C9 Newbie Game- Endgame

[wcaclimbing]

so many angry people

[AceArtemis]

Deadline is in about 46 hours from the time of this post. Remember that at deadlines, the player with the most votes is lynched.

[sully800]

I think Hopscotcher was just acting pretty strange but supported himself well. At the moment I am much more suspicious of pi, then simon so that will guide my vote. If pi turns out to be town though it definitely doesn't mean that Simon is mafia (though he will be my first suspect!)

Stroop is the person that I find myself agreeing with the most now. In my eyes this means he is either being a helpful townie or a mafia member good at his job. In either case I'm glad to see he's not sitting back and for the moment he is a person that I trust.

wca seems to be town to me as well, but if pi turns out to be innocent then wca would be good to interrogate (since they've been fighting).

anyway, here we go vote e_i_pi

[Mr. Squirrel]

anyway, here we go vote e_i_pi

And so the first lynch is made...alright, ace, what's the verdict?

[e_i_pi]

Lynched for accusing a lurker, and then recanting when the lurker turned up and seemed legit. God bless democracy

Oh, and before I go to the gallows, I'll point the FOS at Sully... strange how he doesn't vote til the last minute, all the while claiming to be the impartial investigator. He seems to have sat on the sidelines until the knife can go in the back without it coming back on him. Isn't he a veteran of mafia games? Someone who knows how to play them? Amazing how he's suspicious of me, yet provides no reason for suspicion. He's had his eye on me the whole time apparently... oh wait, no he hasn't... only since I had 3 votes. A little odd, don't you think, trying to talk up how suspicious I am in the dying moments when the clock is ticking down? Almost as if he were trying to tell a convincing story that hopefully someone else would believe, such that they would ring the death knell, so he didn't have to appear suspicious himself by casting a vote. Look at him acting as the kind elderly family friend, pretending to play the impartial referee, all the while the fatal gavel being inextricably held in his paw. What is it we call an elderly male family friend? Oh yes, that's right... godfather...

[Simon Viavant]

So you were innocent?

[sully800]

Lynched for accusing a lurker, and then recanting when the lurker turned up and seemed legit. God bless democracy

Oh, and before I go to the gallows, I'll point the FOS at Sully... strange how he doesn't vote til the last minute, all the while claiming to be the impartial investigator. He seems to have sat on the sidelines until the knife can go in the back without it coming back on him. Isn't he a veteran of mafia games? Someone who knows how to play them? Amazing how he's suspicious of me, yet provides no reason for suspicion. He's had his eye on me the whole time apparently... oh wait, no he hasn't... only since I had 3 votes. A little odd, don't you think, trying to talk up how suspicious I am in the dying moments when the clock is ticking down? Almost as if he were trying to tell a convincing story that hopefully someone else would believe, such that they would ring the death knell, so he didn't have to appear suspicious himself by casting a vote. Look at him acting as the kind elderly family friend, pretending to play the impartial referee, all the while the fatal gavel being inextricably held in his paw. What is it we call an elderly male family friend? Oh yes, that's right... godfather...

You've had 3 votes for over 72 hours, its not like this was sudden or I didn't give it thought (or say my intentions in my previous posts by asking you both to post and prove your innocence). Though I do like your godfather analogy.

BUT your logic is mistaken, because if I had not voted for you in the next two days you would have been lynched anyway as said in the post before mine.

Deadline is in about 46 hours from the time of this post. Remember that at deadlines, the player with the most votes is lynched.

Now this is going to sound suspicious, but I want a fair game and I don't believe you are allowed to talk any more in this thread. If we lynched you and you were innocent then I apologize, but I will guarantee everyone I am not mafia.

8. Once you are killed, you are eliminated from the game. No posting once you are dead.

[Stroop]

Now this is going to sound suspicious, but I want a fair game and I don't believe you are allowed to talk any more in this thread. If we lynched you and you were innocent then I apologize, but I will guarantee everyone I am not mafia.

8. Once you are killed, you are eliminated from the game. No posting once you are dead.

Until the mod actually posts the dead scene, he's not dead

[sully800]

That's strange. I guess then its 4 votes for us to give a message to Ace to kill him. Not 4 votes to lynch him directly

Well if its fair then please speak your mind!

[Mr. Squirrel]

That's strange. I guess then its 4 votes for us to give a message to Ace to kill him. Not 4 votes to lynch him directly

If that's true, does that mean someone could unvote and save him?

[AceArtemis]

-Vote Count-

e_i_pi-4, (Stroop, wcaclimbing, Simon Viavant, sully800)
Simon Viavant-2, (Hopscotcher, e_i_pi)
Hopscotcher-1, (Mr. Squirrel)

Not Voting: -no one-

With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch.

e_i_pi is lynched. Death scene coming soon.

[AceArtemis]

-Scene-

Soon after the anonymous man's speech on City Hall, accusations started flying. After some period of time, e_i_pi was called out for not participating enough. After some more arguing, the sun had started to set, so the town finally decided to lynch e_i_pi.

After lynching e_i_pi, the town looked through his belongings and found nothing suspicious. It seems e_i_pi was just an ordinary, average guy. Too bad, e_i_pi.

e_i_pi (Vanilla Townie) is lynched.

Night 1 Has Begun. Night Actions are due in 48 hours.

[e_i_pi]

Now this is going to sound suspicious, but I want a fair game and I don't believe you are allowed to talk any more in this thread. If we lynched you and you were innocent then I apologize, but I will guarantee everyone I am not mafia.

8. Once you are killed, you are eliminated from the game. No posting once you are dead.

Until the mod actually posts the dead scene, he's not dead

This was my understanding, sorry if I inadvertantly broke the rules. GL guys!

[AceArtemis]

-Scene-

The next morning, when the town woke up, it seemed like a normal day. There were no bloody corpses in plain view, nothing to anger the town and start riots in the streets. It seemed normal, until someone noticed Mr. Squirrel was missing. Once word got around, the people searched all around the city for Mr. Squirrel. Eventually, his dead body was found in an obscure back alley next to an abandoned warehouse.

Although the town had no idea what the mafia's motives were, one thing was certain: those fiends must be brought to justice. The town quickly agreed on the same majority vote lynching they used the previous day. Everyone remembered the events of yesterday in crystal clear detail, and they were furious about having their nice, peaceful city invaded by the mafia. But will they be able to stop the growing threat before they take over the town?

Mr. Squirrel (Vanilla Townie) has been murdered!

Day 2 Has Begun! With 5 alive, it's 3 to lynch.

[Mr. Squirrel]

<----Funeral Ceremony

[wcaclimbing]

no!

two down already....

sorry about lynching you out pi...

I've made a mess of my first game

[Stroop]

At least we didn't lose the cop or doc (if they are in this game).

I'm going to point a finger at sully. The whole game he does nothing but FOS people (I think he literally FOSed everyone...) and when he finally votes, it's to lynch a townie. He tries to influence everyone's decision and when he notices that a majority is doing something, he jumps on the bandwagon, killing a townie in the process.

vote sully

[sully800]

I knew that accusation would be coming. Yes, I know it looks suspicious since I was the final lyncher for e_i_pi and he accused me right after we sent him to the gallows. However it was not like I just jumped on a band wagon and did not continually and consistently explain my reasoning. He had 3 votes for almost 3 days, so if anyone else who voted for him did not want to go through with the lynch they could have easily unvoted.

Moving on, my suspects after a townie lynch must always be the ones who were involved in that lynch. Also on that list are: Stroop, wcaclimbing, and Simon Viavant

Simon is good to look at right now since he was previously on the opposite side of the vote. pi voted for him and we now know that pi was on the good side. Unfortunately there were 3 votes for Simon as well and he could have been lynched at one point so chances are he is NOT mafia (because they probably would have been more persuasive earlier about not voting for Simon).

Now, the big outlier is Mr. Squirrel. He voted by himself for Hopscotcher, and was unable to gather support from anyone else. Then in the night Mr. Squirrel is the one who got lynched. Perhaps he was onto a trail? Here is what Mr. Squirrel said of value that may have gotten him killed.

See everyone! He admits to lying! That scum. fos: sully

And for the record:unvote. Hopscotcher is already at 2 and with only 4 needed to lynch, I wouldn't want him to be lynched because of my joke vote.

Unless some better evidence comes up, I'm going to no vote. or vote no lynch. or whatever I'm supposed to say to officially not vote for anyone.

I just don't feel comfortable voting someone out with so little evidence to work with. If someone brings up something good later on, I may change my vote. But for now, I don't want to lynch when we could so easily kill a townie.

And what will change by the second day? If we just don't lynch anyone today, day 2 will be no different than day 1. I don't see the point in not lynching. We are gonna have to eventually, otherwise the mafia will never die.

In fact, I find your opinion rather scummy...vote wca

Mr. Squirrel has said a lot of useless stuff and now he intends to sit back until someone makes a mistake.

Well, it's kind of hard to say anything useful when you have no posts from anyone else to go by. Right now, sitting back is the only option since I have no info to go on.

I'm gonna have to help out pi here. I don't see why you two are trying to lynch him for being a lurker. For starters, there has been very little to discuss so far in this game unless you wanted to start analyzing joke/random votes. Plus, he wasn't inactive for that long (he posted on page 4).

I think the fact that you two are pushing this so quickly and are trying to form a bandwagon, is far more scummy than what pi has done.
vote simon viavant

am by no means suggesting we lynch Simon. He may be totally innocent. If the vote were close to a lynch for Simon, I'd Unvote. But I'm sticking to my guns.

You think he's scum but you don't want to lynch him, how in the world does that make sense? And btw, he is very close to a lynch. In fact, one more vote for him and he is lynched.

FOS mr. squirrel you really are obvious.

I decided to side with pi simply because I don't see the case you have against him. He didn't post for two days, so what? In that whole time there was only a handful of posts so it is not like he was the only one not active. Plus, he says he was busy with work, which should always come before an internet game. I'm not saying he's innocent or guilty (I'm still not sure myself). I just don't think your reasoning is strong enough to deserve him getting lynched. If you could find some more concrete evidence of his scumminess, I would have no problem casting the fourth vote against him.

I think you are just trying to push a lynch early on in the game when we have very little information to go by. That way, when you and your mafia partner decide to kill off somebody tonight, you guys won't look suspicious since no enemies or connections were made on day 1. Very sneaky of you.

And FOS on wca. You seemed awfully eager to place your vote on pi despite the fact that a few pages ago you were dead set in voting no lynch.

So basically you are claiming that you will vote for any of the three most suspicious people as long as other people are voting for them? You say that maybe viavant is scum but WCA "screams" scum to you. If so, why don't you change your vote? Why would you keep a vote on someone who you are unsure about, especially when they are this close to a lynch?

The reason is because you want to see a lynch. Despite what you said earlier here:

If the vote were close to a lynch for Simon, I'd Unvote.

Simon has been one vote away from a lynch for a while now and you still have yet to unvote. You just want to see a townie get lynched. That is why you are willing to change your vote to wca if there is a large surge towards it but for now you want to stay on the one with the most votes.
unvote simon
vote hopscotcher
This guy just "screams" scum to me.

Based on Mr. Squirrel's pattern throughout the thread, my top three suspects are Simon, wca, and Hopscotcher. I will pardon Simon for now for the reasons mentioned earlier, but I feel like wca has definitely been flying under the radar. My vote goes to Hopscotcher though, because Squirrel was the only one to suspect him and then Squirrel is the one killed in the night.

Vote Hopscotcher.

I'm going to point a finger at sully. The whole game he does nothing but FOS people (I think he literally FOSed everyone...)

Yes you're right, and if you aren't suspicious of everyone on the first day then you aren't playing the game right (or you already know who the mafia are). When you have no info everyone must be a suspect.

[Hopscotcher]

I like this plan!

Vote Hopscotcher

[Stroop]

I like this plan!

Vote Hopscotcher

I'll just have to go along with this then...

unvote vote Hopscotcher

[sully800]

wow guys, really? you wanted day 2 to end that quickly?

I know I brought up the original accusation, but I would much rather have some discussion and interrogation rather than a 1 page lynch-fest. If Hopscotcher turns out to be town then I am 99% sure Stroop is scum...

[sully800]

Actually, I'm still pretty pissed about this, even if I'm correct about Hopscotcher. Here is all of Day 2:

wca added nothing with his post.

Stroop makes an argument against me, as I expected him to

I make a really long post with as much detail as I can gather.

Hopscotcher votes for himself.

Stroop changes his mind about me, agrees with me and lynches hopscotcher. He BETTER be mafia, or you have made a pretty dumb mistake Stroop. (or actually, I guess it means that you are mafia. we kill a townie, and then a townie is killed in the night. That leaves 3 people tomorrow, 2 of whom are mafia).

To anyone: If you are a townie with some sort of power and you can kill stroop you better do it. Because otherwise I think he just ended the game, in part due to Hopscotcher voting for himself.

[sully800]

Before we here the verdict, I would like to call that Stroop and wca are the scum in this game

[wcaclimbing]

I like this plan!

Vote Hopscotcher

as long as you want us to...

vote hopscotcher



sully, hopscotcher, stroop, and wca.
That makes a lynch.

[Stroop]

It was probably already a lynch, but since Ace got on yet didn't post the scene it didn't feel right posting a victory post yet (I thought he might hesitate about what to do with Hop's vote).

I make a really long post with as much detail as I can gather.

I'm sorry that we made your efforts useless

Hopscotcher votes for himself.

But this ruined it for you. Hopscotcher made the town lose by doing this

Before we here the verdict, I would like to call that Stroop and wca are the scum in this game