Re: (GON 3rd game)Town wins. Day 5

[crasp]

With 15 in it takes 8 to lynch. Day ends 23.59 Thursday 20th march.
Vote.

Charm- TheCrown
Killuminati19- Bantam
Archer- Gabseni (1)
Joak - H8 AFK (1)
Bantam- , charm, sirius (2)
Legionaire- jusplay4fun(1)
Jusplay4fun- Legionaire (1)
Mookie- king Ed (1)[/quote]
2 days to go people.

[charm]

I'm 100% convinced that you don't know what you're talking about charm. Quit throwing suspicion on me without some kind of proof. I think that you would only be doing this because you are scum and want to try and get rid of me, a seasoned veteran, who is town.

Vote Charm

Ah shucks! Thanks Crown.
I was feeling neglected that no one was voting for me.
Although, I am a townie and a noob, and may I remind you blonde with boobs!
And you may have noticed I did not vote for you, but I love to stir up some fun.
So now that I feel so special, you should unvote me or else it would be suspicious that you are a bum!

[TheCrown]

except that I now think you were trying to get everyone to put in the back of their minds that I worthy of a vote. That looms as scummy to me, and there was no reason you have come up with as to why you would do that. Actions of a scum, I am sure. The only reason I'm not pushing for a lynch on you is that you, like legion, are a newbie. So, I will be quiet at let others weigh in on which direction to take the town this day.

Most newbies seem to have my attention as scummy, and that may just be to their newbieness, but I'm keeping my eye on:

legion
H8
charm

[joak]

Hey charm..blonde with boobs must have raised a few eyebrows..I will be first tae jump in ..as yer the only lady in this town that I know of fancy going for a hot date to MacDs on the back o ma motorbike it's a big one...ma motorbike that is lol

[TheCrown]

joak, be careful of "newbies with boobies", keep you focus man.

[joak]

Sorry mate got a tad excited not much happens in this toon !

[Killuminati19]

Alright, time to get this moving. Vote Bantam. This will look lame being that he voted for me, but he is supposedly not a noob, staying quiet, and this was his response to being voted earlier. I let him off the hook at the time, time to circle back. He looks as suspicious as any.

[quote="Bantam"]No problem DB,
I considered leaving this reply until tomorrow on the basis of:
We've been watching and Bantam doesn't talk for 2 days and now its twice in a day that must be scummy..

To be honest if anyone does - then that's their choice.
There isn't much to be said at the moment - but am concerned that we have 2 people claiming roles on Day 1.
I've no particular preference at this time - and am in no position to make a vote just to get myself off the hook - evidence is flimsy at best.
By the logic applied to me - you could argue that mookie is next on the list on the basis of 2 posts and I've made three - I certainly won't.
The reverse logic could also be applied - those with the most to lose have the most to say ???

[Gabsensei]

well archer note wanting to vote is still my priority and i will stay on him but bantam is a legit person to be voting for even if he gave his answer? maybe as good as mine if you ask me

[Killuminati19]

Sure gab, I think there is some merit to what archer is saying and I am assuming he believes what he is saying. But I agree with the general consensus that even though we most likely will lynch a townie, it is useful to do so. I don't blame Archer for not wanting to be included on a list later, of those who voted for a townie on day 1, but I think he needs to put himself out there like most of us are willing to do.

[DB4Christ]

Well......I think Kill and Gab both have reasonable arguments at this point. I wish Archer would contribute more. In games past, he has always been more active and helpful. I don't understand his scaled back activity in this game......trying to look things over and come to my best gut instinct on someone, right now....he has my attention. Archer....why have you backed down your offerings in this game?

[joak]

Seems to me that all you experienced guys are scum hunting...you can't all be goodies...I maybe picked up a wee clue earlier but not convinced yet..let's see

[archer3base]

Well......I think Kill and Gab both have reasonable arguments at this point. I wish Archer would contribute more. In games past, he has always been more active and helpful. I don't understand his scaled back activity in this game......trying to look things over and come to my best gut instinct on someone, right now....he has my attention. Archer....why have you backed down your offerings in this game?

I feel I was too aggressive in making assumptions last time... I don't think there is much incriminating evidence so far except 2 people claimed regular townie. That is a fact. Odds they are both regular townie are slim but maybe they just don't want to claim their actual role to put themselves on the scum night kill list. That is an assumption but if I had to vote I'd vote for one of those 2...

[TheCrown]

Not to side with Archer, but it does seem suspicious that H8 got a little heat and has now buttoned up. It's been 4 days or more since he's posted, and it was a vote on joak (to throw suspicion elsewhere?). If I had my druthers, I'd rather lynch H8 for hiding rather than someone who's been on lately.

[joak]

Last game, the reason why we didn't get anywhere at start was because everyone was waiting on the night actions to come in. As the mod I know what the night actions were, and you can read them now in the archives of the last game. They were pointless. Every night actions on night 1 and 2 led to a dead end. The townies started understanding what's going on after night 3, when they based the deductions on the posts and votes of everyone, and they won. It's useless now to lynch on day 1 but it gives an edge later.

. Is it just my reading or does Sirius seem a little disappointed townies won last time

[Killuminati19]

H8, Bantam, Archer, I would be fine with moving on any of the three. I would also add Legion, to a lesser extent. I didn't care for the unprovoked claim. I wasn't aware Archer had participated more in the past. His explanation doesn't move the needle for me either way. Seems like after we presumably lynch a townie, his defense later on will be that he didn't vote for him.

[SiriusCowKing]

Last game, the reason why we didn't get anywhere at start was because everyone was waiting on the night actions to come in. As the mod I know what the night actions were, and you can read them now in the archives of the last game. They were pointless. Every night actions on night 1 and 2 led to a dead end. The townies started understanding what's going on after night 3, when they based the deductions on the posts and votes of everyone, and they won. It's useless now to lynch on day 1 but it gives an edge later.

. Is it just my reading or does Sirius seem a little disappointed townies won last time

I have no idea what you are talking about. In that post I was saying that you can't always rely on night actions to bring new info to the game. Last game the townies won by deducing stuff from the lynches, and so this is why it's important to lynch.

With your little post of yours, you just got more suspicious than bantam. Looks like you're trying to throw suspicions on me.

So to put my suspicion list in order:

h8-afk
joak
bantam
archer
legionnare

Then I would start to list the ones that I am still too much in the doubt. So normally I would vote afk or joak, but like I said I don't want to lynch a noob on day 1.

[archer3base]

H8, Bantam, Archer, I would be fine with moving on any of the three. I would also add Legion, to a lesser extent. I didn't care for the unprovoked claim. I wasn't aware Archer had participated more in the past. His explanation doesn't move the needle for me either way. Seems like after we presumably lynch a townie, his defense later on will be that he didn't vote for him.

I've only played once and it was last game... Maybe db4 remembers me talking more before because I was accusing him in the beginning when he was actually a townie. I just don't want to make the same mistake this time. Also, it seems that it'd be really important for scum to actually get someone lynched.

[Killuminati19]

H8, Bantam, Archer, I would be fine with moving on any of the three. I would also add Legion, to a lesser extent. I didn't care for the unprovoked claim. I wasn't aware Archer had participated more in the past. His explanation doesn't move the needle for me either way. Seems like after we presumably lynch a townie, his defense later on will be that he didn't vote for him.

I've only played once and it was last game... Maybe db4 remembers me talking more before because I was accusing him in the beginning when he was actually a townie. I just don't want to make the same mistake this time. Also, it seems that it'd be really important for scum to actually get someone lynched.

It's not that important though. Apologies to any townie who may get sacrificed on day 1, but townie's will still outnumber mafia by a wide margin. I have called out Bantam and to this point, have heard nothing in response. I agree on Joak. My list:

1. Bantam
2. H8
3. Archer
4. Joak
5. Legionaire

[Killuminati19]

Also, I have to wonder if my old mason brother JustPlay has turned to the dark side.

[legionnare]

Well let's see 15 players means about 4-6 Scum right?

For what it's worth here's my list:

1. Jusplay4fun - didn't vote on Bantam when the BW started rolling to get him to talk
2. Bantam - By all accounts has been behaving suspiciously
3. Archer - I'm not convinced but makes the list due some good points made elsewhere
4. Joak - As far as I can tell he hasn't voted yet, maybe he just isn't sure what to do yet?

I'm not convinced H8 is scum because Jusplay voted for him at the start.

[Gabsensei]

for what its worth there is my list

1.Archer
2.Bantam
3.joak

these are my top 3 so far there is many reasoon also kill is not far like i said in some previous post

[Bantam]

Well it looks as though I'm the 1 to go - so for the rest of my fellow townies - just take note of all those scum aboard my bandwagon.

I've outlined my position fairly consistently - god gave us two eyes and one mouth for a reason.

[TuffyLess]

for what its worth there is my list

1.Archer
2.Bantam
3.joak

So to put my suspicion list in order:

h8-afk
joak
bantam
archer
legionnare

Then I would start to list the ones that I am still too much in the doubt. So normally I would vote afk or joak, but like I said I don't want to lynch a noob on day 1.

I have called out Bantam and to this point, have heard nothing in response. I agree on Joak. My list:

1. Bantam
2. H8
3. Archer
4. Joak
5. Legionaire

For what it's worth here's my list:

1. Jusplay4fun - didn't vote on Bantam when the BW started rolling to get him to talk
2. Bantam - By all accounts has been behaving suspiciously
3. Archer - I'm not convinced but makes the list due some good points made elsewhere
4. Joak - As far as I can tell he hasn't voted yet, maybe he just isn't sure what to do yet?

I'm not convinced H8 is scum because Jusplay voted for him at the start.

I called for joak to claim 24 hrs ago and nothing of a response from him.
Here are others backing for a claim from you joak.
Chances are you're townie but i want to hear it from you to be rest assured.

[TheCrown]

Tuffy, no man is an island. You can't alone make someone claim, it has to be a group decision.

I'm not sure that Bantam just didn't have real life things going on, so he didn't post that much. If you all insist on lynching him, at least let him claim first. I did find it peculiar that Bantam didn't vote for any of the scummy 5 that seem to be floating around everyone's lists, but instead picked on killum.

[joak]

Sirius I'm not trying to throw suspicion on anyone I am entitled to an opinion the same as everyone else maybe I did read your post wrong that's the reason I didn't vote for you I will not vote until I'm sure and so far I've no real evidence on anyone I did vote for king ed earlier but removed it so far people sem to want to vote on folk that haven't posted or made a claim so maybe I should keep my theories to myself and not share them it only makes folk suspicious if you do people are putting we lists of folk they arre suspicious of and for the life of me I can't see where they are getting any evidence ..maybe cos I'm a noob ..but I don't want to vote out a townie so I need to be sure