D2 of The Reid technique Mafia Game

[SoN!c]

Critics of the Reid technique argue that its psychologically manipulative tactics can lead to false confessions, particularly from those with other secrets to hide, because the techniques are designed to make confession seem like the only way out of a hopeless situation. In interrogating a suspect, police often seek to extract an admission of guilt. Officers have found that deceit can be a remarkably effective tool in eliciting confessions from even the most hardened suspects.The most effective defense for unexperienced suspects against veteran Reid technique users is to remain silent and request an attorney immediately.

Limit Your Talking: One of the most common mistakes is talking too much. Keep answers concise, and avoid volunteering unnecessary information.
Stay Calm and Composed: The technique is designed to increase your stress and anxiety to break your resolve. Remaining calm and composed can help you think clearly.

[SoN!c]

Ofcourse seasoned Reid suspects will spinning it around their finger and be like this is too easy

[Devante]

Extreme (or anyone)

Have you ever encountered a town role that has conditions attached which include not being able to claim the role?

Checking mafia wiki a backup is such a role possibly and usually dictated to have conditions. Easily searched and in no way violates spoken dictions….

[Loose Canon]

A backup that cannot say they are a backup?

When everything is pointing (to me) that you were trying to evade making a claim D1 (for fear of what you could get yourself into), and therefore got yourself into trouble by fulfilling a make a claim condition.

I think or wildly speculate you can't be night killed but as a balance to that have to make a claim when in L-1 or 2 scenario.

[Devon99]

Devon, do you have anything you can add to help town? You've been on for a couple days now but haven't really added anything and king did state he had a pr that could be helpful

Could being the operative word. Conditions have not been met.

[halrob64]

by Loose Canon » Mon Nov 10, 2025 3:23 am

A backup that cannot say they are a backup?

What do you mean by backup Loose?
I'm seeing it as 2 people who have roles that are on alternate days and the days they are not using their power role to help town might be days that they become villains, Jekyll and Hyde
Just a thought but what do I know?

[Extreme Ways]

Extreme (or anyone)

Have you ever encountered a town role that has conditions attached which include not being able to claim the role?

Yes, but with a lot milder punishment. Usually it's "if you claim anything related to your role, you will become vanilla town"

[Loose Canon]

A nurse is a backup
A deputy is a backup

I've seen both of the above in prior games.

Devante are you claiming a form of backup?

[halrob64]

https://hero.fandom.com/wiki/Chief_Clan ... coffee.png

[halrob64]

https://simpsons.fandom.com/wiki/Lou?file=Lou.png
Which one is the chief Dev or Devon?

[Charle]

If Dev and Devon are linked to each other by alternative days the same role, then surely we should have a result from N1 whatever it was? Unless it is a vigilante role (not scum) who were responsible for King's death? If that is the case, they should be very careful who they choose to kill, as it can be seriously disadvantaged to Town if we loose more important roles.

[halrob64]

It may be that Dev and Devon are not linked it could be EW and Devon
Dev has made no claim for N1, EW sort of claimed by declaring knowledge that Charle did not kill N1
I'm following up on King who claimed town cop but maybe vanilla or not on alternate nights.
Devon says he may have information that can help town but criteria not met so that has whatever bearing it has.
Maybe there is no link, maybe we have a part time town cop?
So at the moment there is not much help for town folk from the investigative side unless I'm not bright enough to read between the lines.
If Loose is right that someone cannot be killed at night and that person is Dev, then that may point to the need to Lynch but I don't have a clear enough perspective to go down that route.

[Loose Canon]

Halrob I think I almost agree except not Devon and EW, but Devante and EW are the most likely to be linked - that is assuming that Devante is 3P.
A lot to me would fit including (but not exclusively EW thinking he might be linked)

There's a lot of what I could be accused of tunnelling here - I prefer to call it prospecting ( although its usually the support industries (good time girls, bars and hardware suppliers) not the gold prospectors themselves that ended up making money from goldrushes.)

I think Strike (Mafia) , 3P (Devante) and Townie with Power were linked.
With Strike down I think we/town have 3P to thank for that. Thank you 3P (Devante), but if so 3P you may be of no more use to town so thank you and goodbye.
I think a link between 3P and power townie still exists currently.
I did think power townie would die if 3P was lynched.
That might still be so, but it might also be the case that power townie doesn't die but just gets vanillaised (providing that isn't me, and I don't think it is, I prefer to think of it has having his balls cut off).

For the thought of Devante/Lecter firstly eating Strike's brain, and then as a passing swipe Castrating a Townie (but not me) (but with the very large community sword - and I'm wondering if Strike didn't have knowledge of the set up when he speculated on the Sword) ;
That's surely got to be (for comedy's sake) worth a lynch on Devante just in case.

Grab your balls guys (while you still have them) Lynch Devante.

[Devante]

Halrob I think I almost agree except not Devon and EW, but Devante and EW are the most likely to be linked - that is assuming that Devante is 3P.
A lot to me would fit including (but not exclusively EW thinking he might be linked)

There's a lot of what I could be accused of tunnelling here - I prefer to call it prospecting ( although its usually the support industries (good time girls, bars and hardware suppliers) not the gold prospectors themselves that ended up making money from goldrushes.)

I think Strike (Mafia) , 3P (Devante) and Townie with Power were linked.
With Strike down I think we/town have 3P to thank for that. Thank you 3P (Devante), but if so 3P you may be of no more use to town so thank you and goodbye.
I think a link between 3P and power townie still exists currently.
I did think power townie would die if 3P was lynched.
That might still be so, but it might also be the case that power townie doesn't die but just gets vanillaised (providing that isn't me, and I don't think it is, I prefer to think of it has having his balls cut off).

For the thought of Devante/Lecter firstly eating Strike's brain, and then as a passing swipe Castrating a Townie (but not me) (but with the very large community sword - and I'm wondering if Strike didn't have knowledge of the set up when he speculated on the Sword) ;
That's surely got to be (for comedy's sake) worth a lynch on Devante just in case.

Grab your balls guys (while you still have them) Lynch Devante.

I've given up trying to reason with your senseless tunneling Loose, worse then my youngest kid fixating over made up nonsense. Go ahead and lynch if you want but I've laid out things as best I can and would rather town lose one townie then forcing a claim out of me and losing two

[Loose Canon]

So you are saying again that another town dies if you are lynched.

The other town needs to save you then if that is true.

Any other such town who thinks you might be right has to consider

1. How you got both of you in that predicament from D1.
2. The counter argument of 3 fates intertwined.
3. That a claim kills 2 town is unprecedented
4. That if all that fails and in the case of uncertainty there is a 1 in 8 chance house odds that you are 3p

[Devante]

So you are saying again that another town dies if you are lynched.

The other town needs to save you then if that is true.

Any other such town who thinks you might be right has to consider

1. How you got both of you in that predicament from D1.
2. The counter argument of 3 fates intertwined.
3. That a claim kills 2 town is unprecedented
4. That if all that fails and in the case of uncertainty there is a 1 in 8 chance house odds that you are 3p

Well LC:Lord of Chaos here we go again. Not what I’ve said and not what I have said at any point. You continue to grab snippets and using posts to continue your agenda without keeping the proper context.

Look at what Sonic said when I was about to claim and he reminded me about the conditions I have with my town PR. Look at everything I have posted since and it is all very easily laid out. Now the rest of town watch this ongoing exchange as it is evident the selective reading and posting from our lord of chaos is not done by accident, a newer player perhaps but not our good old LC.

So when I am lynched and flip town then pending of course on night events then D3 needs to be a LC lynch. If sonic went the way of last game then 3p cannot be night killed but must be lynched. Of course scum could take a shot but why stoop Loose from continuing to spread mayhem.

I will be voting for myself in a day or two and moving forward with this plan. Before I do I have a few thoughts on scum possibles but want to go back and read their posts then will post my observations and self vote.

Good day sir

[Charle]

Funny enough, I actually believe Devante. My focus has now changed. Kingm claimed cop alternative nights. Devon had the chance to defend that by either tell us what was the verdict on N1, or letting Doctor know to protect him on N2 so we can get some info out of that. Nothing happened and I am going back to our suspicion D1 that Devon is guilty, it can be Mafia or 3P, but not town. Maybe he has a Mafia cop role of some sort?

Unvote

Vote Devon

[Ragian]

Vote Charle

[Devante]

unvote LC Vote Charle

[SoN!c]

Official vote count:


Devante: (2) Loose Canon, Hjelp
Charle: (2) Devante, Ragian
Devon: (1) Charle



With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch!


Deadline D2 is set at November 17th 19:57:59 PM NEW YORK TIME ZONE.

Shocking murder events have marked November 17th across history, each leaving a distinct and unsettling cultural imprint.
The most infamous of these came in 1957, when police entered Ed Gein’s isolated Wisconsin farmhouse and discovered evidence of grave robbing and murder that would profoundly influence American horror fiction.
Realizing the extent of the crimes, investigators reported objects fashioned from human remains and signs that Gein had attempted to construct what he called a “woman suit.”
It was a case so disturbing that it inspired characters like Norman Bates, Leatherface, and Buffalo Bill across film and literature.
Known crimes of November 17th are not limited to the 20th century, however.
Earlier, in 1795, the hanging of William Smith in Sydney became notorious both for its brutality and for the public’s reaction to what many saw as a disproportionate punishment for petty burglary.
When we move forward again to November 17th, 1971, we encounter the Alphabet Murders —an unresolved series of killings in which each young victim’s name shared initials with the town they were found in.
Observers noted that the pattern of initials suggested deliberate selection, elevating the case into one of the era’s most haunting unsolved mysteries as ach victim was killed in a similar method, and their bodies were discarded in or near a town or village whose name began with the same letter as the victim’s names.
Legend and true crime documentation continue to revisit each of these dates, examining how they shaped collective fears and public memory.
From the rural farmhouse to the colonial scaffold to the quiet neighborhoods, November 17th remains a date marked by chilling history.

show

[halrob64]

I must admit Devon's silence is strange mind you, I wonder if there are any innocent parties in this game, maybe all the towns folk have a dark secret and are afraid to step outside the door

[halrob64]

a Lynch fest!! Hang Em High

[halrob64]

I don't see we are going to apply any pressure with 3 candidates for lynching.
Ragian ref Charle I don't see any evidence/thoughts from Ragian
Devon I don't see a reason to lynch at this point but needs to say more.
Loose has ants in his pants ref Devante, I'm not sure about all the Hannibal stuff/brain eating etc, sounds like the tight lycra could be cutting off circulation to the brain there.
EW and Darian very quiet, Darian in particular.
Devante you do worry me with your partial claims.
But when you look for clues you see Strike and EW so I'm going to go for an EW lynch
Lynch EW

[Charle]

With EW's vote I am probably on L-2. So let me claim before i got hammered.

I am the Town Cop, hence my suspicion on Devon as there seems to be a lot of investigating roles claimed. N1 i investigated Halrob and the verdict came back his is Town. I hoped that I could do it another night, but I guess I am now on the chopping block. If doc can save me, let's hope Mafia do not have blockers. I think it is best for town that I revealed this, before I got hammered.

[halrob64]

Deadline D2 is set at November 17th 19:57:59 PM NEW YORK TIME ZONE.

Shocking murder events have marked November 17th across history, each leaving a distinct and unsettling cultural imprint.
The most infamous of these came in 1957, when police entered Ed Gein’s isolated Wisconsin farmhouse and discovered evidence of grave robbing and murder that would profoundly influence American horror fiction.
Realizing the extent of the crimes, investigators reported objects fashioned from human remains and signs that Gein had attempted to construct what he called a “woman suit.”
It was a case so disturbing that it inspired characters like Norman Bates, Leatherface, and Buffalo Bill across film and literature.
Known crimes of November 17th are not limited to the 20th century, however.
Earlier, in 1795, the hanging of William Smith in Sydney became notorious both for its brutality and for the public’s reaction to what many saw as a disproportionate punishment for petty burglary.
When we move forward again to November 17th, 1971, we encounter the Alphabet Murders —an unresolved series of killings in which each young victim’s name shared initials with the town they were found in.
Observers noted that the pattern of initials suggested deliberate selection, elevating the case into one of the era’s most haunting unsolved mysteries as ach victim was killed in a similar method, and their bodies were discarded in or near a town or village whose name began with the same letter as the victim’s names.
Legend and true crime documentation continue to revisit each of these dates, examining how they shaped collective fears and public memory.
From the rural farmhouse to the colonial scaffold to the quiet neighborhoods, November 17th remains a date marked by chilling history.

Your views on this Charle?