Coheed & Cambria mafia - Town Winnn.

[sheepofdumb]

And I can't help but notice Narkyboy is following along with it and not saying a great deal, certainly not the Nark we all know and love eh?

That, gentleman... and Sheep... is what brought it on...

Maybe if you wouldn't skim Skoffins post, you'd see I was replying to her implied question...

You mean those red posts? They hurt my eyes.

[Sierra_Leon]

@ militant: I don't think you understand the reason for my votes correctly, so let me explain. I don't join/push random bandwagons in order to get some random person lynched. I bandwagon in order to apply pressure to some random person, hoping that will provide us with some leads. You should already know that by the fact that I only voted Mandy after the deadline was extended. Until Mandy claimed, you and mandy were equally scummy, so when mandy's wagon toppled yours, I switched. After Mandy claimed, lynching him proved a wrong option, so I switched back to you. There was never a 'change of heart': you are as suspicious to me now as you were at the beginning of the day, which is saying that you were just as good a person to random vote than any other. Fortunately, now that some people (read: pancake) have been giving off scum-tells, I won't have to random vote you anymore.


Oh, and I agree with sheep that Nark's claim was a bit premature. I know Nark to pull that stunt more often, so nothing new there. I also think it's best if he says no more about it.

[militant]

Well, glad that is cleared up

UnFos Sierra

[Anarkistsdream]

Oh, and I agree with sheep that Nark's claim was a bit premature. I know Nark to pull that stunt more often, so nothing new there. I also think it's best if he says no more about it.

I was replying to a question, guys...



I also gave nothing away of value.

[militant]

Oh, and I agree with sheep that Nark's claim was a bit premature. I know Nark to pull that stunt more often, so nothing new there. I also think it's best if he says no more about it.

I was replying to a question, guys...



I also gave nothing away of value.

But you gave away stuff none of the less, stuff that scum would not have known if you had not said it

[Anarkistsdream]

Oh, and I agree with sheep that Nark's claim was a bit premature. I know Nark to pull that stunt more often, so nothing new there. I also think it's best if he says no more about it.

I was replying to a question, guys...



I also gave nothing away of value.

But you gave away stuff none of the less, stuff that scum would not have known if you had not said it

Better that than having all of the townies wonder why I'm not posting much.

It doesn't affect anyone else in this game but me, so why do you all care?

[danodukebb]

still..would have been better not to do that...and made up some bs that you were busy or at a work conference or something lol..

[sheepofdumb]

I don't care if you pull this stunt often. It was still premature and gave scum a good target.

Let's look at it closer.

Well, I'll say this... I am pro-town.

Scum: KILL TOWN!

I would tell you my role, but the way Skittles made it sound it may actually be important.

Scum: Important eh? KILL!

I can say that I am looking for a specific character, and that character is scum.

Scum: Looking for one of us? KILL!

Pray for a doc. Otherwise your a dead man.

[ga7]

Well, the most it says is that AD might not have town's interests at heart. FOS AD
Just kidding, but I'd understand better if it was the case But there might be several explanations as to why it wasn't damageable to tell this, so better leave it at that.

Anyway reading the reactions to PCM's case so far I think if he's scum Skoff should be next. If he's town... Skoff should be next regardless.

[Selin]

Mandy:

Are you day vig or night vig?

.

[jnd94]

I would tell you my role, but the way Skittles made it sound it may actually be important

I have a a problem with this. It's a good excuse for if you are pressed to claim and don't have a a good fake claim. I've played the card before, but the problem is that too many times scum are not lynched because of it. FOS AD

[Selin]

Well, I'll say this... I am pro-town.

I would tell you my role, but the way Skittles made it sound it may actually be important.

I can say that I am looking for a specific character, and that character is scum.

I am not posting because I am trying to figure out who this person is...

Maybe a vig will kill him or he'll get lynched first. *shrug*

Better that than having all of the townies wonder why I'm not posting much.

It doesn't affect anyone else in this game but me, so why do you all care?

Two players already claimed to have power townie roles and here you come with another one completely unnecessarily.
If you are pro-town, you can only win, if town wins. So why does it differ, if your scum target get lynched first? How can a vig kill someone without knowing who you are looking for?

And your claim is everything else than being an excuse for not posting much. You could have been active and look for your scum target in parallel.

Pretty suspicious in my eyes.

.

[Selin]

Regarding pancake there are two options in my opinion:

1) pancake is townie
2) both pancake and mandy are scum

Most probably the first option is true.

.

[/]

AD does sound an awful lot like a lyncher the way he described his role, but I believe he was suggesting something else, I'll say this much, I don't think he was talking about his goal being different than ours.

[Selin]

Analysing the voting patterns I realised that AD has been part of every bandwagon up to now.

1) mandy as the first one (this is the most harmless one at the very beginning of the game and can be neglected)
2) militant as fourth one
3) Iliad as second one
4) pancake as the second one

pretty much vote hopping for someone who wants to stay in the background submarining.

.

[Anarkistsdream]

I don't care if you pull this stunt often. It was still premature and gave scum a good target.

Let's look at it closer.

Well, I'll say this... I am pro-town.

Scum: KILL TOWN!

I would tell you my role, but the way Skittles made it sound it may actually be important.

Scum: Important eh? KILL!

I can say that I am looking for a specific character, and that character is scum.

Scum: Looking for one of us? KILL!

Pray for a doc. Otherwise your a dead man.

You stated nothing of substance in any of this.

[Skoffin]

Sounds similar to my claim in neighbourhood mafia Except less explosive
A lyncher would certaily make things interesting. Anyway, I still don't trust either Nark or Sierra. I will back off Nark a bit though, for now.
And Ga... you're so eager to kill me, why?

[ga7]

My theory is that you came out a wee bit too defensive of Pancake, which is odd and out of character. So either you're scum with him, or scum hoping to say "I TOLD YOU SO!!1!" if he is lynched and town. See, you're scum

[Skoffin]

If I think a bandwagon on someone is silly I will say so.
Or maybe I'm just hopped up on goofballs.

[sheepofdumb]

You stated nothing of substance in any of this.

Did I have to?

[Sierra_Leon]

Regarding pancake there are two options in my opinion:

1) pancake is townie
2) both pancake and mandy are scum

Most probably the first option is true.

.

It would be helpful if you explained how you came to these two options.

[Selin]

Regarding pancake there are two options in my opinion:

1) pancake is townie
2) both pancake and mandy are scum

Most probably the first option is true.

.

It would be helpful if you explained how you came to these two options.

Mandy is a very experienced good player. During the bandwagon of him, we reached a state where he was at lynch -2. Pancake was online at that time, he even made a post stating that mandy was at lynch -2, but didn't vote him.
a) If pancake had been scum/cult and mandy had been town, in my opinion he wouldn't have missed the opportunity to get rid of a good town player and voted mandy hoping that someone would drop the hammer.
b) If pancake had been townie and had no idea about what fraction mandy can be, he would have tended not to vote mandy in order not to loose a potential experienced townia.
c) If pancake and mandy had been both scum, he again wouldn't have voted mandy not to loose a scum partner.

When I made a search in google about mandy's role being Hundriah, I could only find 3 results, only 3
And one of them was mandy's post itself. The other two came from the same resource and Hundriah's name was mentioned there only in one line. This lead me to the conclusion that mandy made either a super fake claim (congrats to him in this case) or told the truth about his characters name at least. Therefore I believe that mandy is not scum (he may be a townie, cultie or neutral). In this case option c is not valid anymore and the probability that pancake is townie is significantly higher than the probability that he is scum.

Regarding mandy, we will have more clues during later phases and we will have the possibility to check whether or not he told the truth regarding to his role and sanity. He haven't answered my question yet. I wanted to know, if he is a day vig or a night vig.

.

[Skittles!]

"What did I do to deserve,
What did I do to deserve,
This?
This?
Deadline is Friday 22nd 4 PM GMT+10. That means you have less than 48 hours.

[Selin]

We need 9 votes for a lynch and have less than 48 hours

Vote: dano for various reasons

1) lots of vote hopping
2) skimmimg many times. There are other examples, but he reached the peak when he posted at the end of page 13 that Iliad is a cop and therefore unvoted him. After all the heavy discussions between sierra and iliad, and Iliad explaining in many posts about his protection abilities like doctor, I cannot accept that someone still think Iliad is a cop.
3) voting unlynch which can only help scum, and stating in the same post that "I'm just worried my knowledge of C&C will cause the mafia to vote me off"

There are some other smaller indications, but the above three are the three main ones.

.

[Skittles!]

Vote count:

Sierra_leon (2) - Iliad, pancakemix
Mandalorian2298 (2) - militant, Clive
FloreDelMal (1) - mandalorian2298
Anarkistsdream (1) - Skoffin
pancakemix (3) - Sierra_Leon, Anarkistdream, ga7
No-lynch (1) - danodukebb
danodukebb (1) - Selin

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.