A Cino Filled Mafia (2/27) *Game Over*

[rishaed]

Ok... that's it... the fact that he is SO pro-me and the fact that he just said everything in his power to align himself with town, PLUS his obscure "I am not a doc" reference does it for me... vote Strike Wolf

I AM the town doc, and I know for a FACT that Strike Wolf is lying... I knew when I said don't replace Shadow and I know it now... whoever disagres with me is obviously scum... I am even willing to vote myself if needed to die and prove my claim. I KNOW I am right.

OR you are a lyncher, who obviously wants to get SW/Shadow Lynched. Plus he never claimed doc? Anywho, full claim?

[iAmCaffeine]

Haven't got a whole lot of time right now..

Not changing my vote for now. Nark's last post seems desperate. I doubt he's a lyncher though because if so he's playing the role very badly with his eagerness to lynch somebody.

I'm not convinced Strike is town either..

Both scum?

[DoomYoshi]

I was the first one to use the word buddying.

Do you think neb would fail that hard as mafia, strike?

[strike wolf]

Ok... that's it... the fact that he is SO pro-me and the fact that he just said everything in his power to align himself with town, PLUS his obscure "I am not a doc" reference does it for me... vote Strike Wolf

Sorry if I don't buy into the "We both have 40 Ph Ds so one of us must be evil" argument. Sorry if I don't want to fully claim my role when I'm not at L-2. Like I said, I am not town doc, I couldn't see someone who was scum taking the risk on a "since I'm town he must be scum" argument (If I turned out to be town he would have backed himself into a corner and been lynched), in a non-game ending situation. I suppose maybe you could be a lyncher. There are some ups and downs to that theory.

I AM the town doc, and I know for a FACT that Strike Wolf is lying... I knew when I said don't replace Shadow and I know it now... whoever disagres with me is obviously scum... I am even willing to vote myself if needed to die and prove my claim. I KNOW I am right.

I find that interesting because all I'm seeing is black and white thinking and some jumps to conclusion. All I'm really seeing is that we have different roles but similar PRs.

I was the first one to use the word buddying.

Do you think neb would fail that hard as mafia, strike?

Desperate distinction is desperate. "Link", "Connection" "buddying." Whichever word was used, they were all getting at the same point.

The connection made wasn't that distinct. What was distinct is that one person jumped on it saying maybe you two were connected and likewise you jumped in telling everyone how untrue it was. Were you worried that he could fail that hard as mafia and distanced yourself?

[Anarkistsdream]

Well... I am tired of trying to get people to vote for you, Strike... it is obvious no one is going to follow me, 40 PhDs or not...

Vote: anarkistsdream

The lack of motivation in this game is ridiculous... Vote me off and prove me right... at least it will give town something to go on, and this game shows me exactly why I lost interest. This is just frigging obscene... 67 pages for 2 days... With at least 6-7 people we can call inactive? Do what you want folks, but I am done with this day...

And Strike. .. you have a PR...

[Minister Masket]

On the contrary, I'd say 67 pages for 2 days shows a great deal of motivation for the game.
It's only suffering at the moment due to Fircoal not being around to impose deadlines.
Not much point complaining about inactives either since 90% of games have them.

I kinda find it hard to believe that two players would have the same PR - in this case the 40 PHD's - and actually I think it's plausible strike has just nicked that from nark to seem believable.

One of these two should be our Day 2 lynch regardless.

[FloresDelMal]

argh i hate when everyone gets out of track and we can not get enough votes on freaking anyone but now after re-reading the bw on comm talapus seemed as the biggest scumster threat atm, he is experienced enough for being smooth while directing the town without attract suspiscion, but he was active on the lynch of commie, and he was happy to remember our mod that he had forgotten to modkill james (in an ever so well mannered easily mistook as well meaning way) and i am more afraid of what he could accomplish as scum than of doom and neb, which could be dealt with later on. Now about strike and anark, i think in this games there is a possibility that one of you could be pro-town without being town, in a chu's game things are hardly ever what they seem (or i am giving too much credit to him ) anyway vote tal because he has the most potential to screw town as scum.

oh and anark paraphrasing what a great lady of mafia once said "calm yo shit sir"

[iAmCaffeine]

If he's willing to be a nonce and vote himself then I'll happily see Nark lynched, town or not.

[DoomYoshi]

nark, i believe that you are town. I don`t believe your case on strike is solid. But I thank you for protecting me from everyone who calls me scummy.

[rishaed]

argh i hate when everyone gets out of track and we can not get enough votes on freaking anyone but now after re-reading the bw on comm talapus seemed as the biggest scumster threat atm, he is experienced enough for being smooth while directing the town without attract suspiscion, but he was active on the lynch of commie, and he was happy to remember our mod that he had forgotten to modkill james (in an ever so well mannered easily mistook as well meaning way) and i am more afraid of what he could accomplish as scum than of doom and neb, which could be dealt with later on. Now about strike and anark, i think in this games there is a possibility that one of you could be pro-town without being town, in a chu's game things are hardly ever what they seem (or i am giving too much credit to him ) anyway vote tal because he has the most potential to screw town as scum.

oh and anark paraphrasing what a great lady of mafia once said "calm yo shit sir"

Hmm I like FDM Her posts are quite refreshing sometimes. Also (Nark, calm down) 67 pages w/ d2 is b/c there is no deadline, but the discussion is never unhelpful. I also agree on FDM's evaluation of SW and Nark. I don't think that this game has such clear allegiances such as town/scum.
fp'd

[DoomYoshi]

vote rishaed

Of course this game has town and scum.

[rishaed]

nark, i believe that you are town. I don`t believe your case on strike is solid. But I thank you for protecting me from everyone who calls me scummy.

???? And out of left field Wha? Either way this post is off somehow.
fp'd:
also you should reread.
therefor FOSDY for skimming.

[DoomYoshi]

What should I reread? The fact that we have 2 confirmed scum factions and 1 confirmed town faction?

[rishaed]

What should I reread? The fact that we have 2 confirmed scum factions and 1 confirmed town faction?

The fact that I never said that such factions didn't exist, that you conveniently skipped the word allegiances, which I was using to say that things probably are not just town/scum/scum. Which is in fact the reason for which you are voting me. Also, I find it strange that out of all the cases you choose mine. There are much stronger cases out there, and you aren't doing yourself any favors right now either. The only thing that I am laughing about right now is that both you and Neb are voting me.

[DoomYoshi]

What should I reread? The fact that we have 2 confirmed scum factions and 1 confirmed town faction?

The fact that I never said that such factions didn't exist, that you conveniently skipped the word allegiances, which I was using to say that things probably are not just town/scum/scum. Which is in fact the reason for which you are voting me. Also, I find it strange that out of all the cases you choose mine. There are much stronger cases out there, and you aren't doing yourself any favors right now either. The only thing that I am laughing about right now is that both you and Neb are voting me.

what would make you think there are not clear allegiances unless you are third-party?

[Minister Masket]

Stop getting sidetracked by DoomYoshi. I voted for him before but I'm willing to delay investigating him further so we can lynch one of the PHD's for today and at least get some information out of it.

I think at this point nark has more votes than Strike, so in the interests of moving forward:

Unvote, Vote anarkistsdream

[iAmCaffeine]

rishaed you often seem to do a good job of sidetracking away from the main focus, quite often too.

[strike wolf]

@Nark: I mentioned my 40 Ph Ds. That's all that Fircoal said was required of my PR. This is ridiculous. You say you're our doctor but you are willing to get yourself lynched to prove I'm scum based on what? Flavor spec?

On the contrary, I'd say 67 pages for 2 days shows a great deal of motivation for the game.
It's only suffering at the moment due to Fircoal not being around to impose deadlines.
Not much point complaining about inactives either since 90% of games have them.

I kinda find it hard to believe that two players would have the same PR - in this case the 40 PHD's - and actually I think it's plausible strike has just nicked that from nark to seem believable.

One of these two should be our Day 2 lynch regardless.

Shadowstar's first post: September 3rd. 4:36 PM CC time.

Con40PHDs.

First time Nark said anything specific about Ph Ds. September 4th. 3:38 PM

Good GOD, man!!! It is already chaos! Good thing I am smart enough to figure all of this out... You know.... Because I have a bunch of PhDs from different Universities... Although.... Most of them are ones I made up.... The colleges... Not the degrees. The degrees are REAL!

Now Nark was also hinting at the PR before that with some of his comments but he didn't out right say anything about 40 Ph Ds.

If he's willing to be a nonce and vote himself then I'll happily see Nark lynched, town or not.

He claims to be our doc and you don't care that he may be town?

Doom continues to make an ass out of himself by going after Rishaed over something that should be pretty much a non-issue. He didn't say there wasn't scum doom. He said that their could be more than simple town/scum/scum mechanic. with a Hoodlum faction coming to the surface and multiple unknowns is that really surprising?

Rodion: Before I forget to mention this again (it's difficult keeping track of 40 Ph Ds.) I would like to see Rodion vote for someone who is actually in the game and see if Fircoal counts it. His one vote was on Democracy and Fircoal counted it (possibly jokingly?). I can't think of why he would fake being voteless as mafia/anti-town (The last time I remember anyone trying was when I could only vote to hammer in Memebase and used that as "proof" of my votelessness) but I would still like to see proof of the claim.

[iAmCaffeine]

Rodion: Before I forget to mention this again (it's difficult keeping track of 40 Ph Ds.) I would like to see Rodion vote for someone who is actually in the game and see if Fircoal counts it. His one vote was on Democracy and Fircoal counted it (possibly jokingly?). I can't think of why he would fake being voteless as mafia/anti-town (The last time I remember anyone trying was when I could only vote to hammer in Memebase and used that as "proof" of my votelessness) but I would still like to see proof of the claim.

I realise you had a lot to catch up on, but when Rodion voted Democracy it was because he was not allowed to vote on that day.

He claims to be our doc and you don't care that he may be town?

Even if he is the town doc, he's clearly not interested in helping the town any more so let him go, at least that will give us some info.

I find it very odd that you're supporting the fact that he's town when he's clearly voting for you, Strike.

[Anarkistsdream]

You guys can't even get it together enough to lynch me! Again, as I said, ridiculous. Strike, you didn't include your pr in the post right before my last one... that is what I was talking about... 40 PhDs aren't worth the trouble you all are giving me... I am town, I am a doctor...

My role is Doc with 40 PhDs, before anyone asks... That IS the role name. Seriously, this is far too big a game and with three factions, this will never get done... This is all I am posting in this thread until I am lynched or until you all get your heads out of your rears long enough to agree on another.

[rishaed]

Rodion: Before I forget to mention this again (it's difficult keeping track of 40 Ph Ds.) I would like to see Rodion vote for someone who is actually in the game and see if Fircoal counts it. His one vote was on Democracy and Fircoal counted it (possibly jokingly?). I can't think of why he would fake being voteless as mafia/anti-town (The last time I remember anyone trying was when I could only vote to hammer in Memebase and used that as "proof" of my votelessness) but I would still like to see proof of the claim.

I realise you had a lot to catch up on, but when Rodion voted Democracy it was because he was not allowed to vote on that day.

He claims to be our doc and you don't care that he may be town?

Even if he is the town doc, he's clearly not interested in helping the town any more so let him go, at least that will give us some info.

I find it very odd that you're supporting the fact that he's town when he's clearly voting for you, Strike.

YOU NEVER LYNCH THE TOWN DOC! Ever, he's not drawing my vote unless proven otherwise >.> Because he's probably first on the chopping block tonight by scum if he is telling the truth (what's left of them).

[Rodion]

I just searched the word "democracy" ITT and there was a vote count, but it was made by Jamesker.

Anyway, unvote, vote Saf per Strike's request.

(I'll be catching up the last 5-7 pages this weekend. Right now I only found this because I searched Rodion in all CC forums to see what people were talking about me - yes, I'm that vain)

[iAmCaffeine]

Unvote, vote Strike Wolf.

I don't believe Nark's and Strike's roles are different, and since Strike is not counter claiming Nark's claim of town doctor, Strike must be one of the scum factions. If not, then Nark is.

rishaed, nice of you to post but ignore the point I raised against you.

@Doom, why are you voting for rishaed? It's just causing more issues in lynching someone. Whilst I certainly don't trust rishaed, he is not a concern at the moment and not a priority. We need to to lynch between the doctors. It seems odd that you're trying to cause more confusion, as much of a troll that you are.

@Rodion, why vote for saf?

[safariguy5]

I don't know about this town doctor claim from Nark.

I feel that to get some resolution here, I should share relevant information. I am Dr. Phil (from the TV show) and I am Town Doc.

I protected TWO Night 1 (night action would be nice Nark).

However, since TWO died, I have a feeling that I am possibly Quack or CPR or however the role is called by Fir.

If this is true, then it's completely possible that Nark is the real doc and I'm basically like a vig. If this is false and TWO died due to some other mechanic and not my target, then Nark is probably lying and we should lynch him.

Of course, there is a small possibility both of us are doctors, but I think this is pretty unlikely.

[jonty125]

[b]unvote, vote Nark[b]

1. Town doc should never vote oneself, when it's not going to prove anything.
2. Saf has claimed doc, I believe there is only one standard town doc, in this game, there could be a few other docs, out there. Given, saf's, target died N1, but that could be a anomaly.