"Plain Old Mafia" [Day 3] [Need Replecement]

[Ditocoaf]

Oh, crap. 3 people, one is mafia. I really have no clue which of you two is mafia, so I'll have to re-read sometime.

It should obvious that I can't be mafia, since Suggs was MIA, and couldn't have sent in the NK.

Actually, William18 seems more suspicious to me, just due to timing... since KK was posting in the night, while we thought we were waiting for suggs, but will showed up just after the NK happened. Since KK was present before hand, why would he have made us wait for the NK?

but I'm not ready to lynch on that quite yet...

[Kernal_Kronic]

Yeah, i agree that suggs can't be. At 1st i thought it was him & he was doing some major submarining & wiping us all out while we thought he was m.i.a.

William's post have been very suspicious, when icedagger claimed 538 was scum, william took forever to post (i think he was hoping the day limit whould run out & 538 would be saved) and then when he did post he asked how sure we were, when icedagger had stated he investigated 538 & that he was scum & then died, proving he was a cop.

I'm going to vote William18

[Ditocoaf]

ugh... I just realized. Since I'm guaranteed town, KK and Will you guys have to pretty much just vote for eachother... so it's up to me to figure out which one of you guys is scum... I'll wait for will to post something, then I'll just get this over with.

KK, if you know that you're innocent, and I'm innocent, then why did you just sound so speculatory about william? Your post sounded like you were scum trying to convince people that someone else was, without sounding too insistant.

So I really have no clue. Both parties, post your defense.

[william18]

ugh... I just realized. Since I'm guaranteed town, KK and Will you guys have to pretty much just vote for eachother... so it's up to me to figure out which one of you guys is scum... I'll wait for will to post something, then I'll just get this over with.

KK, if you know that you're innocent, and I'm innocent, then why did you just sound so speculatory about william? Your post sounded like you were scum trying to convince people that someone else was, without sounding too insistant.

So I really have no clue. Both parties, post your defense.

KK scum trust me! Did you see the way he jumped on me when you said I was suscpicious?


Vote KK

[Ditocoaf]

KK scum trust me! Did you see the way he jumped on me when you said I was suscpicious?


Vote KK

Well, of course he did, he had no other alternatives to look at...

and you didn't post much in the way of a defense.

What I'd like to see, is both of you to scan the past thread and find evidence to prove you're probably innocent; for instance, accusing or being accused by someone who turned out to be scum.

Never mind, I'll look myself. Then I'll vote, and get this thing over with.

[Ditocoaf]

Hmm... this was hard, because neither of you two were too active, especially KK... I certainly found a lot of scumtells in 538. heh.

here's what I've found so far:

At the beginning, William, you and 538 almost seemed to be working together on that bandwagon on me...
KK, your first post here was the hammer on lalaland, and you didn't seem to bother putting much thought into it...
KK, you avoided really doing much until icedagger confirmed that 538 was mafia, then you jumped on it.
William, you had to be pressured into voting for 538; and first seemed defensive about it.

Right now my needle is tipping towards william. Let's see one more post from each of you, make it count, then I'll make a decision.

[william18]

Hmm... this was hard, because neither of you two were too active, especially KK... I certainly found a lot of scumtells in 538. heh.

here's what I've found so far:

At the beginning, William, you and 538 almost seemed to be working together on that bandwagon on me...
KK, your first post here was the hammer on lalaland, and you didn't seem to bother putting much thought into it...
KK, you avoided really doing much until icedagger confirmed that 538 was mafia, then you jumped on it.
William, you had to be pressured into voting for 538; and first seemed defensive about it.

Right now my needle is tipping towards william. Let's see one more post from each of you, make it count, then I'll make a decision.

I hammered 538!

[Ditocoaf]

I hammered 538!

Well, you obviously had to, since he was reported scum by a mod-confirmed cop. But, if that's your defense, I'll wait and hear KK, then make my vote.

[Kernal_Kronic]

Sorry for the delay, i'm busy moving into a new flat & i didn't have time this weekend to get online.

My hammering of lalaland was purely to get the game moving. I was doing training for my new job & couldn't really get online much. There was nothing really suspicious about anyone so rather than having the day end with no information i hammered.

In my post about william i was just giving my reasons for voting for him.

There were only 9 of us & with 5 people dying by the start of day 2 there wasn't really much to say. This game hasn't exactly been a talk fest with a lot of people deadbeating.

[Ditocoaf]

I'm still far from sure about this, but william isn't putting much effort into his defense, and I want to get this over with, so [b]vote will18[/vote]

[william18]

I'm still far from sure about this, but william isn't putting much effort into his defense, and I want to get this over with, so [b]vote will18[/vote]

Wow you stupid. I was a townie.

[Ditocoaf]

I'm still far from sure about this, but william isn't putting much effort into his defense, and I want to get this over with, so [b]vote will18[/vote]

Wow you stupid. I was a townie.

Well, frankly, KK put up a much better defense than you did. You didn't even give any explanaion for the scumtells I found, and they were really weak scumtells anyway, it should have been easy. KK looked at the weak scumtells I found, and defended himself throughoutly. Also, while I admit I screwed up, it can't be denied that I had very little to go on, considering how inactive most people have been in this mafia.

[cmckinney]

i can sub if u need me 2

[Ditocoaf]

i can sub if u need me 2

no need; the game is over. I'm not sure if baggins will come and confirm this all, but it seems mafia won in the endgame... and it's all my fault...

good job KK.

[william18]

i can sub if u need me 2

no need; the game is over. I'm not sure if baggins will come and confirm this all, but it seems mafia won in the endgame... and it's all my fault...

good job KK.

Don't worry. This game was way to small and inactive to get anyone to slip up in the first place.

[Kernal_Kronic]

Yeah i was scum I thought i had tried too hard & looked overly defensive. I had to rewrite my defense because it looked scummy...and dito, when you said you knew who the other scum was I thought I was gone for sure.

It's a pity there were so many inactives, it didn't give town much to go on. I think suggs should have been replaced sooner, 1 extra person contributing would have made a big difference, also the death of icedagger helped a lot. We were going to night kill him on the 1st night but he looked like he had dug himself a pretty big hole to get out of.

[Ditocoaf]

yeah, the modkill of icedagger had a very large effect on this game. It closed the gap significantly between scum and town, but it also validated his roleclaim, outing one of two scum in the process...

[william18]

yeah, the modkill of icedagger had a very large effect on this game. It closed the gap significantly between scum and town, but it also validated his roleclaim, outing one of two scum in the process...

I told you that KK was scum and immediatly jumped on. You gotta beleive me next time!

[Ditocoaf]

heh. yeah, but next time you will be scum!

[william18]

heh. yeah, but next time you will be scum!

And I'll kill you night one!

[baggins994]

Sorry I haven't been around guys, my uncle died so I was out of town for a while. Anyway, everything everyone said is correct.