Conquer Club

Accused:

serialkiller74

The accused are suspected of:

Other: Ratings abuse


Game number(s):

n/a


Comments: Pretty obvious, he seems to have started more or less exclusivly to hand out really bad ratings, see:
http://www.conquerclub.com/player.php?mode=ratings2&username=serialkiller74

Apparently a classic 1's and 5's violation. Or so i've been told by KS.

the issue here might be, he only leaves ratings when it is negative so it appears he abuses it. He received double the amount he has left and almost all of those were good ratings. Had he left ratings for every player he has ever played, I think there would be atleast double than what he has left and alot of positives would be mixed in.

JOHNNYROCKET24 wrote:the issue here might be, he only leaves ratings when it is negative so it appears he abuses it.

Yup - like the Juventino ratings abuse case.

alstergren wrote:

JOHNNYROCKET24 wrote:the issue here might be, he only leaves ratings when it is negative so it appears he abuses it.

Yup - like the Juventino ratings abuse case.

I would recommend posting the link to that thread so it can be compared. I was just posting my observation of what I saw.

Either way, it's apparent he's been suffering from a mean streak with all the recent (and unjustified) 1s this guy hands out.

I've had a game with him, and he's a very vindictive player. Even though his ratings at first were decent and acceptable, his last two--and maybe three--pages are abusive.

JOHNNYROCKET24 wrote:

alstergren wrote:

JOHNNYROCKET24 wrote:the issue here might be, he only leaves ratings when it is negative so it appears he abuses it.

Yup - like the Juventino ratings abuse case.

I would recommend posting the link to that thread so it can be compared. I was just posting my observation of what I saw.

See:
http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=239&t=89553&hilit=juventino+rating#p2069316

(One has to go through the thread, this argument pops up.)

he does seem like he gives other rating other than 1 and fives though it alot fewer that
he gives 0ut the 1 and fives....I not 100 percent you cans say this is rating abuse,though I can see the case 4 it

I wondered why this hadn't been ruled upon yet.

Went to the ratings and lo and behold the only ratings are all 5 stars. If there were any 1 star ratings they have been deleted.

Is someone trying to hide something? LOL Only 5 stars are considered an abuse too.

jefjef wrote:I wondered why this hadn't been ruled upon yet.

Went to the ratings and lo and behold the only ratings are all 5 stars. If there were any 1 star ratings they have been deleted.

Is someone trying to hide something? LOL Only 5 stars are considered an abuse too.

Its being looked at, its 6 pages of all 5 stars.
We need to look through all of them to see if there are questionable ratings in there, the last and only one that was abuse for all 5 stars was easy cause it was very prevalent about having questionable ratings.

6 pages, game by game is taking time. It will hopefully be ruled upon shortly.

KS

king sam wrote:

jefjef wrote:I wondered why this hadn't been ruled upon yet.

Went to the ratings and lo and behold the only ratings are all 5 stars. If there were any 1 star ratings they have been deleted.

Is someone trying to hide something? LOL Only 5 stars are considered an abuse too.

Its being looked at, its 6 pages of all 5 stars.
We need to look through all of them to see if there are questionable ratings in there, the last and only one that was abuse for all 5 stars was easy cause it was very prevalent about having questionable ratings.

6 pages, game by game is taking time. It will hopefully be ruled upon shortly.

KS

Please don't mis understand. It looks as if serialkiller deleted all of his vindictive ratings is all I was saying.

jefjef wrote:Please don't mis understand. It looks as if serialkiller deleted all of his vindictive ratings is all I was saying.

Ohh.. got ya

king sam wrote:

jefjef wrote:Please don't mis understand. It looks as if serialkiller deleted all of his vindictive ratings is all I was saying.

Ohh.. got ya

Yup. That's it. The complaint concerned 1-1½ page or something with 1-1-1s. They appears to have been withdrawn. And with that, I see no reason to keep this thread open. I'm happier to see someone change such bad habit than a warning being handed out.

Hi all,

all i can say is i am sorry to have cause that much troubles with my rating that a gave,

the reason why i deleted all the bad rating was not to hide anything guys i just decide to leave the only the 5s there and delete the rest of them just to stop fighting about this rating thing,

and will not pay attention to rating anymore


cheers

serial

Giving only all 5 stars is also considered an abuse. Wonder how this is gonna turn out.

jefjef wrote:Giving only all 5 stars is also considered an abuse. Wonder how this is gonna turn out.

I believe that this is a simplification - at least what I recall, that was not the mod statement in that thread.

here we go...

i delete them all 1s and 5s and all the rest if that can make everyone happy!lol!!

i will not give anymore rating so it cut off the fight over this!

alstergren wrote:

jefjef wrote:Giving only all 5 stars is also considered an abuse. Wonder how this is gonna turn out.

I believe that this is a simplification - at least what I recall, that was not the mod statement in that thread.

Yes that is a simplification, it was more then just leaving all 5's in that case.

Serialkiller has been Warned for his previous infractions of ratings, there was a screenshot taken and provided to us that helped us in determining the validity of some of the ratings he left. Now seeing as they are all deleted and he plans not to rate anymore, or so he says, it wont matter. But his efforts in rating prior to this was against the ratings guidelines and he has been Warned.

KS

do you all go to bed and cry about your bad ratings or what in the world is wrong with getting 1* ratings? even calling it abuse? like you have been abused? shame on all you accusing this fine player of abuse.

an old saying goes: "accuse me once, shame on you"