[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

by **mtamburini** on Fri Jun 19, 2015 5:06 pm

got tonkaed wrote:One of them came to me, I got a message from the mod saying a wand came to me, but I can't cast any spells with it. I think it was N3? Id have to go back and double check the message, but Im heading out. Ill try and check again tonight.

OH NOW YOU THINK ITS A GOOD TIME TO SAY YOU GOT A WAND

f*ck that shit were lynching ton

Unvote vote ton

by **mtamburini** on Fri Jun 19, 2015 5:08 pm

StorrZerg wrote:can you explain what happened the other 2 nights?

If you dont have a wand nothing happens

by **mtamburini** on Fri Jun 19, 2015 5:12 pm

got tonkaed wrote:I'm ok with a group claim.

Luna Lovegood, no wand.

Claimed no wand 3 days ago

GTFO byyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyye

by **StorrZerg** on Fri Jun 19, 2015 5:32 pm

You thought it wasn't a good idea to claim you got a wand? Whose wand did you get

by **StorrZerg** on Fri Jun 19, 2015 5:33 pm

And tamb, I was talking about your night action n2 n3

by **charm** on Fri Jun 19, 2015 6:05 pm

That is pure BS...I've been asking for my wand back since day 3. He has to have my wand. I would assume that I'm the only one that can use it - what a great twist. I was able to cast a spell on something on the trolly cart and send it to one person. The spell was whatever I wanted, but in the end I either hit a scum or it would backfire on me. I was thinking about something like death by chocolate frogs to add flavor to the game or a box full of vomit jelly beans. Makes sense that someone else can't do it without also having my Trolly Cart. This is such a great game!!

Anyway, I find it super suspicious that GoT didn't say anything about it until now, when I was clearly asking about it. I thought he was scummy in the beginning of the game, but it was only a gut feel then I thought he was for sure VT, now I'm back to thinking he is scum. There was no reason to not say anything about having my wand especially if he couldn't do anything with it.

UNVOTE

VOTE Got Tonk

by **StorrZerg** on Fri Jun 19, 2015 6:21 pm

uyhuhhhhhhhhhhhhh i dont believe the unknown spell or w/e spell you wanted...

by **strike wolf** on Fri Jun 19, 2015 7:08 pm

Why not say you received a wand Tonka?

by **dd515087** on Fri Jun 19, 2015 11:06 pm

unvote, vote tonka

You should have claimed that you got a wand as soon as you got it and that you can't use it and you definitely should've made mention of it earlier this day phase during the mass-claim, but instead as mtam pointed out you said "No Wand" which you are now going back on.

by **dd515087** on Fri Jun 19, 2015 11:07 pm

Also Charm what's the name of your spell? Also where did madmitch go? He never explained his powers fully.

by **aage** on Sat Jun 20, 2015 4:06 am

If Tonka got a wand later in the game, that means he didn't have one before, right?

I don't think it's likely that scum doesn't have a wand at the start of the game.

Tonk's claim only confirms that his role did not have a wand, and Charm's role did. Makes sense with the claims so far, I don't see how emitting this information makes Tonk scum. Withholding it is sketch, but not having a wand is actually a pro-town thing afaik.

by **aage** on Sat Jun 20, 2015 4:07 am

mtamburini wrote:
StorrZerg wrote:can you explain what happened the other 2 nights?

If you dont have a wand nothing happens

So who did you target during N2 and N3?

by **Marashu** on Sat Jun 20, 2015 8:24 am

I'm curious about why tonk didn't claim he found a wand, though. Waiting on that before I vote for him.

by **charm** on Sat Jun 20, 2015 8:42 am

dd515087 wrote:Also Charm what's the name of your spell? Also where did madmitch go? He never explained his powers fully.

Slugulus Eructo

I'm voting for Tonk even if he is town. He obviously has something to hide and can't use my wand. So, if he dies, hopefully my wand will come back to me and then can use it to take out one if the scum. That is a chance worth taking.

So, I would suggest,
1. We take out Tonk - then we discover the truth
2. Someone protects me tonight, so scum don't take me out
3. We determine who we should use my power on tomorrow. Because, if I don't hit a scum, then it backfires on me.

by **StorrZerg** on Sat Jun 20, 2015 10:33 am

no one use any protection on charm LOL

by **charm** on Sat Jun 20, 2015 10:48 am

StorrZerg wrote:no one use any protection on charm LOL

Zerg-ee, you need a spanking?! =D>

by **StorrZerg** on Sat Jun 20, 2015 11:05 am

no, there is literally no reason to save you, because other people are far more valuable aka strike in particular. even if he doesn't have any spell right now.

you have been fogging up your claim like mad. not to mention your claim is weird as hell.

by **charm** on Sat Jun 20, 2015 1:06 pm

StorrZerg wrote:no, there is literally no reason to save you, because other people are far more valuable aka strike in particular. even if he doesn't have any spell right now.

you have been fogging up your claim like mad. not to mention your claim is weird as hell.

Zergee you're never happy. Either sonmeone talks too much or too little. I've tried really hard to play this game smartly, even if my role isn't that important. Now that I've laid it all out there you're still not supporting me. You're going to make an old lady cry. At least I have lots of candy to cheer me up!

by **Epitaph1** on Sat Jun 20, 2015 1:27 pm

VOTE COUNT

madmitch - HotShot, aage, Strikewolf
MudPuppy - Streaker
dazza - mitch, Endgame
aage - MudPuppy
mtamburini - Storr
tonka - mtam, charm, dd

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

by **strike wolf** on Sat Jun 20, 2015 9:57 pm

to clarify. I want full information from GT about why he can't use the wand. The name of the spell he was given and anything else he hasn't disclosed regarding his new wand and/or role that he can reveal without violating the rules. I think it's quite possible between Charm's odd claim and other factors involving GT that at least one of these two are scum.

That said. I am going on a day trip tomorrow and will be back Monday. I will try to check in on my phone when I can but I am not sure what kind of service I will have. So you should hear from me but probably just a few short, sporadic and to the point posts. I would like to weigh in at least once after hearing GT's explanation before we move forward with any lynches.

by **HotShot53** on Sun Jun 21, 2015 12:00 am

strike wolf wrote:to clarify. I want full information from GT about why he can't use the wand. The name of the spell he was given and anything else he hasn't disclosed regarding his new wand and/or role that he can reveal without violating the rules. I think it's quite possible between Charm's odd claim and other factors involving GT that at least one of these two are scum.

That said. I am going on a day trip tomorrow and will be back Monday. I will try to check in on my phone when I can but I am not sure what kind of service I will have. So you should hear from me but probably just a few short, sporadic and to the point posts. I would like to weigh in at least once after hearing GT's explanation before we move forward with any lynches.

Yeah, it's kind of weird... one of the biggest questions is if scum start with any wandless people or not; if all scum started with a wand, then GT would have to be town... if they started with some wandless, then he very well could be scum. If he got a wand with no powers, but whoever got the wand N2 got it with the power that mud claimed, then it would indicate charm might be scum, and mud was telling the truth and is town. No-one has claimed getting the wand night 2 yet though... and it might not be beneficial for them to come forward if they can protect someone from the roleblock or poison or whatever that spell is.

At the moment, my bet is more on the charm side of things though, assuming GT got a wand with no powers. So I will unvote, vote charm

by **dd515087** on Sun Jun 21, 2015 1:45 am

HotShot53 wrote:
strike wolf wrote:to clarify. I want full information from GT about why he can't use the wand. The name of the spell he was given and anything else he hasn't disclosed regarding his new wand and/or role that he can reveal without violating the rules. I think it's quite possible between Charm's odd claim and other factors involving GT that at least one of these two are scum.

That said. I am going on a day trip tomorrow and will be back Monday. I will try to check in on my phone when I can but I am not sure what kind of service I will have. So you should hear from me but probably just a few short, sporadic and to the point posts. I would like to weigh in at least once after hearing GT's explanation before we move forward with any lynches.

Yeah, it's kind of weird... one of the biggest questions is if scum start with any wandless people or not; if all scum started with a wand, then GT would have to be town... if they started with some wandless, then he very well could be scum. If he got a wand with no powers, but whoever got the wand N2 got it with the power that mud claimed, then it would indicate charm might be scum, and mud was telling the truth and is town. No-one has claimed getting the wand night 2 yet though... and it might not be beneficial for them to come forward if they can protect someone from the roleblock or poison or whatever that spell is.

At the moment, my bet is more on the charm side of things though, assuming GT got a wand with no powers. So I will unvote, vote charm

Well we should go back to Ragian's flip after the lynch then:

viewtopic.php?f=213&t=212083&sk=a&start=750#p4674263

He was lynched as "Bellatrix LeStrange - Death Eater" (name - role) when Skill was lynched as VT he flipped:

viewtopic.php?f=213&t=212083&sk=a&start=750#p4674263

"Dobby - Vanilla Townie" (name - role). Compare that with anyone who has been lynched with a spell:

viewtopic.php?f=213&t=212083&sk=a&start=725#p4667408

"Name - spell - role". This probably means that mafia can be wandless or vanilla "mafia goons".

by **virus90** on Sun Jun 21, 2015 3:38 am

to be honest i think we shouldnt go with either tonka or charm today. i think we have found much more obvious scum/ better case and we will have a hard enough time getting enough people to vote that. at this point i dont gonna vote tonka for sure, tonka - mtam, charm, dd. mtam onit, ok potter... trustworthy, but the other 2 i havent town read yet. i think we should look at that to. who do you trust and who are they voting. im far more comfortable with aage, strike and hotshot on the vote on madmitch.
at this point we are in 6 directions. more split then ever? which tells me mafia is leading discussion away from themselves.
vote madmitch

by **StorrZerg** on Sun Jun 21, 2015 6:33 am

Yet virus, mafia voted madmitch with hidden vote. putting him at L-1
why would they vote against themselves like that so late,

NOT TO MENTION STRIKE ISNT VOTING MADMITCH YOU SKIMMING DONKEY. STRIKE VOTE WAS STOLEN AND ITS THE MAFIA VOTE

by **madmitch** on Sun Jun 21, 2015 2:02 pm

OH VIRUS,,how many times have I tried to get rid of you? You are like a bad cold or flu just can,t get rid of you completely.well I got one more spell left it is called NEOCITRANOUS IT IS A POWERFUL SPELL TO Repel or stop bugs like you.