[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[dazza2008]

Strikes claim? Lol?

Aye. I was not thinking there. I just remembered Mud trusting him loads and thought he somehow knew about strike getting the wand and since I never trusted Mud's claim I was not trusting him.

Surely tonk is the best lynch or charm. I never got why folk think Charm is the better choice. Is it flavour related reasons cos I need that shit explaining.

[strike wolf]

In light of charms claim, if its true that is what her wand can do, and no one is claiming to have her wand, scum have her wand and not claming it. once you lose your wand it goes to someone who is wandless. So suspect people who say they are wandless because 2 of them definitly have a wand.

Storr on n1 and dd on n4 DD 100% doesnt have a wand this is fact

[dazza2008]

In light of charms claim, if its true that is what her wand can do, and no one is claiming to have her wand, scum have her wand and not claming it. once you lose your wand it goes to someone who is wandless. So suspect people who say they are wandless because 2 of them definitly have a wand.

Storr on n1 and dd on n4 DD 100% doesnt have a wand this is fact

MP n2 charm N3

[StorrZerg]

my b.

and eye dazza, charm or got tonk.

There is 100% a lie going on between them. And im not talking about "not mentioning the wand" I think that could be a mistake, / forgetting.

Either got tonk is a liar about not being able to use the wand, or charm is a liar about her role and is a death eater, hence why he can't use a wand that is a killing wand.

Need to think on this some more, something isn't adding up as strike said earlier with powers used and known.

[dazza2008]

Charms role seems weird. It seemed odd to want the wand back so badly too and ask for protection etc when there are more important players out there needing the protection.

[HotShot53]

Well, with strike's claim of getting mud's wand and having the same thing mud claimed, that pretty much clears mud and ruins my mud/mad scum pair theory lol.

And with that info, it pretty much comes down to either charm or tonk is lying... either tonk was a wandless scum who got charm's wand but doesn't want to use it (and claims it had no powers when he got it since he claimed VT), or charm is scum and her wand transfers without powers attached to it. Since we already have a dead vig, charm's role claim really doesn't make sense, and I will still leave my vote on her.

[charm]

Well, you can lynch me if you want, but I'd really like the chance to prove myself to you all. If I'm right, and it takes the wand, spell, and sending the package to make it work, then you all just lost the chance at hitting a scum and wasting your votes on me. I haven't lied, I'm just weird! GT has been caught lying - my vote stay with GT.

I was the last one added to the game, a big 24 player game, at the last minute. I bet the mod is having a fabulous laugh at us right now.

[mtamburini]

Mtamburini claimed to disarm dazza, yet dazza still retains wand yes?

I said dazza?

[StorrZerg]

Well, you can lynch me if you want, but I'd really like the chance to prove myself to you all. If I'm right, and it takes the wand, spell, and sending the package to make it work, then you all just lost the chance at hitting a scum and wasting your votes on me. I haven't lied, I'm just weird! GT has been caught lying - my vote stay with GT.

I was the last one added to the game, a big 24 player game, at the last minute. I bet the mod is having a fabulous laugh at us right now.

time you are added has no impact on what role you get.

@tambo all ready cleared up

[strike wolf]

Theory. Tonka and Charm are both scum. Charms wand ability is an inherently scum ability so Tonka cant claim that thats the power withouut condemning Charm.

Not saying the theory is accurate just laying it out there

[charm]

Theory. Tonka and Charm are both scum. Charms wand ability is an inherently scum ability so Tonka cant claim that thats the power withouut condemning Charm.

Not saying the theory is accurate just laying it out there

Wrong!

[Streaker]

Theory. Tonka and Charm are both scum. Charms wand ability is an inherently scum ability so Tonka cant claim that thats the power withouut condemning Charm.

Not saying the theory is accurate just laying it out there

That could make sense. However in that case Tonka is the better lynch, as he has the wand and Charm is without power.

Nurse Wolf's claim also explains his defense of Mudpupp. Would have preferred you just used this in his defense, but I can see why not.

Tonka did withhold information, and now it doesn't make sense he has no power after NW's claim about MP's wand.

I will vote Tonka.

[dd515087]

Am I the only one who thinks Tonka responded nicely to our questions for him? He hasn't been overly defensive and he explained why he didn't claim it earlier. IDK maybe I'm wrong, but I don't like how the votes have started piling up after he tried to remedy the situation.

[virus90]

repost of the roles, as i was searching for it. not updated yet (no time now)

1. Strike wolf v2.0-Remus Lupin-town mason
2. StorrZerg-claimed third party survivor.
3. Marashu-claimed Hermione Granger-town doctor
4. got tonkaed-claimed Luna Lovegood-VT
5. mtamburini-Claimed Harry Potter
6. Endgame422-claimed Mundungus Fletcher (right?)-Vt
7. Streaker-Proffessor Flitwick-Weird two night busdriver role.
8. aage-Horace Slughorn-Vt
9. virus90-Neville Longbottom-VT
10. madmitch-Ron Weasley-hasn't claimed role. Hints have suggested something that could backfire and/or inventor type role
11. dazza2008-Unclaimed I think
12. MudPuppy-Madame Pomfrey-Variation on doctor (wand missing)
13. HotShot53-unclaimed I think
14. dd515087-Hagrid-VT (yes this is the claim I thought he was hinting at).
15. charm-unclaimed. Hinted at wand being misplaced?

i believe tonka's claim more then charms. Lovegood is the same league as me and dobby in my opinion. close friends. since i know im vt and dobby was VT i find it plausible lovegood is VT aswell.
so ill unvote vote charm

[MudPuppy]

My guess is Charm is scum and GT could be the innocent recipient of a bad wand that he doesn't know how to use.... Though the theory that they are both scum is definitely a possibility. Anyway, I'd lean toward lynching Charm 1st:

Unvote
Vote Charm

[aage]

It's possible that both GT and Charm are scum... If GT received a wand when Charm was disarmed, that must mean that either Charm did have a wand and GT did not have a wand, OR both are lying.
If both are lying, it doesn't matter who we lynch.
If GT started the game wandless, I am more inclined to believe his claim. The only scum flip we've had so far is Ragian, who flipped Bellatrix but we received no information about wands or spells. Since it only is logical to connect Bellatrix to the cruciatus curse, Storr's theory about multiple scum being able to use any spell is plausible. That theory would also explain why GT can't cast spells with Charm's wand - it doesn't have a specific spell, like MP's wand. (Yes, with Strike's claim I assume both he and MP are town and telling the truth.) All of these facts and theories suggest Charm is the scum in this duo.

However I'm not keen on lynching a scum that does not have a wand. If Mtam's ability works every night, I suggest we just remove all the wands from the suspicious people so that the mafia can't use any of their powers any more. Lynching a wandless mafia doesn't cripple the mafia as much - it just decreases their numbers.

I'm gonna look back and see who presented the false dilemma between Charm and GT as today's lynch. I still think we should lynch Mitch - there's no way his completely incoherent claim is legitimate. Odds are you'll hit scum on Charm, but Mitch still has a wand and is still dangerous.

[madmitch]

Dangerous HA only to my self

[StorrZerg]

Dangerous HA only to my self

seriously can you stop with the act and just fucking claim fully.

[dazza2008]

Dangerous HA only to my self

seriously can you stop with the act and just fucking claim fully.

[madmitch]

ok here goes I am Ron Weasley, my spell is protego and yes I do have it also, I am town and my role is backup now I hope this eases peoples minds

[Streaker]

ok here goes I am Ron Weasley, my spell is protego and yes I do have it also, I am town and my role is backup now I hope this eases peoples minds

FULL claim. ALL your spells. You claimed to have several. Now you simply claimed doc lol.

[madmitch]

I was bullshitting on all the spells, I was trying to protect the person I was backup for but I did it the wrong way and put to much heat on myself which will not help town if I am gone

[Streaker]

Who u used your night actions on and on what night?

[StorrZerg]

You almost got lynched, and your still playing games. I'm a group of white girls, "I don't even"

[madmitch]

I did not do any actions at night . YOU must be thinking of someone else. I will start using my power when the other docter is dead,which I hope is not for awhile since it is my girl