Which do you think best reflects reality: dice, no dice?

[ironbuttaxe]

Also cards. The obvious answer would be no dice and no cards.

[wcaclimbing]

flat rate (but every bonus for cards is +4)
and dice that would have a smaller effect.

Cause there still is randomness in war, and people can bring out reinforcements (cards), but that never has a huge effect on the war. just a small one.

[TheBro]

Also cards. The obvious answer would be no dice and no cards.

If it is obvi no dice and obvi no cards, why is there a thread on it?

I would have to say dice and flat rate. There have been wars that a nation(or a pathetic self proclaimed 'independent state') won their independence despite having huge odds against them. They even defended their independence in 1812. Of course, I'm not referring to a specific one, just throwing out numbers ya know?

[Fruitcake]

http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=43095