[SPECIAL] Surprise Mafia - Over - Mafia Wins - MVP Aladdin

[Epitaph1]

I coulda had class. I coulda been a contender. I coulda been somebody, instead of a bum, which is what I am.

GL, everyone.

[rishaed]

:(

I coulda had class. I coulda been a contender. I coulda been somebody, instead of a bum, which is what I am.

GL, everyone.

epi your dead. GO HOME!

[Whatsausage]

I strongly suggest vig / day vig to claim day 1

Are there any other tips you have to help town lose as fast as possible?

Vote metsfanmax for making a serious comment in the first 24 hours, for shame

[StorrZerg]

Ironically mets is on the right track.

However, he isn't thinking about it correctly regarding what happens with a claimed vig.

First off I want to state that any claimed killing role that is forced to out, will look extremely sketch. Mafia, sk, vig. However a sk and mafia must survive to end game. Hence their reluctance to claim day 1. A vig doesn't have that requirement.

So with a voluntary day 1 claim, we can have full information on a kill, with reasons, and near certainty that the person is town.

So with that said, it comes to night actions.

Does medic save? Probably shouldn't. Why? Because if just a vig in a game with unknown roles. We almost certainly have some sort of investigation role. Not to mention can't be to obvious.

Does mafia kill vig? Highly unlikely. Why? Same as medic, they want to kill protection and investigation. Additionally a watcher could watch vig. Easy way to be caught.

[StorrZerg]

I strongly suggest vig / day vig to claim day 1

Are there any other tips you have to help town lose as fast as possible?

Vote metsfanmax for making a serious comment in the first 24 hours, for shame

Sorry, joke phase is over. Serious business plz.

[Ragian]

You don't get to decide when the joke vote phase is over, son. At least let people check-in. Also, who will sub for mtam before he ruins this game too?

[StorrZerg]

You don't get to decide when the joke vote phase is over, son. At least let people check-in. Also, who will sub for mtam before he ruins this game too?

Sure I dont, but some actual game discussion has started, so let's not clutter it with joke posts.

[Ragian]

Or you should've allowed for jokes before getting all bogged down in serious business.

[Whatsausage]

You don't get to decide when the joke vote phase is over, son. At least let people check-in. Also, who will sub for mtam before he ruins this game too?

Sure I dont, but some actual game discussion has started, so let's not clutter it with joke posts.

Would you prefer every player in the game lay out their thoughts on whether a vig should claim straight away? That is the type of discussion that could envelop the entire day without really gaining much of anything.
Say someone claims to be a vig, what would be the next course of action? It appears you would believe that player to be town, but where does that leave scum hunting? Hoping for a counterclaim?

[madmitch]

Welcome all, To my pal Degaston thanks for the vote of confidence ,with that said my first line of business is to say I think it is to early for anyone to claim anything and VOTE ALADDIN for voting for mod

[DJPatrick]

Razorvich wrote "Have fun..... and my vote is Djpatrick and Rizky..... I can smell Aussie scum "

The sharpbitch has picked it in one..soz Risky...looks like someone has a long memory and a short rope!!!

Not voting just yet, waiting for more pps to face the daylight

[AladdinSane]

What is your mafia experience Aladdin?

I have an entire game under my belt.

[AladdinSane]

Oh great, we have another TimWoodbury to deal with? At least you can capitalize >.>

LOL. Metsfan, my roll compals me to mispel a couple of times per post. I wood like too take this oppertunity to thank the cant who thort that one up. WIll try too capitolize corectly tho. I forgot too mispel in the post above ^

[AladdinSane]

VOTE ALADDIN for voting for mod

Welcome too supprise Mafia, Mitch! My thery is that the bigest supprise of all will be that the Mods have alinements: Streaker is obviously scum, so Dakky must be Town.

[rishaed]

OOOOH!! What if the suprise is that the Mods are Scum? Can we lynch the mods? Pretty Please?

[Marashu]

Oh great, we have another TimWoodbury to deal with? At least you can capitalize >.>

LOL. Metsfan, my roll compals me to mispel a couple of times per post. I wood like too take this oppertunity to thank the cant who thort that one up. WIll try too capitolize corectly tho. I forgot too mispel in the post above ^

Uggh, this is gonna be rough, especially with some ESL players. Aladdin, is it part of your role, or are you post restricted?

I agree with Storr to a point - I can definitely see the merits and advantages to having a claimed vig D1, and I do feel like this outweighs the cons. The point I would contend is that they necessarily should claim - claiming would be a strong, pro-town play, but if it doesn't fit in the player's style, then they might want to consider holding off. And if the vig is a newer player, or someone who hasn't been a vig before, then I would fully agree with Storr.

Vote / for that objection-able confirm post.

[ptlowe]

VOTE STREAKER btw: he was scum in that other gam, and lepards dont change there spots.

vote aladdin pnly scum vote for mods

[HotShot53]

I strongly suggest vig / day vig to claim day 1

Are there any other tips you have to help town lose as fast as possible?

Vote metsfanmax for making a serious comment in the first 24 hours, for shame

Sorry, joke phase is over. Serious business plz.

Vote storr for trying to stop the joke phase before I got my joke vote in.

As to the whole vig claiming discussion, a vig claiming on day 1 is more likely to be believed than one that everyone is suspicious of already on say day 4. Of course, by claiming on day one he is less likely to survive to day 4, when he might actually have good enough reads to be more useful. I know storr likes claiming early when something like third party or vig, but I personally do not do that.

[StorrZerg]

VOTE STREAKER btw: he was scum in that other gam, and lepards dont change there spots.

vote aladdin pnly scum vote for mods

vote
ptlowe

Yes... we should lynch ptlowe

@hotshot do it sooner next time

[/]

Finger Of Objection back at Marashu, because pointing fingers is a must in this situation.

I think it's probably not all that great for a vig to claim, and even less so to be guided around by town yet, unless they are day vig. In a big game like this, calling all your shots is just asking for trouble; back when I used to play, a baddie busdriver was pretty fashionable, even in small games.

Vote Hotshot because I envy his upcoming vacation.

[ptlowe]

VOTE STREAKER btw: he was scum in that other gam, and lepards dont change there spots.

vote aladdin pnly scum vote for mods

vote
ptlowe

Yes... we should lynch ptlowe

@hotshot do it sooner next time

Trying to protect your scum buddy aladdin? Or are you trying to extend the joke voting stage you have tried so hard to end. Either way your posts are starting to be scummy.


Hey lets have the town vigilante claim so you can kill him n1. .brilliant.

[Iron Butterfly]

vote storr

may as well as he likes to claim day one anyway.

[StorrZerg]

vote storr

may as well as he likes to claim day one anyway.

sometimes yes. I do see the advantages in early claiming. And certain roles i will claim very early. (like vig) I would claim that on any day 1 in 99% of games.

[StorrZerg]

VOTE STREAKER btw: he was scum in that other gam, and lepards dont change there spots.

vote aladdin pnly scum vote for mods

vote
ptlowe

Yes... we should lynch ptlowe

@hotshot do it sooner next time

Trying to protect your scum buddy aladdin? Or are you trying to extend the joke voting stage you have tried so hard to end. Either way your posts are starting to be scummy.


Hey lets have the town vigilante claim so you can kill him n1. .brilliant.

So points against you and why i believe you are scum.
2nd person to use the "x person voted for mod! "joke"" Reads to me as someone not trying to figure the game out and skimming. WHy? because they are just looking at minor things.

I follow this up with your blatant omgus. with equally terrible reasons building upon. (I don't understand how you can accuse me of attempting to be joking regarding my vote on you) The bonus however, is that you resort to saying EITHER WAY, as in, it doesn't matter what i said, only that my posts are starting to appear scummy. To which i would love further explanation. How ever i shall assume its mainly based on my idea about vig claim day 1.

To which you make a snarky remark!, yet you provide no input. Seems to me, you skimmed posts, saw several people putting it down, and decided to go along with the rest. Aka bandwagoning.

[StorrZerg]

You don't get to decide when the joke vote phase is over, son. At least let people check-in. Also, who will sub for mtam before he ruins this game too?

Sure I dont, but some actual game discussion has started, so let's not clutter it with joke posts.

Would you prefer every player in the game lay out their thoughts on whether a vig should claim straight away? That is the type of discussion that could envelop the entire day without really gaining much of anything.
Say someone claims to be a vig, what would be the next course of action? It appears you would believe that player to be town, but where does that leave scum hunting? Hoping for a counterclaim?

This discussion would lead to nothing? Well if my options are jokes and discussion about the game, i'm going to lean on game discussion. Do i want all people to talk about it? I wouldn't mind. I do i want more than 3? Yes, its a large game.