want to die because death eater fears his shackles.

Filch laugh at the BG, he no read well like me. Hahahahahah

[degaston]

Filch plays in your face, would you rather a sad squib claim latter when it could be lylo?

A fake claim of paranoid wizard (pgo),

Filch no want to die because death eater fears his shackles.

Filch laugh at the BG, he no read well like me. Hahahahahah

Which one of you wizards turned Filch into a cave man?

[mtamburini]

I guess out of all the reads I am most confused with Streaker's/mtamb's read on charm.

At this point having reread again it probably is a bit harsh to be as on degaston as I have been, he didn't push back on hotshot, and maybe he just missed the bottom of the opening scene. From there a couple people pressured and he omgus'ed a few times, which can happen.

Having said that, prior to charm's longer catch up post, the only posts were voting death eaters and noting to streaker that while they couldn't have ice cream, they could have chocolate and candy which echos something from the first post about wanting to eat chocolate frogs.

I cant think for the life of me of a character in the top 24 or so harry potter characters that does a whole lot based off that tiny flavor. But it was good enough for Streaker, I guess I am just looking to be enlightened on that one.

Don't know what to say about charm here. Did I really call town on her already? I don't believe I have.
Mtamb rated her town-ish, based on meta. I agree to this read, and await further posts from her to develop my read further.

Degaston deserved the attention he got. Simple as that. His last defense was actually quite good. I do not agree anymore that Degaston is a worthy persuit for now.

Need to reread Sempai's post again before commenting.
MTAMB baby, what are your feelings towards Sempai?

Ragian is jumping quite heavily for the little pressure he is under...

I could get behind a senpai lynch if mine doesnt go through``

[StorrZerg]

I suspect a death eater lurking in the shadows staying away from the fight...

[sempaispellcheck]

I guess out of all the reads I am most confused with Streaker's/mtamb's read on charm.

At this point having reread again it probably is a bit harsh to be as on degaston as I have been, he didn't push back on hotshot, and maybe he just missed the bottom of the opening scene. From there a couple people pressured and he omgus'ed a few times, which can happen.

Having said that, prior to charm's longer catch up post, the only posts were voting death eaters and noting to streaker that while they couldn't have ice cream, they could have chocolate and candy which echos something from the first post about wanting to eat chocolate frogs.

I cant think for the life of me of a character in the top 24 or so harry potter characters that does a whole lot based off that tiny flavor. But it was good enough for Streaker, I guess I am just looking to be enlightened on that one.

Don't know what to say about charm here. Did I really call town on her already? I don't believe I have.
Mtamb rated her town-ish, based on meta. I agree to this read, and await further posts from her to develop my read further.

Degaston deserved the attention he got. Simple as that. His last defense was actually quite good. I do not agree anymore that Degaston is a worthy persuit for now.

Need to reread Sempai's post again before commenting.
MTAMB baby, what are your feelings towards Sempai?

Ragian is jumping quite heavily for the little pressure he is under...

I could get behind a senpai lynch if mine doesnt go through``

I get the feeling you could get behind a lynch on just about anyone if you can't get Storr killed.
What's the deal with the two of you, anyway? Is this just carrying over from a prior game or something?

I suspect a death eater lurking in the shadows staying away from the fight...

Me, too - possibly more than one. A couple of people have been VERY quiet.

sempai

[StorrZerg]

Sempai still wants Me removed, can't make up hid mind. Unwilling to search for death eaters, blatantly stating he wishes to follow.

[sempaispellcheck]

Sempai still wants Me removed

Wrong. I'm suspicious of you, but I suspect you can be useful if we can figure out what the hell you're actually saying

blatantly stating he wishes to follow.

Whatsorry? Where did I ever blatantly state that I wish to follow?

sempai

[virus90]

that took ages to catch up, wow. anyway.
The storr thing was very obvious, i started rereading since my last post and since that; i had noted storr as 3th party or VT. possible survivor and he claimed survivor. and i agree with i think it was hotshot who said it; if you have to claim 3th party later you probably wont be beleived. his voting during rest of the game should be indicative of his alignement if he is leading on 2 scum lynches i dont see any reason to doubt him for 3th party survivor.

Besides if mtam really kills storr night 1 there is no need to lynch him day 1. which brings me to mtam, MTAM are you a vig?
seriously charm mentioned it slightly but why are not more people on this? mtam claims being able to kill storr, threatens to do so. and charm mentioned a bit about it but that was about all. No questions asked really; it raises all kind of questions with me:
easy for mafia to say i kill storr tonight so i prove im vig while being mafia. / why would you claim vig day 1 trying to lynch a possible 3th party? is there no better shot then storr? / is he even a vig or just shouting something and making a false threat (i think i might have seen that before)....
so whats up with this ? mtam are you still planning to kill storr? so many questions... and i dont understand why no one asked these...

ok on other people. town read on streaker cause he acts like the other game in which he was town and had some more good points in my opinion.
dont understand/agree the votes on sempai, nor the ones on ragian. both have valid reasons for acting like they did in my opinion.

then a little on BG-the brain. wants to lynch storr for bad play and is tunneled on stor in my opinion. since i strongly disagree and he hasnt offered more then that i gladly change my vote to him.
unvote vote BG The brain

[degaston]

Unvote
Vote Iron Butterfly
... because he's only made one post since the game started.