StorrZerg wrote:I can swing wagons, people this game just like following where i go....
I lead votes, I'm not letting other people do the work and hiding.
Yes - that worked out just great for us on day 1.
Of course it's easy for you to swing/lead votes, because given the choice of lynching you or a townie, the scum will always go for the townie. I'd bet that if a vote starts to build against a scum, then a few people (scum) will suddenly start to see the sense in lynching you.
StorrZerg wrote:skillfusniper33 wrote:Thanks, I was hoping you had investigated me last night
Honestly this is weird, why would you expect to be investigated.
Maybe because he's one of the few characters without a wand, and he was hoping that a confirmation of that might help to save him, since he knew his role claim probably wouldn't.
StorrZerg wrote:If skill is mafia, its possible they tracked/did something with deg so they knew where he went. Thus knowing SKill had to claim no wand.
Unless skill is some kind of tracker (don't know what actual role would do this), and he tracked me investigating him, how would he know? This was why I didn't want to say who I investigated first - because then he would know that he had to claim a wandless character.
StorrZerg wrote:skillfusniper33 wrote:WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:Thinking about it, Minerva wouldnt have needed a wand to be a watcher. She could just switch to tabby cat form and watch unnoticed.
I dont like the idea of killers using non-wand weapons. Doesnt fit with the flavour. I dont know mafia roles well enough to comment on whether there are going to be non-wand roles in mafia.
If you are looking only on flavor, Voldemort wouldn't allow anyone to join him if they weren't deemed a pure blood, and thus be able to use magic, and with most of his members being wizards I would assume all of them would have a wand, even if they had a passive role. If deg were to investigate a wizard then they would have a wand on them at all times, even if it wasn't necessary for their role, since the wand is the main way that magic is used in this series.
Interesting flavor talk, considering if he is what he says he is, he should expect some mafia to be wandless. Other wise deg finding no wand would auto mean town. That doesn't sound right. To me it sounds like he all ready knows he has been investigated by deg.
Skill obviously suspected/hoped that I had investigated him, because there aren't that many wandless characters, and you had already claimed one of the most prominent ones. And whether he was scum or town, if he was wandless and had no powers, then he's going to want to distance himself from the death eaters, because he won't be able to prove his role.
I don't think that this provides any indication of his alignment. Most of your case against him is about him being a passive follower. But since I would call him a less experienced player with only 361 total mafia posts, I'm willing to give him a bit more leeway on that than I would someone like you with 2455.
In the end, I don't have much of a positive case to make that he is town (though I lean that way), but I don't see that anyone has much of a case that he's scum. I think the strongest case that he's town is that there are so many people willing to lynch him without any evidence instead of a 3rd party. I suspect that there are at least a couple of scum on that wagon right now. Skill's not doing himself any favors by not showing up this morning, but I would rather go for Storr because I'm sure he's not town.
