Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[autoload]

*Cough* The doc (AKA Exile) has been long dead LSU.

And why should you be the prime target while I'm the only power role in the open?

Vote LSU for not following the game.

I think LSU means that the Merry Men will be targeting Prince John tonight. In that case, barring a Doctor or role blocker, LSU will take the arow and die (Bodyguard). No need to vote LSU on that information. Maybe something else, but not that.

[autoload]

Never mind my last post. I see you already hashed that out...

[I GOT SERVED]

I'm really not sure what to do about LSU. I want to vote for him, as his posts have been rather confusing to me. But his role claim is rather believable.

I'll withhold my vote for now.

[Aegnor]

Already I'm convinced for now. A bodyguard claim sounds pretty reasonable to me.
We should start looking elsewhere, and go back to LSU if we fail at bringing up anything else.
Unvote LSU

[willis]

I believe LSU at the moment.It makes sense that Prince John would have a bodyguard in a game like this. Although IMO he did role-claim a bit early, and what scum wouldn't want to kill the bodyguard.
Also pancake did seem like he was pushing a bit hard for a lynch...

I'll wait until a little later to cast my vote.

[autoload]

I believe LSU at the moment.It makes sense that Prince John would have a bodyguard in a game like this. Although IMO he did role-claim a bit early, and what scum wouldn't want to kill the bodyguard.
Also pancake did seem like he was pushing a bit hard for a lynch...

I'll wait until a little later to cast my vote.

Dammit willis. We already talked about why scum would just leave the bodyguard alive when he made his claim early in the game. Why waste a kill on the bodyguard when he will die anyways if they target the Prince? You have been reasonably high on the suspicious list since the beginning and behavior like this isn't helping your cause...

[willis]

sorry I just can't think straight sometimes.
I agree that it does make me look scummy, but I can honestly say that I am not scum.

[moz976]

Ok well I'm kind of lost right now as to where we should go from here. So I compiled all the unsuccessful lynches we have had to see who was on them

Red=Confimed Scum
Blue=Confirmed Town
Green=Role Claims
Bold=Voted on all three lynches

Day One
wicked, AK_Iceman, spinwizard, hecter(nagerous), Aegnor, willis, Selin, dominationnation, Anarkistsdream, for dummies, LSU Tiger Josh, mandalorian, XenHu

Day Two
got tonkaed, Incandenza, moz, XenHu, willis, Aegnor, autoload, LSU Tiger Josh, for dummies, Anarkistsdream, Selin, pancakemix

Day Three
willis, XenHu, Colaalone, Aegnor, pancakemix, autoload, dominationnation, for dummies, moz

So as you see willis and for dummies have been on every wrong lynch so that to me puts a FOS on them.

While I was compling this I also thought that it would be a good mafia tactic never to vote wrong since you would know who was mafia and who was not so here are a list of everyone left and I bolded the ones that have never been on a wrong lynch:

1. pancakemix
2. XenHu
4. nagerous (replaces hecter) hector did vote in the first lynch
5. dominationnation
6. Aegnor
7. willis (replaces She Wolf)
8. red bull (replaces dwightschrute)
9. Incandenza (replaces jnd)
10. I GOT SERVED
11. LSU Tiger Josh
12. Guilty Biscuit
13. spinwizard
22. Colaalone (replaces Ehriggn)
23. for dummies

So I'm not sure where that is going to put my vote but those are my suspects at the moment. Anyone have any opinions on any of that?

On a side note I did the role claims from memory if anyone else has role claimed sorry

[nagerous]

So the mafia are the guys that don't vote for the townies? The only reason my name is in bold is because I didn't think Selin was scum??? I trusted his views and I only joined the game halfway through day 3 when hecter was replaced for deadbeating through the whole of day 2. That seems a pretty lame way to suggest that I might be suspicious because I didn't vote on one guy that I thought was honest.

[I GOT SERVED]

I also didn't vote for selin because I trusted his roleclaim.

As for the other guys, I prefer to vote for somebody only if I believe the evidence behind them. This was the case with my votes.

[moz976]

I think it is a valid theory. By not voting for someone who would later be confirmed as town it keeps people from looking at you as a suspect. You could always go back and say well I didn't vote for so and so.

Granted in your case it might not hold much water since you were a mid game replacement but it is something I am keeping in mind.

[autoload]

Ok well I'm kind of lost right now as to where we should go from here. So I compiled all the unsuccessful lynches we have had to see who was on them

Red=Confimed Scum
Blue=Confirmed Town
Green=Role Claims
Bold=Voted on all three lynches

Day One
wicked, AK_Iceman, spinwizard, hecter(nagerous), Aegnor, willis, Selin, dominationnation, Anarkistsdream, for dummies, LSU Tiger Josh, mandalorian, XenHu

Day Two
got tonkaed, Incandenza, moz, XenHu, willis, Aegnor, autoload, LSU Tiger Josh, for dummies, Anarkistsdream, Selin, pancakemix

Day Three
willis, XenHu, Colaalone, Aegnor, pancakemix, autoload, dominationnation, for dummies, moz

So as you see willis and for dummies have been on every wrong lynch so that to me puts a FOS on them.

Aegnor was also on every wrong Lynch. I am inclined to believe he is town, but nothing is certain with him. XenHu was on all of them as well. Included him to be thorough...

[LSU Tiger Josh]

What I find highly amusing is that people were talking about me "bandwagoning" on the first day b/c I made 3 votes including one on the innocent Mandy while 4 members have been on the wrong lynch each time. In a game of this size and no real deadline on lynching someone that I believe would be a more proper bandwagon type accusation.

[red bull]

I also didn't vote for selin because I trusted his roleclaim.

As for the other guys, I prefer to vote for somebody only if I believe the evidence behind them. This was the case with my votes.

same here i trusted selin and if i was mafia i would have voted for him

[autoload]

I also didn't vote for selin because I trusted his roleclaim.

As for the other guys, I prefer to vote for somebody only if I believe the evidence behind them. This was the case with my votes.

same here i trusted selin and if i was mafia i would have voted for him

Shoulda, woulda, coulda... That doesn't help us one bit...

[Incandenza]

Yeah, I know, I promised some sort of big thing... I'm still working on it, but for the moment I'd like to return to a concept I introduced yesterday after the... unpleasantness. It got lost in the ensuing noise about how I must be mafia since I'm familiar enough with the Hood legend to recognize a giant with a big stick as Little John....

Has it struck anyone else as peculiar that Cola has been quiet pretty much the entire game since he subbed in, yet was around and posting while that whole affair went down? Given the circumstances, I highly doubt that 'Little John' targeted tonka before the day began. Thus tonka must have been targeted by someone who was watching and saw him revealed as the vig, as tonka was killed not an hour later (I don't remember how much time it was exactly, but it wasn't much). There are a few people that fit the timing profile (yes, I know, myself included, but that's not the point), but Cola sticks out due to the fact that he just so happened to make 90% of his posts right around that time.

So let's get the ball rolling a bit and see what cola has to say.

VOTE colaalone

[pancakemix]

That's an excellent point. Still, let's here from him...

[dominationnation]

I see what you are saying but I would rather go after someone that has been loking suspecious to me for a while. VOTE PANCAKE You gave an easy unnecisary role claim. And several other stuff that I will go back to look for later but dont have the time now.

[XenHu]

Yeah, I know, I promised some sort of big thing... I'm still working on it, but for the moment I'd like to return to a concept I introduced yesterday after the... unpleasantness. It got lost in the ensuing noise about how I must be mafia since I'm familiar enough with the Hood legend to recognize a giant with a big stick as Little John....

Has it struck anyone else as peculiar that Cola has been quiet pretty much the entire game since he subbed in, yet was around and posting while that whole affair went down? Given the circumstances, I highly doubt that 'Little John' targeted tonka before the day began. Thus tonka must have been targeted by someone who was watching and saw him revealed as the vig, as tonka was killed not an hour later (I don't remember how much time it was exactly, but it wasn't much). There are a few people that fit the timing profile (yes, I know, myself included, but that's not the point), but Cola sticks out due to the fact that he just so happened to make 90% of his posts right around that time.

So let's get the ball rolling a bit and see what cola has to say.

VOTE colaalone

I saw that too. However, I for one have never found one vote very pressuring. So:

Vote: Colaalone

On a side note, I would just like to back up LSU's claim of bodyguard, or rather the existence of such role. I do indeed have a guard, and for now, I trust that LSU is it.

-X

[pancakemix]

I see what you are saying but I would rather go after someone that has been loking suspecious to me for a while. VOTE PANCAKE You gave an easy unnecisary role claim. And several other stuff that I will go back to look for later but dont have the time now.

Aegnor already cleared me.FOS DN

[Aegnor]

I see what you are saying but I would rather go after someone that has been loking suspecious to me for a while. VOTE PANCAKE You gave an easy unnecisary role claim. And several other stuff that I will go back to look for later but dont have the time now.

Aegnor already cleared me.FOS DN

Aye, the night Exile was found dead, I followed pancake and he didn't use any ability that night. Does that clear him? You be the judge.

[dominationnation]

I see what you are saying but I would rather go after someone that has been loking suspecious to me for a while. VOTE PANCAKE You gave an easy unnecisary role claim. And several other stuff that I will go back to look for later but dont have the time now.

Aegnor already cleared me.FOS DN

Aye, the night Exile was found dead, I followed pancake and he didn't use any ability that night. Does that clear him? You be the judge.

Ive never been mafia so gelp me on this. When the mafia chooses who to kill does only one of the mafia members make the kill or do they all? If there is a godfather (robin hood) does he make the kill or do his cronies?

[pancakemix]

I see what you are saying but I would rather go after someone that has been loking suspecious to me for a while. VOTE PANCAKE You gave an easy unnecisary role claim. And several other stuff that I will go back to look for later but dont have the time now.

Aegnor already cleared me.FOS DN

Aye, the night Exile was found dead, I followed pancake and he didn't use any ability that night. Does that clear him? You be the judge.

Ive never been mafia so gelp me on this. When the mafia chooses who to kill does only one of the mafia members make the kill or do they all? If there is a godfather (robin hood) does he make the kill or do his cronies?

He gets to pick.

[dominationnation]

so he could have been mafia just not the one who made the kill right?
my vote stands

[Incandenza]

Okay, I call major fucking shenanigans. Colaalone has yet to swing by, yet he found the time to run an rt game this evening. If I had another vote, it would go to him.

AK, could you prod cola please, if for no other reason than that he can be here when we lynch him?