LOTR Mafia-Night 3[On hold]

[Huckleberryhound]

Firth - but Koesen changed his ringvote to MM then?

Huckle - well I just figured it would be a bad thing for the doc to be blocked all game on him, but it's true that it's a riskier move. Ah well, I don't know

you might be right, but he'll be a target till he passes it anyway...best the doc reads this, than skims past it (not a lot of activity in this thread of late

[pancakemix]

Mandy's logic makes sense, which is not very usual. I'll follow that logic and Vote MM for Ringbearer.

[mandalorian2298]

I agree there, what are you expecting, a mass roleclaim?

Not necessarly a role claim, more like a side claim.
Anyway, I think I probably won't pass it on, just to be sure. Unless you think I really should in the town's best interest? I need opinions....
Where's mandy when you need him...?

Ok, the whole point of giving you the Ring is to make it harder for mafia to choose their kills. For maximum efficiency:

1. Don't post about wherther you are going to keep the Ring or not. Keep them guessing.
2. If you are going to pass the Ring, don't pass it to either Exile or me, because we are more likely to be targeted for Night Kill (if mafia dissregards the Ring-search, which they probably will.)
3.As you pointed out, if you are going to pass the Ring, there is a danger of passing it on to the Scum. All, I can say about that possibility is: Good luck!

[Huckleberryhound]

If the cop is reading this, can he investigate MM tonight, so we can see if we've done/are doing the right thing ?

[Huckleberryhound]

If the cop is reading this, can he investigate MM tonight, so we can see if we've done/are doing the right thing ?

oh yeah, i don't expect a typed response....just a suggestion to be read.

[Koesen]

What's so wrong about my suggestion to give the ring to LSU? Why is he a worse choice than anybody else and how does that make me scum?

[firth4eva]

does the ring have to be given today?

[Koesen]

I assume it has to be given. We can't let a thing like that just gather dust in a corner, can we? Who knows who will pick it up...

I still don't see what was so scummy about my suggestion for LSU.

[Huckleberryhound]

What's so wrong about my suggestion to give the ring to LSU? Why is he a worse choice than anybody else and how does that make me scum?

You bandwaggoned behind him in the lynch, then you vote him for the ring....looks kinda scummy, and i never even voted for you for that reason.

[Minister Masket]

does the ring have to be given today?

I think according to Chad's rules: there has to be a ringbearer.

[Chad22342]

does the ring have to be given today?

I think according to Chad's rules: there has to be a ringbearer.

Well not immediatly but the longer it takes to find the ringbearer the easier it is to be obtained by scum...

[Minister Masket]

Ah, I see. Thanks. Now I know why there was a sudden rush to elect a ringbearer.

BTW, @ the cop who investigates me: skip over the drugs incident, that was a baaaddd mistake...

[Chad22342]

Vote Count

(1)Koesen-(Firth)
(1)Huckleberryhound-(LSU Tiger Josh)
(1)LSU Tiger Josh-(Huckleberryhound)

For the Ring of Power

(6)Minister Masket-(Mandy,ga7,Dwightshrute,Koesen,Huckleberryhound,PCM,)


With 12 alive it will take 7 to decide, Day ends friday 5PM!

[Koesen]

What's so wrong about my suggestion to give the ring to LSU? Why is he a worse choice than anybody else and how does that make me scum?

You bandwaggoned behind him in the lynch, then you vote him for the ring....looks kinda scummy, and i never even voted for you for that reason.

I guess from your point of view, that actually makes sense. But my vote for TWO was in no way related to LSU's.

Believe what you want.

[Huckleberryhound]

What's so wrong about my suggestion to give the ring to LSU? Why is he a worse choice than anybody else and how does that make me scum?

You bandwaggoned behind him in the lynch, then you vote him for the ring....looks kinda scummy, and i never even voted for you for that reason.

I guess from your point of view, that actually makes sense. But my vote for TWO was in no way related to LSU's.

Believe what you want.

It hardly matters...there's so many submarines and no shows in this game now, i doubt it'll progress much beyond day 3 anyway.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I said I had 3 possible people acting scummy and most of the veterans in the game agreed. I never said definitely that TWO was scum although I thought of the three acting most scummy that he was the one with the worst excuse as he has more experience then the others. Right now though you've moved up onto my scummy chart as Koeson's suggesting of me or anyone else isn't that out of the question since I know personally I don't know who to trust in this game other then myself.

[Huckleberryhound]

I said I had 3 possible people acting scummy and most of the veterans in the game agreed. I never said definitely that TWO was scum although I thought of the three acting most scummy that he was the one with the worst excuse as he has more experience then the others. Right now though you've moved up onto my scummy chart as Koeson's suggesting of me or anyone else isn't that out of the question since I know personally I don't know who to trust in this game other then myself.

Then you need a big FOS for skimming, coz never voted for him for that reason bro.

[Huckleberryhound]

I said I had 3 possible people acting scummy and most of the veterans in the game agreed. I never said definitely that TWO was scum although I thought of the three acting most scummy that he was the one with the worst excuse as he has more experience then the others. Right now though you've moved up onto my scummy chart as Koeson's suggesting of me or anyone else isn't that out of the question since I know personally I don't know who to trust in this game other then myself.

In fact, i voted for him before he voted for you....unvote vote LSU

Skimming, and a second scummy vote in two days.

[ga7]

Chad, day ends at 5pm of which timezone?
On the ringbearer I hope someone drops the hammer so we can focus on the lynch, it's true there seems to be few active people so we might have trouble avoiding a no lynch I'll read back on that...

[Chad22342]

Chad, day ends at 5pm of which timezone?
On the ringbearer I hope someone drops the hammer so we can focus on the lynch, it's true there seems to be few active people so we might have trouble avoiding a no lynch I'll read back on that...

American Eastern

[ga7]

Mmh well I'm not confident in voting for any of the active posters right now but if there's nothing new near the deadline I think I'll vote LSU as I'm less convinced by his case on Huckle. My main reason being, I feel that we might hit the jackpot on LSU & Koesen, but it's pretty much a hunch. I'd like to hear more opinions though.

FOS Exile & Spin we barely saw you today, and it might work as well as with Dwight

[Minister Masket]

I'm bored,
VOTE SPINWIZARD for submarining and not contributing to the game much.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I said I had 3 possible people acting scummy and most of the veterans in the game agreed. I never said definitely that TWO was scum although I thought of the three acting most scummy that he was the one with the worst excuse as he has more experience then the others. Right now though you've moved up onto my scummy chart as Koeson's suggesting of me or anyone else isn't that out of the question since I know personally I don't know who to trust in this game other then myself.

In fact, i voted for him before he voted for you....unvote vote LSU

Skimming, and a second scummy vote in two days.

very nice OMGUS revenge vote. There was nothing skimming about what I said as I stated what I had done on day 1 and how I feel on day 2 about you.

[Chad22342]

Bump?

[mandalorian2298]

vote spinwizard

He is posting everywhere but in this game.