[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[Endgame422]

Ok close enough for me.
I am mundungus fletcher.
I have no wand and therefore cannot cast spells.
Hope this at least partially explains my wagoning because my vote is all that i have.
And as to my defense noone made that case on pix/rage/dazza for me that is all me. I am also noting that tal would rather lynch ron or HP(again protecting pix) but like i said noone likes the pix case today because pix claimed he was poisoned but that could just be a stalling tactic imo. If he lives through the night ill be pushing hard again tomorrow but i doubt thats going to happen because ill likely be dead before I have the chance.
Streaker i am going to point out that you saying your vote is wasted on tal and wagoning on me is exactly why im being pressured today(i did the exact thing D1 and got tons of flak from dd)
I think virus is the easy target here(and the most likely target that could save my life) but imnot really thinking he is scum so,
Vote talapus
If he flips scum that would be a second scum defending pix and my case would be made for tomorrow.
That said anyone think that scum would be on every lynch wagon this far? I think ive been playing much too high profile for scum in the early days of a game this size.
Charm pushing me based on my avatar is weak sauce. I think charms town for the record but come on. Attack my gameplay not my avatar.
Also MPs intentionally buddying with strike for the 2nd time seems pretty suspect.
I would guess hes trying to build cred but idk seems a little transparent to me.

[madmitch]

according what I found out FLETCHER was capable of casting apparition and possible patrons and revulsion jinx which he used to escape Harry when he was caught stealing, in all he is a thief,liar and coward but granted he was capable of loyalty only to Dumbledorf which does not help us townies much now

[Talapus]

Vote talapus
If he flips scum that would be a second scum defending pix and my case would be made for tomorrow.

I'm sorry, I missed the part where I'm defending pix......please share with me so I have an idea of what you are talking about. If you are referring to the whole thing with cult and the three main kids I guess I vaguely get it but I certainly am not openly defending pix so need some clarification from you on this.

[Endgame422]

In response to mitchs flavour post i had my wand taken because i couldnt be trusted not too lift(steal) things.(ie:silver bars and lockets)
That said i helped harry with the horcruxes and took a polyjuice potion to disguise myself as HP(essentially being a HP meat-shield).
The irony of this is not lost on me as thats essentially what i am here as well.
FP by tal.ill find the quote but essentially you said you would rather lynch HP or Ron over pix which is softdefending him.
Both ron and Hermione are claimed protective rules so no difference there and im fairly sure HP is not the best way to test the fakeclaim theory.(Pix is as ive mentioned)

[got tonkaed]

There just is no point to pix today. Even if there is something to be gathered by pix flipping the assumption is that it would be happening tonight. If it doesn't happen tonight and there is no new information then sure.

[madmitch]

I know you disguise yourself as Harry,but as soon as Voldemort showed up you disappeared in terror leaving Moody to get hit by the killing curse. I rest my case.

[Endgame422]

I get why noone likes the pix case today but i call them as i see them. Perhaps i should have been patient but oh well,too late for that.
I couldn't find a specific post that summarized for you tal but throughout your argument about masonry you seemed to want to lynch HP(but knew it wouldt happen)so you attacked ron,essentially just bypassing pix despite him being a topic already which related to your point.

[Endgame422]

I know you disguise yourself as Harry,but as soon as Voldemort showed up you disappeared in terror leaving Moody to get hit by the killing curse. I rest my case.

Dude its voldermort.
Hes pretty scary.

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

Endgame - sempai, dd, Daz, Talapus, charm, Streaker (L-3)
virus - Storr, tonka, mitch, HotShot
tonka - MudPuppy
Talapus - Endgame

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

[got tonkaed]

Semp are you planning on using that second vote?

[Talapus]

I get why noone likes the pix case today but i call them as i see them. Perhaps i should have been patient but oh well,too late for that.
I couldn't find a specific post that summarized for you tal but throughout your argument about masonry you seemed to want to lynch HP(but knew it wouldt happen)so you attacked ron,essentially just bypassing pix despite him being a topic already which related to your point.

There is time to discuss anything you want, this day has no deadline that I'm aware of. And I get what you are saying when I talked about cult stuff but yes I certainly wasn't openly defending pix. And honestly I'm not about to even rehas the cult stuff until we actually find one I guess as it's a hot topic.

Honestly I just haven't given pix much thought after the claim and after the suppossed "Ron" went ahead and reminded us all not so subtley that his friend Hermoine was poisoned after we already heard that from her as well. I mean unless they are both in on it then Ron and Hermoine would have to both be scum. So I mean if you really think pix has that strong a case against her do you feel the same about our claimed Ron? I would think you would have too but am curious.

[Talapus]

I am mundungus fletcher.

Honestly, I don't even know what to think about this claim. One of the biggest names in all the books turned up scum and more bit rolls are actually town that we are lynching. This is like Streaker's claim, totally believable but hard to gauge. But I compare it to mine and I'm in same boat, I just am not sure names are going to give us anything in this game which is kind of frustrating.

[got tonkaed]

Dumbledore wasnt the actual role that got lynched. I feel like names have been fairly reasonable so far with alignment. I don't think there is a ton of reason to believe that Mundugus wouldn't be town allied.

[StorrZerg]

In response to mitchs flavour post i had my wand taken because i couldnt be trusted not too lift(steal) things.(ie:silver bars and lockets)
That said i helped harry with the horcruxes and took a polyjuice potion to disguise myself as HP(essentially being a HP meat-shield).
The irony of this is not lost on me as thats essentially what i am here as well.
FP by tal.ill find the quote but essentially you said you would rather lynch HP or Ron over pix which is softdefending him.
Both ron and Hermione are claimed protective rules so no difference there and im fairly sure HP is not the best way to test the fakeclaim theory.(Pix is as ive mentioned)

Sorry what role do you think he is? Because he is heavily flavor talking and it could very well just be flavor.... I don't see him hard claiming protection, just want to "protect " harry.

[StorrZerg]

Dumbledore wasnt the actual role that got lynched. I feel like names have been fairly reasonable so far with alignment. I don't think there is a ton of reason to believe that Mundugus wouldn't be town allied.

Yeah, but he likely was a fake claim. If he wasn't then you should be demanding everyone name claim.

[StorrZerg]

Talapus you pushing virus now that end claimed?

[Endgame422]

Hmmm i am just thinking that some of big names have to be fakeclaims based on the fact that myself and most of the other townies so far have been lesser characters and the fact that lynching voldermort has got to be game over so scum has to have some fakeclaim(s) at their disposal.
I feel like ron is believable actually.
mitch is playing his usual game by my read and repeatedly hints towards "protecting" his main 2 friends.
Not sure of details but what else would ron be? He has to be at least a decent role.
If he was inv he would have came out by now with at least a strong case somewhere and we already have vig/busdriver off the list.
Ive been thinking poison doc possibly or something to that effect.

[got tonkaed]

He might have an ability he isn't using to be honest. He kind of hinted at it in an earlier post with the whole point that he doesn't know who the scum are.

[StorrZerg]

So end are you vt?

[aage]

Endgame - sempai, dd, Daz, Talapus, charm, Streaker (L-3)
Talapus is possible scum, Daz and Streaker both are slightly scummy to me so I don't like this wagon.

virus - Storr, tonka, mitch, HotShot
Tonka is likely scum and Hotshot is slightly scummy so I don't like this wagon either.

I think we might be wagoning on two townies here. Unless the mafia are pre-emptively bussing their teammates.

@Endgame. I don't think lynching You Know Who is game over, as I've said countless times: this is mafia, not the magical world of harry potter.

Strike and Talapus still worried about the cult we don't know if it exists yet. Strike makes a note about it though, good.

Strike's list.

11. aage-Cult>town>mafia>third party. Too active to really think he is third party unless he is pulling a Storr. I feel like his play has changed a little bit. This could just be his scumminess coming to the surface. Could mean that he's been recruited. Still pending full reread of him, I would believe town over mafia.

Earlier today you called me mafia and you were going to present a case; now you say I'm cult, but you believe I'm town over mafia and you will post a case on Tonkaed. The 'scumminess coming to the surface' is interesting, is it because I changed my posting style since N3? More questions, less walls of text, I actually prefer this with the time I have on my hands. Shame. I was hoping to prove my alignment in defence of your case, since you're my #1 town read atm.

As for your other reads, the only one I really disagree with is Dazza, I think he should be looked at regardless. You say your limited read on him is town, what is that read based on?

[got tonkaed]

Aage - anything specific I can respond to that might change your mind?

Strike as the confirmed townie is planning on presenting something, but so far it is just the vote from Mudpuppy, who I think could be omgusing a bit, and yourself.

Unvote Virus

More content from him today and since laying low is kind of the biggest thing against him, no longer a reason for a vote.

[StorrZerg]

Common aage, you can give more than that. Strike called virus scum, might be why some sheeping

Please give some substance besides vote analysis. (On the players

[StorrZerg]

Aage - anything specific I can respond to that might change your mind?

Strike as the confirmed townie is planning on presenting something, but so far it is just the vote from Mudpuppy, who I think could be omgusing a bit, and yourself.

Unvote Virus

More content from him today and since laying low is kind of the biggest thing against him, no longer a reason for a vote.

What did you like from what he talked about today? Simply "posting " imo isn't a reason to unvote.

[charm]

Charm can you post the msg

It's on page 81

[aage]

Common aage, you can give more than that. Strike called virus scum, might be why some sheeping

Please give some substance besides vote analysis. (On the players

Sure, but short since it's late. Will post again tomorrow with more detail.


Endgame -
sempai = double voter, with the imperius curse stealing votes I don't think he's mafia.
dd = I'm not sure about him but I'm leaning town. Main reason is I don't really find fault with his arguments and I don't find the case against him convincing.
Daz = mainly a sheeper, from what I've remembered of this game. I don't recall Dazza posting a single creative thought in this thread.
Talapus = discussed before, I think he's scummy.
charm = targeted by the imperius curse on day one which lends credibility, now targeted by a different negative spell, scum must hate her.
Streaker = claimed Flitchwick, which is a strong name claim, but with an ability that I've never heard of before. That plus his name being mentioned in the note. I don't really care that his name is in the note - it seems to be fairly arbitrary who is in the note and who receives it, and we don't even know who sends it - but I really disliked his defence against the note. As I posted during that day, he mentions that you are 3rd party four times in a row, which is not relevant, just seems to undermine your credibility. Other than this he's been fine, and none of this would've happened if his name wasn't in the note, so I dunno if it's scum panicking or town panicking.

Virus -
Storr = I have no doubts you are what you say you are. You've been helpful and constructive in your posts. I have no intention of lynching you and every intention of listening to you, but sometimes you are wrong.
tonka = mainly a bootkisser. He figured me out for a town read on day 3 but he doesn't really say why. In my recollection he has mostly been following proven towns.
mitch = Ron claim, otherwise useless and can't read his alignment for shit.
HotShot = we've discussed this case before, it was halted before we could finish it but HotShot never convinced me he wasn't scum. Since that case he has posted sporadically and with very little content.