D2 of The Reid technique Mafia Game

by **Charle** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 3:54 am

I am with EW in this one. Just claiming PR is just an easy way to get out of a situation. We are going to need more than that to work with, and if it is real, then as a PR would have given some result last night.

Vote Devante

by **SoN!c** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 4:01 am

Official vote count:

Devante: (3) EW, Hjelp, Charle

Devante is at L-2

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch!

by **halrob64** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 4:18 am

Strike was silent for a good part of the game, I didn't like his responses to jhelp in particular and called him out as scum, after that he made a couple of eloquent posts about the game and I didn't pursue it.
I think you backed him Loose? Not an accusation but a question?
I am suspicious of you Charle you have also been silent through most of the game but quick to call for a lynch on Dev.
EW maybe you know more than you are letting on?
There are not many of us left in reality, it was carnage last night. So I am assuming 2 mafia and the town nutter/Hannibal
We can call on Dev and force a full claim, but what if...he does have a pr town role, that could be falling into the mafia game plan and maybe mafia at the moment pushing the lynching?
Just thoughts

by **Loose Canon** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 4:37 am

I had question marks over strike D1, but opposite direction marks to those of others who said they suspected him.

The question marks I had over strike were also outweigh ed by those I had over rag.

by **halrob64** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 4:43 am

Yeah I get that, that was the way I went too. Fiendish minds at work!

by **Extreme Ways** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 4:54 am

halrob64 wrote:Strike was silent for a good part of the game, I didn't like his responses to jhelp in particular and called him out as scum, after that he made a couple of eloquent posts about the game and I didn't pursue it.
I think you backed him Loose? Not an accusation but a question?
I am suspicious of you Charle you have also been silent through most of the game but quick to call for a lynch on Dev.
EW maybe you know more than you are letting on?
There are not many of us left in reality, it was carnage last night. So I am assuming 2 mafia and the town nutter/Hannibal
We can call on Dev and force a full claim, but what if...he does have a pr town role, that could be falling into the mafia game plan and maybe mafia at the moment pushing the lynching?
Just thoughts

You're not wrong, but you're also not quite right either.

As for the condition Dev is "accursed with" - it might be some weird Lovers thing. It makes most sense as town to have that but either way we need some clarity from Dev I think.

Dev doesnt seem to be surprised to have survived.

by **Ragian** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 6:17 am

Fine, let's jump down Devante's hole

@Loose, I wavered because I had ignored all the stuff that Son!c had written in the thread, thinking it was the usual drunk stuff that doesn't need my very limited brain power. I think I asked several times why Devante hadn't claimed because I think it sets a shite precedent for the rest of the game (kindergarten logic). Dev then reiterated why he couldn't claim. Sheesh, one time I win as 3P, and you're on my case all games thereafter. Mean!

I've now read it a bit more carefully now, and it's fairly logical to see that Dev has a twin (for lack of a better word) in the game. There's someone else there. I just wonder if a) Dev knows who it is, b) Dev knows the alignment of that person, and c) if Dev is able to talk about it.

Everybody voting, hold your horses. It's early D2 and we can talk before hanging someone without due process. I didn't like Charle's vote. It came off opportunist and piggybacky. EGMEOY, Charle!

by **Ragian** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 6:19 am

Oh, EW suggests a Lover role, I see. Makes sense.

Furthermore, the cop in the game (must be one...otherwise framer is dumb) should NOT reveal themselves D2 unless it's with a guilty verdict.

by **Ragian** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 6:19 am

And bear in mind that framing happens before killing, so Strike way well have framed someone before getting poisoned.

by **halrob64** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 6:27 am

Charle is the Elavator Killer only my personal opinion

by **Loose Canon** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 6:52 am

Sorry but I just don't see lover.

Jailor yes going along Hannibal lecter lines, and I'm reading jailor as being ok if Devante is lynched.
Just not if Devante spells things out.

I've decided not to vote Devante yet, he needs to digest (strike/accusation)

Also we have time till Devon joins who may after all have N1 info he has inherited from king as so may elect to share?

by **halrob64** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 7:02 am

I'm not lynching yet we need to hear more from Charle and Devon

by **Ragian** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 7:07 am

Happy days. What do you want to hear from Charle, halrob?

by **halrob64** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 7:15 am

He is an experienced game player so any opinion at the moment would be helpful to me

by **halrob64** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 7:35 am

Also curious why you didn't ask me what I wanted to hear from Devon Rag? As I had mentioned him in the same post.
Just asking like

by **Ragian** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 7:41 am

halrob64 wrote:Also curious why you didn't ask me what I wanted to hear from Devon Rag? As I had mentioned him in the same post.
Just asking like

Thought it obvious that you want to hear from the new player just entering the game. What you want out of Charle is contingent. Do you feel that he hasn't said enough? Are you indicating that he is non-committal? That sort of stuff, mate.

by **halrob64** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 8:10 am

Yes I am

by **Darin44** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 8:32 am

Loose Canon wrote:Sorry but I just don't see lover.

Jailor yes going along Hannibal lecter lines, and I'm reading jailor as being ok if Devante is lynched.
Just not if Devante spells things out.

I've decided not to vote Devante yet, he needs to digest (strike/accusation)

Also we have time till Devon joins who may after all have N1 info he has inherited from king as so may elect to share?

Kingm did say Devon now he was cop odd or even days