Webcomics Mafia! Evil Prevails!

[icedagger]

We don't imo. We have two options:

More random voting if nothing from day one can be picked up on cos of the jester
Someone finds something vaguely incriminating from day one and we work from there

I'll reread I guess

[pmchugh]

I don't know, but I'm thinking there's an outside chance it was the mafia

Well yeah I know that but I mean the character. Very possibly miko from OOTS, considering she's basically a female ninja.

Except for the fact that she's a paladin Maybe you're thinking of Therkla?

does it really matter? what we need to find out is who is playing said character NOT who the character actually is...

Not really, but why would you ignore the theme in a themed game?

not ignore, but what does it matter truely? yes we have a theme but we are still searching for the mafia as if it was a normal name, its just a neat twist to say 'hey i got ... as my character' and what not. I personally can think of many ninjas on many web comics but which one it is will not effect that any, and speculating on such is just wasteing our time

I agree with nate fully looking at charcters is meanigless until someone is shown as or claims a specific character.

No random voting anymore, every day gives scum tells and info and that where we need to look.

[AceArtemis]

I thought this was a good point Bolt made on Day 1:

FDM should be lynched tomorrow for advocating a lynch of a power role, that is not only really useful and hard to outguess for scum, but also one that has an action that is proveable.

This should be something to get the discussion going; we don't have much else going on at the moment.

Thoughts?

[sheepofdumb]

I second this motion. FDM was advocating the lynch of a provable (and now known) power role. I know I've stated this before but I was really, really confused by the daykill. Now I finally realized what happened.

[/]

I agree as well, vote floresdelmal.
I have stated all my reasons yesterday.

[Natewolfman]

makes sense to me, vote FDM advocating that lynch yesterday was a no-no

[pmchugh]

makes sense to me, vote FDM advocating that lynch yesterday was a no-no

Look at nate all confident these days!

vote flores, I fully agree with the above posts. You were pushing for someone who was town to be lynched, what more can be said.

[AceArtemis]

Vote: Flores

I was waiting to see what the town thought before I voted.

[AceArtemis]

Another thing brought up in Day 1 that we should probably discuss now is the status of ani. Bolt brought up the point that ani should be vigged Night 1, and to my knowledge we didn't have any objections, but for whatever reason, that didn't end up happening.

This begs the question: should ani still be vigged?

If so, Iliad might have to do it, because it is uncertain whether or not we still have a vig in the game. Unfortunately, this uses up one of the town's two daily "lynches". (I'm assuming Iliad has unlimited kills, that's what I got out of the posts he made.)

In case you all forgot, here's the reasoning behind vigging ani.

Second, wierd as this may be, a vig should actually kill ani since if he is scum he is sitting on a safe claim.

Vigging the lynchee would cause the lyncher to lose automatically, or at very best revert to a VT win condition. I am completely serious that I want him vigged as the only way having him around cant create problems later in the game is if the lyncher dies early. If ani really is a lynchee, the lyncher really doesnt want ani to get vigged given that they will of lost.

I know, now you all think I'm obsessed with Its Bolt. I just think this was a good point brought up early that should probably be revisited.

[nagerous]

I thought this was a good point Bolt made on Day 1:

FDM should be lynched tomorrow for advocating a lynch of a power role, that is not only really useful and hard to outguess for scum, but also one that has an action that is proveable.

This should be something to get the discussion going; we don't have much else going on at the moment.

Thoughts?

The thing that is bothering me, is that someone could deliberately kill Bolt in an attempt to frame flores, knowing that he had said such a strong comment about Flores the day before.

[/]

I thought this was a good point Bolt made on Day 1:

FDM should be lynched tomorrow for advocating a lynch of a power role, that is not only really useful and hard to outguess for scum, but also one that has an action that is proveable.

This should be something to get the discussion going; we don't have much else going on at the moment.

Thoughts?

The thing that is bothering me, is that someone could deliberately kill Bolt in an attempt to frame flores, knowing that he had said such a strong comment about Flores the day before.

What exactly do you mean? We know who killed bolt, it was Iliad, I don't see how that effects the case against flores in any way.

[Stroop]

This begs the question: should ani still be vigged?

Yes, but perhaps we (Iliad) should wait in case someone else worth vigging comes up.

[FloresDelMal]

Agreed, it's not the slightest bit in the interest of town to lynch a claimed JOAT, essentially the most useful role in most normal games. Vote flores, also the only other one who voted after the claim is InkL0sed, for no apparent reason, jester perhaps?

I was in a rush and didn't feel like elaborating, but Its Bolt definitely seemed scummy to me. I thought his advocacy of a mass-claim seemed noobish (I assume he is one, as I've never seen him before)

he wasnt a newbie, he is a player from mafiascum or at least that's what i got told when i asked "who is that noob" that's why i found him so scummy and moronic for pushing for a mass claim, contradicting himself and claiming without being that close to a lynch instead of put an argument to defend his sorry ass.

Oh and sheep, of course i didnt believe his claim, i thought he took the easy way out, if i had believed he was protown in any way, even if he was annoying i could have defended him, as i have tried to protect other moronic players making suicidal moves in the past, 2 coming to my mind right out of the bat: Ani and william, of course both of them have improved since then.

Fair enough Flores Unvote

Lol that was Danodukesomething.

Agreed, it's not the slightest bit in the interest of town to lynch a claimed JOAT, essentially the most useful role in most normal games. Vote flores, also the only other one who voted after the claim is InkL0sed, for no apparent reason, jester perhaps?

From what I gather reading Bolt's posts he was a one-shot JOAT. About as useful as a one-shot cop generally... I didn't believe his claim either and it's definitely a more sacrifiable role than say, any role that can keep doing something after night 4 IMO so I'm happy Illy took the shot. I question Pmc's logic about Illy in fact; it's pretty obvious he would have never played it like that if he wasn't town. Can you imagine a scum daykiller announcing and dropping hints about his kill? Unless, seeing the scene, he couldn't kill without having his identity revealed but I don't think it's very likely. And if you indeed think he is not town, why do you want to keep him alive and lynch him "if he makes a bad kill" only then? That makes no sense; imagine the cop finds a scum, claims and Illy shoots him because he's in fact mafia hitman and doesn't need to survive. Explain that to me please
Vote Pmc

From what I gather reading Bolt's posts he was a one-shot JOAT. About as useful as a one-shot cop generally... I didn't believe his claim either and it's definitely a more sacrifiable role than say, any role that can keep doing something after night 4 IMO so I'm happy Illy took the shot.

Both the death scene and the front page say nothing about "one shot", I also don't see the posts of bolt you are talking about, as far as i can tell there is no evidence of bolt being anything less than town's unlimited JOAT.

Im "Bunnywith", a JOAT (Jack of all Trades). I have one shot kill, investigate, rb and protect. Planning on vigging ani tonight unless we lynch the lyncher.

as usual my conquer chauvinist take the easy way out bandwagoning the only woman at play who make no excuses for point out your lack of vision ^^

[FloresDelMal]

being that refreshed for those with fragile memory vote pmc

[pmchugh]

being that refreshed for those with fragile memory vote pmc

Huh? I didn't get the point of your quotes, I see no reason A. Why we shouldn't vote for you and B. Why you are voting for me.

The reasoning you quoted was answered by me here:

Lol that was Danodukesomething.

Agreed, it's not the slightest bit in the interest of town to lynch a claimed JOAT, essentially the most useful role in most normal games. Vote flores, also the only other one who voted after the claim is InkL0sed, for no apparent reason, jester perhaps?

From what I gather reading Bolt's posts he was a one-shot JOAT. About as useful as a one-shot cop generally...

No three times as useful actually.

I didn't believe his claim either

Thats cause your a fool Seriously though his claim was correct.

and it's definitely a more sacrifiable role than say, any role that can keep doing something after night 4 IMO so I'm happy Illy took the shot.

Maybe but its a lot more useful than many other roles nights 1-3.

I question Pmc's logic about Illy in fact; it's pretty obvious he would have never played it like that if he wasn't town. Can you imagine a scum daykiller announcing and dropping hints about his kill? Unless, seeing the scene, he couldn't kill without having his identity revealed but I don't think it's very likely.

On the contrary I think its very likely and does warlock sound like a townie to you?

And if you indeed think he is not town, why do you want to keep him alive and lynch him "if he makes a bad kill" only then? That makes no sense; imagine the cop finds a scum, claims and Illy shoots him because he's in fact mafia hitman and doesn't need to survive. Explain that to me please
Vote Pmc

Then we lose a cop for a mafia killer, a fair trade IMO presuming we aren't at LYLO. And we are a long way from LYLO.

[nagerous]

No ani should not be vigged, there will be no endgame if ani is lynched. Investigated maybe to check the strength of his claim....

[/]

Yes flores, we are all just being sexist, there really was nothing scummy about what you did, I mean, it must have been a complete coincidence that the jester made the exact same (completely not scummy) move that you did to get himself lynched.

[Minister Masket]

I'll have a vote count up tomorrow people.
Being hit with coursework in all three of my college subjects at the same time is not a barrel of laughs.

[AceArtemis]

No ani should not be vigged, there will be no endgame if ani is lynched.

I'm not quite following you here. Care you explain why there isn't an endgame if ani is lynched? I thought that if a lynchee is lynched, the lyncher just wins and the game continues.

[Iliad]

Agreed, it's not the slightest bit in the interest of town to lynch a claimed JOAT, essentially the most useful role in most normal games. Vote flores, also the only other one who voted after the claim is InkL0sed, for no apparent reason, jester perhaps?

I was in a rush and didn't feel like elaborating, but Its Bolt definitely seemed scummy to me. I thought his advocacy of a mass-claim seemed noobish (I assume he is one, as I've never seen him before)

he wasnt a newbie, he is a player from mafiascum or at least that's what i got told when i asked "who is that noob" that's why i found him so scummy and moronic for pushing for a mass claim, contradicting himself and claiming without being that close to a lynch instead of put an argument to defend his sorry ass.

Oh and sheep, of course i didnt believe his claim, i thought he took the easy way out, if i had believed he was protown in any way, even if he was annoying i could have defended him, as i have tried to protect other moronic players making suicidal moves in the past, 2 coming to my mind right out of the bat: Ani and william, of course both of them have improved since then.

Fair enough Flores Unvote

Lol that was Danodukesomething.

Agreed, it's not the slightest bit in the interest of town to lynch a claimed JOAT, essentially the most useful role in most normal games. Vote flores, also the only other one who voted after the claim is InkL0sed, for no apparent reason, jester perhaps?

From what I gather reading Bolt's posts he was a one-shot JOAT. About as useful as a one-shot cop generally... I didn't believe his claim either and it's definitely a more sacrifiable role than say, any role that can keep doing something after night 4 IMO so I'm happy Illy took the shot. I question Pmc's logic about Illy in fact; it's pretty obvious he would have never played it like that if he wasn't town. Can you imagine a scum daykiller announcing and dropping hints about his kill? Unless, seeing the scene, he couldn't kill without having his identity revealed but I don't think it's very likely. And if you indeed think he is not town, why do you want to keep him alive and lynch him "if he makes a bad kill" only then? That makes no sense; imagine the cop finds a scum, claims and Illy shoots him because he's in fact mafia hitman and doesn't need to survive. Explain that to me please
Vote Pmc

From what I gather reading Bolt's posts he was a one-shot JOAT. About as useful as a one-shot cop generally... I didn't believe his claim either and it's definitely a more sacrifiable role than say, any role that can keep doing something after night 4 IMO so I'm happy Illy took the shot.

Both the death scene and the front page say nothing about "one shot", I also don't see the posts of bolt you are talking about, as far as i can tell there is no evidence of bolt being anything less than town's unlimited JOAT.

Im "Bunnywith", a JOAT (Jack of all Trades). I have one shot kill, investigate, rb and protect. Planning on vigging ani tonight unless we lynch the lyncher.

as usual my conquer chauvinist take the easy way out bandwagoning the only woman at play who make no excuses for point out your lack of vision ^^

I had the biggest urge to switch my vote on you.

Just because you even tried to play the sex card. It's the bloody internet-no-one gives a shit or even knows for certain. You are scummy because you act scummy, not because it's all some secret conspiracy by us "chauvinists"

[FloresDelMal]

It's the bloody internet-no-one gives a shit or even knows for certain. You are scummy because you act scummy, not because it's all some secret conspiracy by us "chauvinists"

So illy care to explain why i am the only one being repeatedly bandwagoned just for dont beliave the claim of a guy that i still beliave to have played quite scummy? besides, is not like i am the only one who didnt beliave his claim, the guy didnt got vigged for nothing.

And about the jester, the guy was obviously not scum, and that's why i didnt voted him, becausei actually dare to think for myself instead of just follow the lead of whoever is more bloodthirsty atm

[Iliad]

It's the bloody internet-no-one gives a shit or even knows for certain. You are scummy because you act scummy, not because it's all some secret conspiracy by us "chauvinists"

So illy care to explain why i am the only one being repeatedly bandwagoned just for dont beliave the claim of a guy that i still beliave to have played quite scummy? besides, is not like i am the only one who didnt beliave his claim, the guy didnt got vigged for nothing.

And about the jester, the guy was obviously not scum, and that's why i didnt voted him, becausei actually dare to think for myself instead of just follow the lead of whoever is more bloodthirsty atm

You didn't vote him because I didn't think you were even posting then. If you were I applaud you-you managed to drift under the radar-a skill many people wish they had.

You are being bandwagoned because people consider you to be scummy. Perhaps a couple of those people are just jumping on the wagon. However you're trying to claim some king of sex card. I'm sorry lady but we're not running for Vice Pres here, this is a mafia game. Half of the people here probably dont' even know you're female.

If you are repeatedly bandwagoned it's either something you've done, ie scumminess, or they are wrong or they are out to get you. Argue instead of whining that's it's all somehow sexism.

Do not forget that I wield the difference between the life and death.

[Drench]

edit

[Drench]

edit

[Iliad]

Back and reading.

However, I did read the last page quickly, and Flores is quickly digging a hole for herself. I mean:

as usual my conquer chauvinist take the easy way out bandwagoning the only woman at play who make no excuses for point out your lack of vision ^^

What is that?

You are being bandwagoned because people consider you to be scummy.

This. I didn't know you were female until you happened to say it. Migods, this is a Mafia game! You have been scummy, therefore people are voting you!

Do not forget that I wield the difference between the life and death.

Am I missing something here? Or is this a funny? If it is, I dun gedit.

I'm reminding flores that I can killing any one of you at whim.

Just putting it out there