POTC Mafia Game Thread Day 7 Town Win! Premium goes to Sully

[nagerous]

Victor, we need to temporarily unite with mafia to win.

Vote Falko

[pancakemix]

Vote Victor

[strike wolf]

Well I guess this is what I get for trusting victor on that gamble. God bleeping dammit...I had you pinned as the recruiter and I let you get away based on the claim...

[strike wolf]

Also mafia should have no motivation to fall in line with cult. Even combined they do not make up a majority so they can't control the lynch and even if someone flips town still has Governor Swann preventing an unwanted lynch. You also can't trust victor. He has a sword now and if I was him I would be looking to eliminate the only remaining people who could kill him asap. Meaning that as soom as they eliminate falko you guys would be the next on the chopping block.

The best possible soluttion for every noncult would be to vote victor

[Commander9]

Gg guys.

[edocsil]

Well now I owe no allegiance to the Mafia. Insult to injury was added, and now I am cult. My old WC is still in effect, kill Jack and I leave the game, although I likely see him siding with the cult, as he needs to live. Victor, next time you recruit keep your mouth shut, I could have wormed my way out of it myself and then used it to our advantage.

Vote / as he is scum.

[nagerous]

Also mafia should have no motivation to fall in line with cult. Even combined they do not make up a majority so they can't control the lynch and even if someone flips town still has Governor Swann preventing an unwanted lynch. You also can't trust victor. He has a sword now and if I was him I would be looking to eliminate the only remaining people who could kill him asap. Meaning that as soom as they eliminate falko you guys would be the next on the chopping block.

The best possible soluttion for every noncult would be to vote victor

They may not be able to control the lynch but they can also force a no lynch and take out more townies in the night phase.

[strike wolf]

And still find they won't win because of cult. Helping cult does not help mafia.

[nagerous]

And still find they won't win because of cult. Helping cult does not help mafia.

Now they are outed it is better than siding with a town which will stab them in the back once victor (the cult leader) is lynched, town will then lynch / and then doom in that order and then finally finish off the remaining culties who have no NK ability.

[nagerous]

With Victor's swords, cult and mafia can work together temporarily to kill off two townies in the night phase, then by all means remaining mafia and town will have to sign a temporarily alliance to try and defeat the cult. If mafia and cult don't work together at this point however town will win through the power of majority (which they do not possess right now).

[strike wolf]

And still find they won't win because of cult. Helping cult does not help mafia.

Now they are outed it is better than siding with a town which will stab them in the back once victor (the cult leader) is lynched, town will then lynch / and then doom in that order and then finally finish off the remaining culties who have no NK ability.

Honestly they are screwed either way. So mafia...would you rather help town or would you rather screw over edoc who screwed you guys over by killing victor and nerfing the cult? Victor's sword is most likely protective in nature which means you couldn't kill two townies at night and it will just prevent mafia from being able to take out victor when they need to to stop the cult.

[nagerous]

By lynching Victor, they are effectively signing their own death warrant, better to survive than be lynched.

[strike wolf]

And I could say the same thing happens if they help cult but the truth is their death warrant has already been served. The only way it wouldn't. Be signing their death warrant is if edoc had lied and one of the scum is still hidden. They could jump on the victor wagon and remain hidden or they could help cult knowing that victor and edoc have that knowledge but town does not. It would effectively screw themselves over.

[DoomYoshi]

Well, if I was mafia, I certainly wouldn't be siding with Victor's team, especially now that it has edoc.

[mandalorian2298]

Also mafia should have no motivation to fall in line with cult. Even combined they do not make up a majority so they can't control the lynch and even if someone flips town still has Governor Swann preventing an unwanted lynch. You also can't trust victor. He has a sword now and if I was him I would be looking to eliminate the only remaining people who could kill him asap. Meaning that as soom as they eliminate falko you guys would be the next on the chopping block.

The best possible soluttion for every noncult would be to vote victor

I like the idea of Victor with a sword, since he is the only guy I can be sure won't try to stab me with it (if I die, he loses one of his pets).
Seeing how this game has become a real clusterfuk, I'll keep my vote on Edoc. Anyone who helps me by lynching or NKing him earns my help (I'll just sleep better knowing that no one is plotting my death). Of course, if Town has a plan to win this, I'm not averse to helping them out, for Mayor's sake, as long as it doesn't demand too much work on my part.

Fastposted: Yes Mafia, heed the words of DoomYoshi, one of the master tacticians that managed to lose a game for Town in which they got 3 free Mafia names head start. Surely he can steer you toward victory.

[DoomYoshi]

I find it weird that edoc was recruitable and not Mr. Squirrel.

Thanks for the vote of confidence mandy.

[sheepofdumb]

By lynching Victor, they are effectively signing their own death warrant, better to survive than be lynched.

Yeah but Mandy said something about his WC having something to do with the death of Jones. I doubt we can recover the townies the cult has claimed but it'd be nice.

[Falkomagno]

and now the freaking davy jones have a sword. mea culpa
vote victor

How do you figure that Davey Jones has a sword?

Also, I am faced with a dilemma. On one hand, I really don't feel like helping this town out since they are a pack of treacherous dogs. On the other hand, the Mayor helped me out, and I would sure like him to win. I'll have think about it.

In the meantime, vote Edoc since, well, he is Mafia.

C'mon...I'm always wanted you in our side, and now that the people who vote for you can feel regret of their actions there is no need to keep a grudge on town. Lets work together we still have the majority and all the bad guys are uncovered...Let's win this. Let's eliminate damn VS, since at night he will be really dangerous and protected, and if we don't lynch him right now we can lose right away.

Townies of the Caribean!!!! There is a day in which the cult won a mafia game...BUT NOT THIS DAY!!! THIS DAY WE FIGHT!!!!

if you are town, the better chance to win is to vote agaisnt victor, cult recluter, Davy jones, which now have a sword which protect him of a NK and give him the chance to kill!



On a side note, I don't understand something, why if the cult tried to recluit mafia before (Mr. Squirel), it ends with the mafia dead, and now it seems like Edoc was successfully recruited?? if is a mod mistake, edoc should be dead now, for consistency.

[strike wolf]

By lynching Victor, they are effectively signing their own death warrant, better to survive than be lynched.

Yeah but Mandy said something about his WC having something to do with the death of Jones. I doubt we can recover the townies the cult has claimed but it'd be nice.

I have the feeling they might be endgamed if victor dies...

[nagerous]

There's only six of you town, you will never get a majority to lynch Victor.

BWAHAAHHAAH!

Unless mafia want to play like morons and end the game right now rather than fighting on =)

[Falkomagno]

There's only six of you town, you will never get a majority to lynch Victor.

BWAHAAHHAAH!

Unless mafia want to play like morons and end the game right now rather than fighting on =)

6 over 11...it sounds like majority to me...

[nagerous]

12 alive... and also mandy is only third party - or playing like it anyway.

Why not just lynch edoc, I'm sure the mafia and mandy are baying for his blood

[Falkomagno]

12 alive... and also mandy is only third party - or playing like it anyway.

Why not just lynch edoc, I'm sure the mafia and mandy are baying for his blood

True. I count bad. The problem to hang anyone else is the extra night of recruiting for the cult,. Victor now is too powerful, and the only way is to hung him. Otherwise will be just surrender

[nagerous]

12 alive... and also mandy is only third party - or playing like it anyway.

Why not just lynch edoc, I'm sure the mafia and mandy are baying for his blood

True. I count bad. The problem to hang anyone else is the extra night of recruiting for the cult,. Victor now is too powerful, and the only way is to hung him. Otherwise will be just surrender

The town's logic makes sense, a pity it is just not the majority logic. This move means 100% chance of defeat for mafia.

Also, those townies that support the cults plan are more likely to be recruited, we have cookies over here

[strike wolf]

There's only six of you town, you will never get a majority to lynch Victor.

BWAHAAHHAAH!

Unless mafia want to play like morons and end the game right now rather than fighting on =)

Not idiots you know very well there is a very limited chance for them to win with cult or town. A chance that does not grow by helping cult.